Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Mellow Italian eatery featuring a wide range of classic red-sauce fare, plus gourmet pies & subs.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 4207 Oregon Pike, Ephrata, PA 17522
Phone: (717) 859-5444
Website: http://ordertwocousinspizzamenu.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Two Cousins Pizza Ephrata
To Help Reward Our Community For Eating Local, We Are Excited To Give Away A FREE LARGE CHEESE PIZZA Every Friday To A lucky winner!
Two Cousins Pizza Brownstown – Ephrata, PA – 4207 Oregon Pike …
Two Cousin’s Special Pizza Pepperoni, ham, sausage, bacon, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, black olives & extra cheese. $12.99
Two Cousins Pizza Ephrata – View Menu & Order Online – Slice
Sicilian Gourmet Brick Oven Pizza · Sicilian Bacon Cheese Fries Pizza · Sicilian Buffalo Chicken Pizza · Sicilian Two Cousins Supreme Pizza · Sicilian Meat Lovers …
Reviews
Katie Sciotti
Food is terrible. Most of the food tasted frozen and reheated. Meatballs weren’t anything to speak about and bland. Steak quesadillas came out and the steak was still pink. I ordered a slice of spanako which is supposed to be a white pizza with tomatoes, spinach, and feta. It came out on a cheese pizza with red sauce. Just not a good experience at all. The young lady behind the counter was nice enough though. Restaurant was clean. It’s a shame the food wasn’t good. Respectfully, we won’t be back.
Edit to the owners reply: then your staff shouldn’t have offered white pizza slices. And your food does taste frozen but if it’s not then I guess that’s even worse considering….
… moreEdit to the owners reply: then your staff shouldn’t have offered white pizza slices. And your food does taste frozen but if it’s not then I guess that’s even worse considering….
James Butta
Been here a few times. Never had any complaints with the food.
Customer service is also good from my experiences. My most recent visit, I ordered two different pizzas and was given two pizzas with the same toppings.. so that was a bit annoying. With it being holiday season, i didn’t have time or the energy to go back and see if they could or would help me but things happen.
Edit: (after they responded to me)
I did originally give this a 3 out of 5 stars which isn’t awful by any means though I do understand every business wants a 5 star rating.
I didn’t complain about the customer service or the food in my original review as you can see ^^^
… but since it feels like your response was an attack to me… here goes…
Yes I did have the 20-30 seconds as I left to take pictures of your establishment. If you or anyone cares to look, you would see that I have reviewed hundreds of places and have millions of views (yes, plural) Which means my reviews seem to stand out and make a difference.
I was taking pictures to help give anybody my insight and hopefully help them make a decision on if they would like to eat at this establishment… which is why this feature was created.
Looking through some of your reviews within the last year, I see whom ever this is (I assume Gio the owner) seems to lash back at anyone who doesn’t praise him or this place.. sir… I gave a three star review and stated that I didn’t have a problem with service or food.. but since we’re here.. as you can see in my pictures.. both pizzas look very similar.. I did end up trying a slice of each and one tasted like sausage. The other (meatball) didn’t really taste like anything. No taste.
To quote you in one of your reviews sir, “how you approach a situation will determine the outcome”
If you simply would have responded with courtesy and respect I would have changed my review and probably raised the stars.
Here’s an idea to avoid any confusion. USE ACTUAL MEATBALLS. Who blames the customer for their distaste.. well Gio from two cousins in Brownstown does. The meatballs were tasteless regardless.
The other Two Cousins in Ephrata on main st is much better anyway. I’ve spoken to the owner and employees and he’s never been insulting or made me feel negative. There is also zero confusion when it comes to toppings and the crust actually has some crisp to it too!
Here’s a business tip: don’t lash out at your customers or ever utter “ppl like you are what is wrong with this world (his response to a different customer” and note that sometimes it’s best to just take it on the chin and keep moving…. ORRRR… as I stated, just respond with courtesy and respect yourself, as you seem to preach and maybe the reviewer will feel happy and upgrade their review instead of downgrading it and letting the millions (AND {MILLIONSSSS} of people know.
… moreCustomer service is also good from my experiences. My most recent visit, I ordered two different pizzas and was given two pizzas with the same toppings.. so that was a bit annoying. With it being holiday season, i didn’t have time or the energy to go back and see if they could or would help me but things happen.
Edit: (after they responded to me)
I did originally give this a 3 out of 5 stars which isn’t awful by any means though I do understand every business wants a 5 star rating.
