Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 6900 Daniels Pkwy #3, Fort Myers, FL 33912
Phone: (239) 362-0604
Website: http://tonysnypizzaftmyers.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Tony’s NY Pizza – Best Pizza Shop In Fort Myers, FL
Enjoy the best New York–style pizza in Fort Myers at Tony’s NY Pizza. Fresh ingredients, handcrafted pies, and authentic NYC flavour served daily.
Food Menu – Tony’s NY Pizza
Our Menu · Appetizers & Soup · Salads · Calzones & Stromboli · Create a Pie · Tonys New York Pies · Pizza by The Slice · Classic Italian Subs · Italian Dinners.
Tony’s NY Pizza – Fort Myers, FL
Order your favorite dishes in seconds! Order Online.
Reviews
Rob W
My mom decided she wanted pizza and I stumbled upon this place.
The two ladies behind the counter were pleasant and great to deal with.
The medium pizza was made fresh and fast. It was chessy without asking for extra cheese, we also added pepperoni and onions.
The crust was crispy and chewy, like a good NY style. The cheese tasted like a blend of mozzarella, provolone, and parmesean.
The sauce, in my opinion, was bland and needed some salt and seasonings, but did have a fresh feel on the taste buds.
My mom loved it.
… moreThe two ladies behind the counter were pleasant and great to deal with.
The medium pizza was made fresh and fast. It was chessy without asking for extra cheese, we also added pepperoni and onions.
The crust was crispy and chewy, like a good NY style. The cheese tasted like a blend of mozzarella, provolone, and parmesean.
The sauce, in my opinion, was bland and needed some salt and seasonings, but did have a fresh feel on the taste buds.
My mom loved it.
Jermaine Lee
Tony’s NY Pizza caught my eye thinking maybe I found a good spot. Coming from the tri-state aera I had high expectations for an authentic NY Italian pizza flavor. In my opinion the pizza was bland the bread or the crust it self was ok. However no flavor or richness in the pizza sauce or quality of cheese. The slice display did look appealing though. I had 1 plain and 1 pepperoni Sicilian.
… moreJohn W (Travelin.Johnny)
This is the 2nd on the NY Tony restaurants I’ve visited. We got there late, close to closing time but they didn’t rush us out. They were very graceful. The staff is super friendly. The pizza is delicious, but needs to be cooked more. The crust was floppy when you fold it. Real NY pizza crust should not flop when you pick it up, but also should not crack when you fold it. It was close to ideal, but not there. I recommend asking for well done. Based on the 1 experience I we had, we’ll be back again. We didn’t try it, but the chicken Parm pizza looked really good.
… moreMimi Pipino
I want my money back !!
They should be ashamed to send this out the door ( Uber Eats).
Its burn to a crisp , the pasta had no sauce on it . TG I has a little container of sauce from the rolls .
Doesn’t matter . It is going down the garbage disposal
… moreThey should be ashamed to send this out the door ( Uber Eats).
Its burn to a crisp , the pasta had no sauce on it . TG I has a little container of sauce from the rolls .
Doesn’t matter . It is going down the garbage disposal
Tyler Fisher
Tony’s is a great little pizza shop with a cozy atmosphere and ample portion sizes. Their “Welcome Wagon” free pizza offer was fantastic! My family loves Tony’s.
… moreEmily Lacina
Tony’s NY Pizza was delicious! Their staff, the space itself, and the fantastic food will have us coming back as our regular pizza spot. Glad to support them 🙂
… moreDavid Berisaj
I’m a uber driver I just moved here from Detroit I thought I had the best pizza in the area but I was wrong this is the best ive found anywhere from New York to Detroit to Miami il be back forsake the staff is amazing and the half off when paying cash unbelievable I’m very happy I had the queen’s white I’m in love .
… moreJazmin Iniguez
Always purchase pizza from Tony’s every weekend, first time we experienced raw pizza dough.
… moreLisa Seydler
Loyal customer since it opened. On 9/21/25 did a take out medium cheese. Worst pizza I ever had. Something was wrong with the dough. Could not eat it. Threw it away. Sad. Always loved the pizza here.
… moreJean-Luc Haag
First time here. Workers are nice and slices are huge & good price. They put it in the oven before giving it to you to make sure it’s hot and fresh. I will come back here again
… more