Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1200 Periwinkle Way, Sanibel, FL 33957
Phone: (239) 966-7654
Website: https://tuttipazzisanibel.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: toasttab.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Tutti Pazzi Italian Kitchen | Italian Restaurant in Sanibel, FL
Private Events. Let us host your next event. Inquire Now. Visit Us. Sanibel Island, FL. OPEN EVERY DAY FOR DINNER. Full Menu Available from 4 pm to 9 …
Menus | Tutti Pazzi Italian Kitchen in Sanibel, FL
See the menus for Tutti Pazzi Italian Kitchen in Sanibel, FL. Offering pasta, pizza, seafood, and wine.
Hours & Location | Tutti Pazzi Italian Kitchen in Sanibel, FL
Visit Tutti Pazzi Italian Kitchen in Sanibel, FL at 1200 Periwinkle Way. Open Wednesday – Monday from 11 am – 7:30 pm.
Reviews
Jake
We went to Tutti Pazzi on a Saturday night at around 7:00 PM and the restaurant was fairly crowded.
Our waitress (Leah) was extremely friendly and very on top of it.
We had high hopes after they brought the fresh baked bread and olives out (these were wonderful).
We ordered salads, and there was so little dressing on the Caesar salad, that it looked like there wasn’t dressing on the salad at all.
When the dishes came out, they looked as if they would have a ton of flavor; however, there was a lot left to be desired. I’m one to almost never use salt and pepper, and even I was reaching for the shakers.
Additionally, there was karaoke, which I find bizarre for an Italian restaurant on a Saturday night, even if it is on an island.
… moreOur waitress (Leah) was extremely friendly and very on top of it.
We had high hopes after they brought the fresh baked bread and olives out (these were wonderful).
We ordered salads, and there was so little dressing on the Caesar salad, that it looked like there wasn’t dressing on the salad at all.
When the dishes came out, they looked as if they would have a ton of flavor; however, there was a lot left to be desired. I’m one to almost never use salt and pepper, and even I was reaching for the shakers.
Additionally, there was karaoke, which I find bizarre for an Italian restaurant on a Saturday night, even if it is on an island.
EmaLee Harmon
Tutti Pazzi was only 4 minutes from our resort, and we’re so glad we went! The atmosphere was lovely. The veiws from the second floor as the sun set were beautiful! Food was full of flavor and the tiramisu was amazing! Definitely recommend the margarita pizza!
… moreP Oneliv
Easily accessible from the Main Road Periwinkle Way, plenty of free parking including for Handicap accessible Vehicles. The Restaurant was clean and well staffed by friendly employees. Restrooms were available and also clean.
The Menu has something for everyone, including Children.
Our Food was prepared as requested and the portions were more than ample.
The Drinks as well were Perfect.
The Deserts and after Dinner drinks were Great!
The Prices in our opinion were more than Fair.
The Staff were wearing some Super Shirts, which are also available for purchase, good Stuff.
Our Waitress Gabby was excellent!
… moreThe Menu has something for everyone, including Children.
Our Food was prepared as requested and the portions were more than ample.
The Drinks as well were Perfect.
The Deserts and after Dinner drinks were Great!
The Prices in our opinion were more than Fair.
The Staff were wearing some Super Shirts, which are also available for purchase, good Stuff.
Our Waitress Gabby was excellent!
M J
Delicious meals and appetizer. Live music on Wednesday nights. Guy played the piano and sang. Loved that. Personable waiter. Only downside was that he didn’t notice when we were ready to leave for a while. Other than that, he was great.
… moreKate O
Have gone to Tutti Pazzi for the last two nights in a row! The food is exceptional, some of the best on the island in my opinion.
I strongly recommend their bruschetta & pizza margherita. I’ve also had both their fusili vodka pasta & the rigatoni arrabbiatta , both were scrumptious (although the rigatoni may be spicy to some folks!)
There is always a live musician playing which really gives great ambience. It can get busy though, so either call ahead or make a reservation!
… moreI strongly recommend their bruschetta & pizza margherita. I’ve also had both their fusili vodka pasta & the rigatoni arrabbiatta , both were scrumptious (although the rigatoni may be spicy to some folks!)
There is always a live musician playing which really gives great ambience. It can get busy though, so either call ahead or make a reservation!
Leah Stehula
We were very impressed! Delicious, high quality, authentic Italian food, and friendly staff. We got to chat with the owner, and it was awesome to hear his passion and Italian history. Also loved the touch of the live music the evening we were dining there!
… moreD Newman
If you are looking for an authentic Italian experience on Sanibel that combines high-end professionalism with the heart of a family kitchen, look no further than Tutti Pazzi.