I didn’t complain about the customer service or the food in my original review as you can see ^^^
… but since it feels like your response was an attack to me… here goes…
Yes I did have the 20-30 seconds as I left to take pictures of your establishment. If you or anyone cares to look, you would see that I have reviewed hundreds of places and have millions of views (yes, plural) Which means my reviews seem to stand out and make a difference.
I was taking pictures to help give anybody my insight and hopefully help them make a decision on if they would like to eat at this establishment… which is why this feature was created.
Looking through some of your reviews within the last year, I see whom ever this is (I assume Gio the owner) seems to lash back at anyone who doesn’t praise him or this place.. sir… I gave a three star review and stated that I didn’t have a problem with service or food.. but since we’re here.. as you can see in my pictures.. both pizzas look very similar.. I did end up trying a slice of each and one tasted like sausage. The other (meatball) didn’t really taste like anything. No taste.
To quote you in one of your reviews sir, “how you approach a situation will determine the outcome”
If you simply would have responded with courtesy and respect I would have changed my review and probably raised the stars.
Here’s an idea to avoid any confusion. USE ACTUAL MEATBALLS. Who blames the customer for their distaste.. well Gio from two cousins in Brownstown does. The meatballs were tasteless regardless.
The other Two Cousins in Ephrata on main st is much better anyway. I’ve spoken to the owner and employees and he’s never been insulting or made me feel negative. There is also zero confusion when it comes to toppings and the crust actually has some crisp to it too!
Here’s a business tip: don’t lash out at your customers or ever utter “ppl like you are what is wrong with this world (his response to a different customer” and note that sometimes it’s best to just take it on the chin and keep moving…. ORRRR… as I stated, just respond with courtesy and respect yourself, as you seem to preach and maybe the reviewer will feel happy and upgrade their review instead of downgrading it and letting the millions (AND {MILLIONSSSS} of people know.
Steven Sexton
Nice little local pizza place. Pizza was good not great. My wife liked the spaghetti but didn’t like the meatball. The prices were good.
… moreJennifer Stancliff
My husband and I have been searching for 3 years for a good Sicilian pizza since we moved to Rothsville. We found it! Two Cousins in brownstown did and excellent job. We loved our pepperoni Sicilian pizza. Definitely will be going again.
… moreserge
I am from west coast Washington state traveling in the east. I have ate at our highest quality pizza spots. And with full honesty I confidently say that this pizza is the best thing I have tried. Two Cousins Pizza have made the cheese, the dough and sauce into the happiest marriage I will ever witness. The high end pizza parlors in the west coast have nothing on you guys. Right on, I’m sad that I cannot stay and eat more pizza. However I will come back!
… moreJustin Stauffer
The girl behind the counter was very helpful, and the pizza was great.
… moreJennifer Hammonds
This was our first time trying Two Cousins. The sauce was excellent and they didn’t skimp on the toppings! We will definitely be going back! ❤
… morerick S
Two Cousins was recommended to me by a fellow coworker. He spoke extremely highly of them. I’m not usually a pizza lover but now when I order anything Italian sandwiches, pizza or otherwise I go to Two Cousins. Very very good!!!
… moreJackie Eisenbise-Ross
Heads up, if you want italian sausge. Placed an order for fettuccine alfredo with a side of sausage (along with other entrees, sandwiches and sides). In the restaurant’s defense, sausage is listed as just “sausage” under their sides menu. Never assume! Our assumption was that we were getting Italian sausage. Silly us, thiking we would be getting Italian sausage, ordering sauasaga at an Italian pizza place. What we got was a container of 4 breakfast links in a puddle of alfredo sauce. While the rest of the food was fine, that was kind of gross.
In reply to the establishment’s reponse: It wasn’t the sauce that was the problem, it was the breakfast sausage. As for availability(since you mentioned “I can’t even get it myself”), Costco always carries Primo Italian sausage or Dutchway (so close to your restaurant) always has some in their meat case. Maybe not top of the line, like found at Nonna Rosa’s, but a much better choice than breakfast links.
… moreIn reply to the establishment’s reponse: It wasn’t the sauce that was the problem, it was the breakfast sausage. As for availability(since you mentioned “I can’t even get it myself”), Costco always carries Primo Italian sausage or Dutchway (so close to your restaurant) always has some in their meat case. Maybe not top of the line, like found at Nonna Rosa’s, but a much better choice than breakfast links.
Becky
First time eating at this Two Cousins. We got a pepperoni pizza and buffalo chicken pizza. They were delicious. It’s been hard finding buffalo chicken pizza we really like- this one is good. We don’t like close by, so I may need to make a drive to come back. Thank you!!
… more