Hours
| Monday | 3–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 3–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 3–9 PM |
| Thursday | 3–9 PM |
| Friday | 3–10:30 PM |
| Saturday | 3–10:30 PM |
| Sunday | 1–7:30 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 4724 Indianapolis Blvd, East Chicago, IN 46312
Phone: (219) 397-9009
Website: https://tonispizzamenu.com/?utm_source=gbp
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Toni’s Pizza – East Chicago, IN – 4724 Indianapolis Blvd – Hours …
View the menu, hours, address, and photos for Toni’s Pizza in East Chicago, IN. Order online for delivery or pickup on Slicelife.com.
Toni’s Pizza – 4724 Indianapolis Blvd, East Chicago, IN 46312 – Slice
Order online at one of the best restaurants in East Chicago, IN! Toni’s Pizza is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers – satisfy your …
Tonis Pizza | East Chicago IN – Facebook
Tonis Pizza, East Chicago. 70 likes · 29 were here. We try our best to satisfy our customers, we have excellent pizza makers and lovely staff who will…
Last Updates
Reviews
Dexter Norman
I went here a few years ago and still the best sausage pizza i ever tasted dont know if I’ll ever make it back there but if you’re reading this keep up the amazing work do you’ll have one in Georgia let me know so I can go get the best pizza in the world
… moreAnthony Santellano
Since I never been at this restaurant before in East Chicago I wonder what happen to it or why they had to close it down
Now I wish that one day someone will buy and own this restaurant now I would definitely work at an pizza restaurant to make pizza for the customers if they were needed to hire someone there.
… moreNow I wish that one day someone will buy and own this restaurant now I would definitely work at an pizza restaurant to make pizza for the customers if they were needed to hire someone there.
Roberto Lopez
Is it closed forever I grew up eating this pizza it’s the best since I was a kid I moved since away but every spring and summer I like bringing my kids just to pick up a pan pizza hot and ready to eat at least twice a month and eat it and all of them get really happy to taste such a great pizza from my childhood now there all dissapointed it’s not open even a lot of people I know grew up there still come back just to eat it I hope you guys come back
… moreTony G
One of the many smaller pizzerias in East Chicago, but also one of the longest lived. I’ve been coming here off and on since I was a little boy. Their pizza is no frills, good amounts of cheese and toppings on top of a crust that I’ve always found just a bit too thick and bready. I wish they would flatten the crust some and spread the sauce and toppings out more; tavern-cut (squares) pizzas from here always have four weird tiny corners that are 85% crust with a little red sauce dab on the end. That being said it still tastes good and the deals aren’t bad at all. They offer pizza by the slice as well, and chicken and sandwiches that I’ve never tried. Not a bad place for a pie.
… moreMaria Ortiz
The food is delicious. The place is very clean and they have an excellent customer service.
… moreSamoht Jones
If I could have given zero star I would’ve. Pizza is terrible. Just wanted a cheese and jalapeño pizza, why did I waste my money on this cardboard tasting pizza! The jalapeños taste old! The pizza came in the cheapest freaking box, the box is flimsy that it wasn’t even stronger enough to hold a medium thin crust cheese pizza! I will never patronize this place again. The box has advertising for Jackson Hewitt which leads the to believe that the box is old as hell and that’s why the pizza taste weird. I am adding to my review to give Toni’s suggestions for making their pizza more desirable. Before putting the pizza in the oven brush the edges with garlic butter, or olive oil, as it will make an absolute difference. Add Italian seasoning, fresh garlic and Bertolli robust olive oil to your pizza sauce and let it simmer for about two hours before adding using, preparing the sauce the day before is best! Top your pizza with a sprinkle of oregano and a final brush of the garlic butter around the edges! Watch how your reviews go from 1 star to 4 stars and you will thank me later. Trust the process!
… moreLotus Nyxxon
Ordered carryout on a bad snow day.
They treated me with great respect and a great amount of patience with my order for 10+ people.
The restaurant was extremely clean and set to the best standards during the condition of the world, currently.
They communicated very well and I definitely will have future business here.
… moreThey treated me with great respect and a great amount of patience with my order for 10+ people.
The restaurant was extremely clean and set to the best standards during the condition of the world, currently.
They communicated very well and I definitely will have future business here.
Jessics Manzanalea
Waited 2 hours for a $63 order. Had to call 2x. Told order left at 630 didn’t arrive till 710pm. Pizza was supposed to be a 18″ giant sausage and pepperoni. Was a 12″ pepperoni. Called back for 3rd time told to bring pizza in or they couldn’t do anything. If I wanted to drive there I wouldn’t have ordered delivery. NEVER AGAIN.
… moreShana reed
The workers are rude. And they have an attitude when they mess up on the order. I feel like if I am paying my money then the food should be how I want it to be. The old owners were a lot better and more nice. Never again. And I really use to like Toni’s. And the manager don’t even understand my complaint. Never again.
… moreJenny Garcia
Used to be my go to and even now trying to give it another go but they are always closed. Their online hours are completely wrong. Says they open at 3 show up at 5 and they’re still closed. Cant even call cause the voicemail is full. Smh under new management but still keeping the same horrible service. I suggest yalls change ur hours online to the correct time rather than have someone waste their gas to find yalls still closed.
… more