ina
been seeing the silly tiktoks & i was hungry in the neighborhood so i decided to stop by. really good food, i’ll definitely be back!! the employees were also super nice! there are only 3 tables so don’t expect to be able to dine in. as a ranch connoisseur & midwesterner, i approve of this ranch. the crust becomes inedible after reheating, i wouldn’t recommend buying extra for leftovers unless you wanna reheat it in the stove.
… moreGanzGnau Der
Came here because of their crazy Instagram Videos (you guys are nuts).
I‘m from Germany & they brought me all the way down to their Pizza Shop!
Best Crust i had in NY (had a lot).
Tasty Pizza, good Humor! Loved it.
… moreRose Bush
Do yourself right and visit this fine establishment. The pizza is fantastic and worth a multi-hour drive in freezing weather. Also, Happy National Pizza Day
… moreKira Pärn
Such a lovely, cozy pizza place. The service was fast, friendly and the guy taking our order was very patient & soft spoken. Pizza itself was delicious! Lots of good vegan and vegetarian options and they were well made. 10/10 !
… moreJeffery Lin (JLMusic)
Ordered the buffalo slice and a slice of non vegan vodka. The flavor hits you right away and it is absolutely amazing. 10/10 would recommend
… moreElissa Fountain
One of our favorite pizza spots! Love all the TMNT stuff on the walls. Very nostalgic. Also the pizza is solid and they always have lots of options! And the staff is friendly too!
… moreAlex A
Nice decor inside, staff were really friendly and chatty, pizza was lovely with a great variety of toppings
… moreNina
The pizza is really delicious and tastes very fresh. However, I hate to be that person, but I did notice a concern with sanitary practices. The young woman behind the counter (brown hair with bangs) handled the pizza by touching the crust and placing it in the oven, then proceeded to touch behind her ears, her hair, cash, and the counter without washing her hands. While I didn’t see what she touched beforehand, the lack of handwashing afterward raised concerns about food safety. I hope this can be addressed, as proper hygiene is important when handling food.
… moreAlex Gallind
The deep dish cut is amazing
Nice flavor not dry at all just the perfect smooth taste I love the amount of sauce.
I would highly recommend the the spicy pizza.
… moreDavid Kazak
Absolutely loved our visit to Vinnie’s Pizzeria! We tried the elote slice and the mozzarella sticks, and both were incredible. The elote slice was packed with flavor—loaded with sweet corn, creamy cheese, and just the right kick of spice. The mozzarella sticks were perfectly crispy on the outside, melty on the inside, and paired with their marinara sauce (which was seriously amazing) made them even better.
The vibe inside is super retro and cool—definitely a fun place to hang out. Just a heads up, there are only three tables, so seating is limited, but honestly, the food is so good it’s worth grabbing it to-go if you have to. Can’t wait to come back!
… more