Ryan Sanderson
Pizza was overall really great and well priced. Many different types of “by the slice” were ready to eat. I would give their cheese pizza a 3 star, as the sauce or cheese needs a kick but the 3 Cheese Chipotle Chicken pizza was a 4.5 star, as the crust and toppings were in perfect harmony. This place is worth a visit if you love pizza. The staff was very friendly too.
… moreMack Suleiman
Stopped by this place after walking through Skaneateles and it was an excellent decision! The service is great, I was helped almost immediately, even though it was lunch time and very busy in the place. I ordered the daily special (it was a wrap with corned beef, Russian sauce, lettuce, tomato, banana peppers and Swiss cheese). It blew me away! For under $9, I got a wrap packed with meat and veggies and cheese! I can confidently say that it’s one of the best sandwiches I have ever had! Everything just works together so well! I would strongly suggest this place for anyone looking for a hearty meal on the cheap!
… moreAmes “TheGoogleReviewer” PA
Food was excellent. Chicken salad 1/2 sandwich and a lamb gyro. Place was super busy, mostly for takeout. Staff were fine but not very friendly. Would definitely go again but would take the food and eat elsewhere for some ambiance.
… morePaul Harris
I live a 1 hour drive south and frequently drive up for awesome pizza by the slice, and enjoy them at the waterfront park across the street.
… moreV M
Coworkers and I were just raving about this place! Great pizzeria located right near the swimming area on the lake. Fast, friendly service. Staff was helpful and answered all my questions. Amazing slices, at incredible prices. I had the spicy buffalo wing and the garlic, both were delicious! Would definitely go back next time we’re in Skaneateles!
… moreTay Baker
Waited at the Byrne Dairy sub counter for about 8 minutes with none of the staff bothering to help. Left and went to Valentine’s where they immediately and with a nice positive attitude made me a great sandwich.
… moreA D
The staff is very friendly, but the pizza was quite oily. It’s an average pizza place, though they might have other menu items that are worth trying.
… moreRose Rafferty
Great pizza, quick service and reasonably priced. Perfect for a quick weeknight dinner.
… moreJessica Fernandez
The service was superb and the pizza is to die for. I recommend the sausage & pepperoni, buffalo wing, and waffle fries. I will definitely be back
… moreMary Maas
Having grown up in Skaneateles, when in town, stopping at Valenrines is a must. It brings back back memories. The pizzas haven’t changed, which is the reason we always go back! Thin, foldable, just the right amount of grease and delicious crust! It’s the best pizza we had in our week passing through, and we had 3 others! Maybe it’s the memories, maybe not!
… more