Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1141 S Main St, Bellefontaine, OH 43311
Phone: (937) 210-5158
Website: http://www.vicariospizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Vicario’s Pizza
Authentic Italian Pizza and PastaAuthentic Italian Pizza and PastaAuthentic Italian Pizza and Pasta … Vicario’s Pizza. 1141 South Main Street, Bellefontaine, …
Menu – Vicario’s Pizza
Handcrafted Pizza for Every Occasion. Order Now. Copyright © 2026 Vicario’s Pizza – All Rights Reserved. Powered by. This website uses cookies.
Vicario’s Pizza & Pasta | Bellefontaine OH – Facebook
Vicario’s Pizza & Pasta , Bellefontaine. 1672 likes · 160 talking about this · 36 were here. Buckeye Family has teamed up with Vicario’s Pizza. Hours:…
Reviews
kim romine
We were staying in the area for the night. As we we’re checking Google for somewhere to get dinner this showed up. We thought we’d give it a try. The portions were huge and a great price. Everything tasted good. The sever was friendly. Would recommend if you’re ever in the area.
… moreTodd Johnson
Bar atmosphere, food was ok! Service was good! Pretzel bites were on point, cheese not so much.
… more59rammer61
Phones work randomly the online ordering system doesn’t work. The “breadsticks” and hotdog buns cut in half and don’t look good. The people own it better get control of the restaurant before they are forced to close it. I wish I could give negative rating.
… moreBrett Bender
Stopped in to grab a pizza on my way home. Great looking place. Had a great vibe. Wish I could have stayed for a drink but needed to bring the pizza home for the family. Pizza was excellent. Great sauce (Traditional), and lots of cheese. Definitely recommend grabbing a pizza from here.
… moreLee Lawrence
Food was overpriced garbage. “Breadsticks” are just hot dog buns cut in half sprinkled with some flavorless “seasoning”. Stromboli was cooked on the outside and cold on the inside and cheese wasn’t even melted. Waitress wasn’t even friendly didn’t ask if we wanted refills and had a attitude like we were bothering her. We will not be returning ever.
… moreGreg Wall
I ordered a pound of wings, got nine burnt wings. Also ordered a pep and mushroom French bread, only cheese on it. Also told 35 to 45 minutes delivery and a hour and 5 minutes. Food is room temp at best. This place was better at old location. Not even worth eating this food.
… moreChelsea Chapman
This was our first time here since the move. We decided to get hamburgers and fries and shared an order if mushrooms. We also ordered a pizza and pasta to go for our children. We were hesitant to order hamburgers from a pizza place but we are so glad we did. They were hands down one of the best burgers we have had in town. The mushrooms looked like an order for four! It was clean, the staff was friendly and all of our food was delicious. We will be back!
… moreTyler Watkins
Buckeye Pizza lost a lot of money putting any interest in this place. Ordered apps 20 mins before a pizza and a sub- apps came out the same time as the pizza and we never got the sub and the server still tried charging us for it. Place is cold as ice in 40 degree weather. Server never once came back to our table after serving food (30 minutes later.) “Do you need a refill?” Yeah, 25 minutes ago. There was only two tables in the restaurant and the server was behind the bar on her her phone the entire time.
… moreAngie Ferdinand
Tried pizza and appetizers today in Bellefontaine. Everything was delicious! Poppers with raspberry sauce, bread sticks with cheese sauce and marinara..so good! Pizza was cooked perfect and so good. We will definitely be back.
… moreDezirae Sea
First time eating here and hopefully not the last! Unfortunately I live about 5 hours away or I’d order at least every couple months! My bf has been coming here since he was little so it’s definitely a “local community pizza spot”. I see why he made it a necessary stop on our trip.
… more