Our corporate team recently had the pleasure of hosting a private dinner here, and the experience was nothing short of spectacular. They actually closed down the entire restaurant just for our group, providing an intimate and exclusive atmosphere that made our evening feel incredibly special.
Tutti Pazzi stands out for their exceptional service. Despite the large group, the service was seamless. They strategically placed friendly, professional servers at every station to ensure no one was ever waiting. There were multiple stations on each floor so that people who made themselves comfortbale upstairs, didn’t have to go downstairs to get their meal.
We appreciated their personal touch! As a small family-owned gem, they don’t just “serve” you, they welcome you. We truly felt like part of their warm extended family from the moment we walked in. There was a entertainer who normally performs there on Tuesdays, and he was great! His music selection appealed to everyone in our group.
You can taste the quality in every bite of their fresh and flavorful food. The cold antipasto spread was a massive hit, fresh, vibrant, and perfectly curated. Every dish that followed was clearly prepared to order with top-tier ingredients.
It’s rare to find a place that can handle a full team event while maintaining the soul and quality of a cozy neighborhood trattoria.
Whether you are planning a large team gathering or just want a delicious, authentic meal, I cannot recommend Tutti Pazzi enough. Thank you to the whole team for making us feel so at home!
… moreOur corporate team recently had the pleasure of hosting a private dinner here, and the experience was nothing short of spectacular. They actually closed down the entire restaurant just for our group, providing an intimate and exclusive atmosphere that made our evening feel incredibly special.
Tutti Pazzi stands out for their exceptional service. Despite the large group, the service was seamless. They strategically placed friendly, professional servers at every station to ensure no one was ever waiting. There were multiple stations on each floor so that people who made themselves comfortbale upstairs, didn’t have to go downstairs to get their meal.
We appreciated their personal touch! As a small family-owned gem, they don’t just “serve” you, they welcome you. We truly felt like part of their warm extended family from the moment we walked in. There was a entertainer who normally performs there on Tuesdays, and he was great! His music selection appealed to everyone in our group.
You can taste the quality in every bite of their fresh and flavorful food. The cold antipasto spread was a massive hit, fresh, vibrant, and perfectly curated. Every dish that followed was clearly prepared to order with top-tier ingredients.
It’s rare to find a place that can handle a full team event while maintaining the soul and quality of a cozy neighborhood trattoria.
Whether you are planning a large team gathering or just want a delicious, authentic meal, I cannot recommend Tutti Pazzi enough. Thank you to the whole team for making us feel so at home!
merlyn leal
I had a wonderful dining experience at Tutti Pazzi ! The ambiance was warm and inviting, with the perfect balance of classic Italian charm.
The real standout, however, was our server, Victor. From the moment we sat down, he was attentive, knowledgeable, and genuinely friendly. He gave excellent recommendations — the alfredo pasta and the margarita were absolute highlights — and made sure everything was perfect throughout the meal without ever being intrusive.
Victor’s professionalism and upbeat attitude really elevated our evening. You can tell he takes pride in his work, and it made a big difference. We’ll definitely be back — and next time, we’ll be asking for Victor again!
… moreThe real standout, however, was our server, Victor. From the moment we sat down, he was attentive, knowledgeable, and genuinely friendly. He gave excellent recommendations — the alfredo pasta and the margarita were absolute highlights — and made sure everything was perfect throughout the meal without ever being intrusive.
Victor’s professionalism and upbeat attitude really elevated our evening. You can tell he takes pride in his work, and it made a big difference. We’ll definitely be back — and next time, we’ll be asking for Victor again!
Erin
Tonight, my life forever changed. Logan, a singular man and incredible sensation, was the waiter that served my family this evening. The experience centered solely around his incredible personality and beautiful sense of humor. In every interaction he brought joy and whimsy, elevating the dining experience to an entirely new level. Every time he stopped by the table, my entire family was overcome with wonder at his beneficent manner and kindly soul. Now that I know this type of man exists in the world, having seen such an example of perfection, I’m considering divorcing my husband.
It’s lovely to see this establishment open, very similar in a good way to it’s predecessor Matzaluna. Good food and great iced tea.
… moreIt’s lovely to see this establishment open, very similar in a good way to it’s predecessor Matzaluna. Good food and great iced tea.
Adam and Miranda Senteney
We were frequent visitors of Matzaluna so we were a little hesitant to try Tutti Pazzi. It turns out the food and service is just as great as its predecessor. Victor, our waiter, was patient with us in describing customer favorites and his personal favorites. We will definitely be back. This restaurant and their friendly staff deserve the 5 stars.
The table favorite was definitely the pizza though. The brick oven taste is just so distinct and delicious.
… moreThe table favorite was definitely the pizza though. The brick oven taste is just so distinct and delicious.