4.2 – 380 reviews • Pizza restaurant
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
mytomspizza.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Reviews
Brandon Roscoe
The homemade dough for the pizza is phenomenal. Literally the best pizza crust I’ve ever had. Gyro meat is tender and flavorful. House made Greek dressing for the salad is light, garlicky, lemony and highlighted with the creaminess of feta. Grape leaves were fresh and delicious. Kids had fettuccine alfredo with the house grilled and marinated chicken. It dissappeared along with the chicken parm sandwich before I could sample. 10/10 would recommend!
… moreElizabeth ED
Passing through town, we stumbled upon Tom’s Pizza and Restaurnt and glad we did. The dinning area was packed and inviting. Although I can see why their lighting is set up like it is, the individual table lighting is blinding. The menu is a mix of Mediterranean and Italian. We ordered our food and the wait was way to long. After 50 minutes and three tables that came after got there food, we finally got ours. Although we received no explanation we chucked it up as kitchen mix up…hey it happens. The food was worth the wait and I felt like my mouth was Emeril Lagasse with every bite…BAM BAM BAM. The kitchen is not afraid of seasoning and my meal was absolutely delicious.
We’ve returned to Tom’s several times and each time the wait for food was 40-50 minutes so it appears to be a normal thing. If you want to eat delicious food and time is not an issue or restraint then Tom’s is a good choice for delicious, well seasoned food. My family will continue to return.
… moreMikeat
The service was lousy and the place was unkept and repulsive. I sat for over an hour before receiving my food and the whole time i was surrounded by filthy tables covered in half eaten food and dirty dishes.
… moreArynn Frampton
Local family Greek pizza place. Their pizzas and hoagies are excellent, well-seasoned and hot. The steak salads are delicious as well. They are very slow tho, they are understaffed. I recommend ordering and reserving ahead.
… moreDori Dzierzynski
This is the best restaurant in Indiana hands down. That’s why they got 3 gold metals and a silver medal. Great job Tom’s Pizza and all the cooks and waitresses. Love the waitresses they are all great and have wonderful personalities especially Wonderful Sam, Grace, Trisha, and Andrew. Great job Kristina
… moreDave Frycklund
Always very enjoyable to get their house special pizza and a Greek salad for 2. An Indiana classic for over 50 years.
… moreMatt Kozusko
Always great! Indiana’s best pizza, Greek salads, gyros and shishkabob should not be missed.
… moreGeorge the Greek
I’m not sure if it was the pizza chef of the day or if the pizza is always so SALTY!? Ordered 2 pies for a get together, Had to order another from another establishment. Hard pass
… moreLydia Kelley
Excellent food. I used to be a regular when I lived in Indiana. The food did not disappoint. The server could have been more knowledgeable about the menu.
… moreEric Dietrick
I normally don’t leave reviews for places but this experience was especially bad from a service standpoint. The food was good, I’ll give them that but the waiter we had was probably the worst I’ve ever had. We asked for refills on our drinks after having empty cups for about 15 minutes and never being checked on, and then had to wait well over 5 minutes while he stood at the counter not getting our drinks. Also keep in mind you pay $3.25 for a drink and they only allow 1 refill, that is one of the greediest things I’ve ever heard. Also $2.50 to get pepperoni on HALF of a pizza. It’s a shame because the food was good but I’ll never go back there simply because of the greed and the poor service.
… more … View more