Address and Contact Information
Address: 2096 Greeley Mall, Greeley, CO 80631
Phone: (512) 738-4626
Website: https://trattorianatoli.com/
Related Web Results
Trattori Natoli – 2050 Greeley Mall, Greeley, CO, 80631 – MapQuest
Get more information for Trattori Natoli in Greeley, CO. See reviews, map, get the address, and find directions.
Jason Natoli (@natolis_pizza) · Greeley, CO – Instagram
37 followers · 13 posts · 90’s Style Mall Pizza Authentic Italian Recipes Best Pizza in Town No Cap.
Trattoria Natoli in Greeley, United States – reviews,open hours,photo …
Trattoria Natoli. United States Colorado Greeley Trattoria Natoli. Basic Info. Trattoria Natoli. 2050 Greeley Mall, Greeley, CO 80631. 5.0 (28)$$$$. Open until …
Reviews
Alejandro Martinez
We tried the Valentine special pizza along with a strawberry lemonade and a cherry limeade — and wow. Hands down, this is the best pizza we’ve had in Greeley.
The pizza was absolutely loaded with flavor and way more filling than we expected. Every slice was satisfying, and we were full faster than we thought we’d be (which is never a bad thing when it comes to pizza). The Valentine special was a perfect choice — fresh, delicious, and clearly made with care.
The strawberry lemonade and cherry limeade were the perfect refreshing pair to go with it. Both were flavorful and balanced — not overly sweet, just right.
Safe to say, we’ve officially found our new go-to pizza place in Greeley. Can’t wait to come back and try more!
… moreThe pizza was absolutely loaded with flavor and way more filling than we expected. Every slice was satisfying, and we were full faster than we thought we’d be (which is never a bad thing when it comes to pizza). The Valentine special was a perfect choice — fresh, delicious, and clearly made with care.
The strawberry lemonade and cherry limeade were the perfect refreshing pair to go with it. Both were flavorful and balanced — not overly sweet, just right.
Safe to say, we’ve officially found our new go-to pizza place in Greeley. Can’t wait to come back and try more!
Destanie Dettmann
An absolute must if you’re in the area! Hands down one of our favorite pizza places no need for ranch either, pizza is great without it! Also love the lime ricky drink. When we are craving pizza you will find us here! Amazing service as well owner is very personable.
… moreBigMike
Best pizza I’ve had in a long time! The hot honey made in house with the owners suggestion on our slices was so perfect and flavorful! And the cherry limeade was delicious along with the lemonade with like 3 whole lemons was amazing! Will definitely be back and will definitely be telling everyone I know about this place!
… morecarlos duran duran
Great experience food is amazing since day one. I have to space my self or I will get big eating here.
… moreJunior Luna
The pizza is top notch some of the best pizza you’ll ever try stop by the mall and try it you keep comming back.
Come one come all and grab a slice or two try their drink selections they even have hot coco and cheesecake slices.
… moreCome one come all and grab a slice or two try their drink selections they even have hot coco and cheesecake slices.
Andrew Seffron
We stopped in after seeing and smelling the amazing food when wondering around the mall. We had a large pepperoni pizza with hot honey and it was the best pizza I have had in so many years. The staff were so friendly and nice even though it was close to closing time. I also had the meatball sub and it was almost better than the pizza if that’s even possible. I am from out of state and will be going back just for this food. Thank you you guys for the amazing food and service.
… moreJoe Wolfe
Went on 12-04-25. I ordered 2 Whole 3-meat pizzas. They tasted very good. The young man working, I believe his name is Jayden, has excellent customer service skills. He was the only person working that day. He was taking orders and preparing/filling the orders. Even tough there were 6-7 customers waiting in line, they were all very patient with him, which was great to see. The wait time is to long, they need at least 2 people working per shift. Also, they need carry out containers/bags for the customers. I saw one lady who ordered two slices and two drinks have to juggle and balance her food and drinks while she walked away. Any way on my next visit, I’ll try the meatball grinder. Have a great day!
… moreJuan Rodriguez
I came in with little, to no expectations, thinking, “just another pizza joint”.
Was I blown away, the spot is phenomenal, and blew my mind. Definitely try it out for yourself!! New favorite spot by far, so much more to praise, the drinks were amazing, quick service as well, once again check this spot out and tell everyone and everybody
… moreWas I blown away, the spot is phenomenal, and blew my mind. Definitely try it out for yourself!! New favorite spot by far, so much more to praise, the drinks were amazing, quick service as well, once again check this spot out and tell everyone and everybody
Joe Hernandez
Love Natoli’s—great pizza at an awesome price. The tiramisu is delicious, the dirty sodas are a must, and everything is made fresh in-house.
… moreselena paguina
I tried this place while shopping and its literally the best Pizza i’ve ever tasted. I had to go back the next day for another slice. The food is amazing, the people and atmosphere are also very welcoming and amazing as well. 10/10 would highly recommend
… more