Joe Lajoie
They have multiple locations, all are amazing. Had the Detroit and the New Haven style, both were incredible! Some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. We also tried the chargrilled wings (juicy, crispy and incredible char flavor), the “Cus Salt” pie and the Risotto bites. Everything was fantastic!
… moreAshley Greiner
Hands down the Gluten free Detroit style pizza is the best gluten free pizza I’ve ever had (I’ve been GF for over 17 years). I will never stop raving about it. So good!! (And before anyone comes at me, I know it’s not authentic DSP…I had them add more sauce and cheese this time!).
… moreEllie
toss & fire is without a doubt the some of the best pizza in cny! their specialty pizzas are to die for. also, the workers are so so so kind!! please do yourself a favor and stop by here!
… moreTammy Clarke
Our pizza and wings were the best we’ve had in a long time. We asked them to make wings sauce with blue cheese and medium buffalo sauce and they did it with no problem, it wasn’t on the menu. The young man even can over to check to see if we liked how he made them.
Would highly recommend!!!
… moreMary Plaisted
Extremely friendly staff! Busy, but not overwhelming. The wall decor was beautiful. The menu was HUGE! And we got the NY style, and buffalo garlic knots (it was the special today). I can’t remember what pizza; had pickles on it. And oh my goodness, they were HUGE! Super flavored, and the combo of ingredients was .
… moreRachel Rowlee
I LOVE the pizza here! I came for the first time and the cashier Sophia was very kind and helpful and had wonderful recommendations. Not often do you find a place where the food quality matches the service quality. I will definitely be coming back for those garlic knots!
… moreJoseph Arcuri
Great pizza! We came on New Haven pizza night. The staff was very friendly and attentive to our needs. They gave us a free pizza too!
… moreRobin Madak
I loved my half of my pizza (meatball and minced garlic), but hubby’s half was just so-so (sausage and bacon). Staff was friendly and the decor was cute, but the bathrooms were not as clean as they should have been and it was pricey for what we got.
… moreRob Oatman
I’ve loved Toss & Fire for years, but I had never visited the Camillus location. I had also never tried their straight-up pepperoni pizza. I checked both off my list today and was not disappointed. Crust, sauce, cheese … all first-rate. The cupped pepperoni was excellent. I could quibble about the meat’s distribution, but won’t. The fried mozzarella was super, too.
… moreLynn Reith
We live near another toss and fire, and would rather drive to Camillus for better service, food and atmosphere!
… more