Nate Bernklau
It was good. Really good. Or in other words…
Umberto’s Pizza in Tulsa, OK, delivers a delightful culinary experience that marries traditional Italian craftsmanship with the fresh ingredients of Oklahoma’s heartland. The crust is a work of art: thin, crisp, and perfectly charred, it serves as the ideal canvas for the vibrant toppings that burst with flavor in every bite. With each slice, Umberto’s showcases a mastery of pizza-making that deserves high praise and a visit from any true pizza aficionado.
… moreDallas Harper
I’ve always wondered about this place bc it’s right beside the Walmart I go to and the building is super cute but it’s not for me! I got 2 slices of the veggie pizza, the crust tastes over cooked and then all the toppings are in the middle but they don’t taste cooked. Weird combination
… moreSerena Thornbrugh
I’ve been here a couple times now and I love the pizza here. It looks simple, but sometimes simple is all you need. I love that you can order by the slice and trust me, one slice will fill you up quite a bit. I also tried their calzone and it was the best I’ve ever had. The red sauce that comes with it is super tasty and they don’t skimp on the fillings. Definitely check this place out if you want no frills, quality NY style pizza.
… moreJoshua
Finally tried this local place. The pizza was delicious and outstanding. My love ordered the garlic knots and you can see they put like an entire can of minced garlic on it. We absolutely love garlic and this was wayyyyyy to much and ruined it. Pizza joint was cool but outside of ordering not much small talk or atmosphere building going on.
… moreTyler Ramirez
Been coming to this place for close to 15 years and I’m happy to say it’s always been the best pizza in town. The crust, cheese and sauce have so much flavor, you’d think you’re on the street in NYC having a slice. Everyone behind the counter is always friendly. 10/10 I’ll always be back
… moreSingletrack Rambler
Really good NY style pizza. I bought by the slice and really enjoyed it, even though it was reheated. The crust had a good chew/crunch ratio and the sauce was not too sweet. They also are not shy with the toppings. The guy next to me had a calzone that looked really good. I think if I would have ordered a whole pie fresh it would have been an easy 5 stars. Worth noting that the prices and service we’re also really good.
… moreMary Thompson
DISCLAIMER: I’m honored to be a Top 10 Reviewer for Google. I do my best to be fair and honest but realize your experience may differ from mine. So, please keep that in mind when considering this restaurant, establishment, and/or venue. REVIEW:. Very good New York style pizza. We ordered a 12″ Supreme and had enough for two people plus took two slices home for later. Dined inside where they have 14 tables and self-service Coke products. You order at the counter and they bring it to your table. They have 6 pizza sizes to choose from for any sized appetite! The pizza was very good but the restaurant wasn’t real clean, especially by the fountain drinks area. I’m a stickler for cleanliness so when I see filth in the lobby, I can’t help but wonder if the kitchen area is the same. For that reason I’m not sure I’ll be returning.
… morePama
The pizza quality is excellent however if you “add” toppings don’t expect a lot …. I ordered a half cheese half pepperoni and found 4 pepperoni hidden under the cheese. Tasted great but it won’t be loaded if you’re expecting that.
… moreSherrie Wallace
Have tried Umberto’s (31st & Harvard, Tulsa, OK) a few times before & it was pretty good, almost but not quite delicious….today, however was not it….pretty bad experience for me! The pizza was edible but greasy, the over abundance of the toppings both meat & veggie were not cooked through at all. I like a bit of bite to my veggies but for them to be almost completely uncooked is unreal. The crust was more than a bit soggy making the slice very limp to the point of not holding up to the toppings…can you say, “Give me a bib!” At $7 +tip a slice this was just not it for me….doubt I’ll give them another shot after this.
… moreSwati Nemade
One of the best pizza places in Tulsa. It’s a small diner style quick bite restaurant with friendly staff and clean facility. Pizza crust is really super tasty made to perfection. They made Jalapeno pineapple pizza for the first time and still it was made the best way. The calzone and marinara was equally good. The ingredients for pizza were good quality. Also I loved eating my food sitting next to the curvy mirror wall.
… more