Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
New Haven-style pizza is front & center at this old-time hangout also doling out Italian basics.
Hours
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 410 Main St, East Haven, CT 06512
Phone: (203) 469-9582
Website: https://www.tolliseasthaven.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Pizza | Tolli’s Apizza | East Haven
Our Italian Restaurant has been around since 1954. A place where the food is hot and everyone is family. Tolli’s Apizza make the best brick oven pizza …
Tolli’s Apizza – Serving and Delivering Great Italian Food & Pizza for …
All Our Food Our Restaurant … Copyright 2019 Tolli’s Apizza 410 Main St, East Haven, CT (203) 469-9582 & Ocean WP by Nick.
Tolli’s Apizza & Restaurant – 410 Main St, East Haven, CT 06512
Order online at one of the best restaurants in East Haven, CT! Tolli’s Apizza & Restaurant is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers …
Reviews
Katie George
Have been coming to Tolli’s for 30 years. Every time
That I am here the staff is friendly and inviting. The food is consistently excellent. The pizza rivals and New Haven pizza. If you not on the mood for pizza there are many choices on the menu.
… moreThat I am here the staff is friendly and inviting. The food is consistently excellent. The pizza rivals and New Haven pizza. If you not on the mood for pizza there are many choices on the menu.
Rob George
My wife grew up in East Haven and grew up eating at Tolli’s. Even though it’s changed owners, I would say that it’s just as good as it’s always been. The staff is friendly, the atmosphere is inviting & the food is top-notch. Will continue coming here and enjoying the restaurant. Please, before leaving a scathing review, consider whether the issue resides with your delivery service or with the restaurant themselves.
… moreJessica Rascati
Do not book an event here. I hosted my baby shower at this location on 02/08/26 and it was a complete nightmare. This was supposed to be a day about me celebrating with friends and family, but instead, I spent the entire time stressed out, angry, and managing the staff’s incompetence.
The negligence was staggering. We had a strict two-hour reservation starting at 2:00 PM. Despite the restaurant being virtually empty, the server completely ignored us for a full hour. She didn’t even take our order until 3:00 PM, leaving us with only an hour to eat and celebrate. It felt like she either couldn’t understand English or simply refused to listen to a word I said.
I was the host. I selected the package. I called and set everything up. Yet, she ignored my direct instructions and took orders from other guests instead, resulting in pizzas with toppings I specifically told her not to include. When the food runner brought the wrong order, instead of apologizing, she gave me an attitude and said, ‘I didn’t put the order in.’ I don’t care who put it in—you work there, fix it!
The service was lazy and stingy. One plate of bread each table for a whole group? Empty drink pitchers for twenty minutes? I walked out of my own baby shower feeling defeated and upset because the staff couldn’t do the bare minimum. You ruined a special day I can never get back!
… moreThe negligence was staggering. We had a strict two-hour reservation starting at 2:00 PM. Despite the restaurant being virtually empty, the server completely ignored us for a full hour. She didn’t even take our order until 3:00 PM, leaving us with only an hour to eat and celebrate. It felt like she either couldn’t understand English or simply refused to listen to a word I said.
I was the host. I selected the package. I called and set everything up. Yet, she ignored my direct instructions and took orders from other guests instead, resulting in pizzas with toppings I specifically told her not to include. When the food runner brought the wrong order, instead of apologizing, she gave me an attitude and said, ‘I didn’t put the order in.’ I don’t care who put it in—you work there, fix it!
The service was lazy and stingy. One plate of bread each table for a whole group? Empty drink pitchers for twenty minutes? I walked out of my own baby shower feeling defeated and upset because the staff couldn’t do the bare minimum. You ruined a special day I can never get back!
Tim Smith
ALMOST didn’t go to this place because of the reviews but happy we did. Some of the best cheese pizza we have ever had. I could see some people wanting the crust more well-done if you are comparing Tolli’s to one of the big 3 but we thought it was cooked perfectly. Prices were quite fine.
If I had to think of some negative stuff: The Mario pizza was a bit dry for my liking but still tasty. The waitstaff was extremely pleasant but they needed more than one server on a Friday night.
We will definitely go back for dine-in and/or pick up. I see there are some poor reviews connected with delivery but I personally don’t trust any 3d party apps (even Slice) to be perfect. Unless it is delivered personally by a business’s own delivery driver I do pickup. But that’s just me.
… moreIf I had to think of some negative stuff: The Mario pizza was a bit dry for my liking but still tasty. The waitstaff was extremely pleasant but they needed more than one server on a Friday night.
We will definitely go back for dine-in and/or pick up. I see there are some poor reviews connected with delivery but I personally don’t trust any 3d party apps (even Slice) to be perfect. Unless it is delivered personally by a business’s own delivery driver I do pickup. But that’s just me.
Christopher Rascati
We hosted a baby shower at Tolli’s in East Haven and unfortunately the experience was really disappointing.
When we arrived around 2 PM, the restaurant was nearly empty, yet there was no host or staff at the entrance to guide guests coming in and out, which immediately made things confusing. Our server seemed unsure of what was going on from the start. We didn’t even begin placing our food order until around 3 PM, despite the event starting an hour earlier.
We clearly told the server which pizzas we wanted, but one of them still came out wrong. Between the delays, lack of organization, and overall inattentiveness — especially considering how empty the restaurant was — it put a damper on what was supposed to be a special celebration.
We understand restaurants get busy, but in this case that wasn’t the issue. Basic coordination and communication would have made a huge difference. We hope management takes this feedback seriously so future guests have a better experience.
… moreWhen we arrived around 2 PM, the restaurant was nearly empty, yet there was no host or staff at the entrance to guide guests coming in and out, which immediately made things confusing. Our server seemed unsure of what was going on from the start. We didn’t even begin placing our food order until around 3 PM, despite the event starting an hour earlier.
We clearly told the server which pizzas we wanted, but one of them still came out wrong. Between the delays, lack of organization, and overall inattentiveness — especially considering how empty the restaurant was — it put a damper on what was supposed to be a special celebration.
We understand restaurants get busy, but in this case that wasn’t the issue. Basic coordination and communication would have made a huge difference. We hope management takes this feedback seriously so future guests have a better experience.
Steve C.
Great pizza, and lasagna. Lady servers were super too.
… moreJoe Del
Today was the third time in as many months that we were delivered the wrong pizza. Today I had to wait for the correct one which made me late to work. The “well done” pizza looked cooked with burn marks but was soft and soggy not crispy.
This is the only place I’ve ever been to that asks for the pizza back and doesn’t give you a free soda or tell you to keep the pizza that was wrong or something! as a way to say sorry.
Only one of us did not like the pizza the day originally sent so we all had to wait to eat until they sent the right one. If they told us hey you could just keep the one that we sent originally I would have not been late to work and I probably would have gave the driver another 10 bucks.
… moreThis is the only place I’ve ever been to that asks for the pizza back and doesn’t give you a free soda or tell you to keep the pizza that was wrong or something! as a way to say sorry.
Only one of us did not like the pizza the day originally sent so we all had to wait to eat until they sent the right one. If they told us hey you could just keep the one that we sent originally I would have not been late to work and I probably would have gave the driver another 10 bucks.
jennie gam
I hope people see this review. Someone has flooded these folks with 1 stars and have the wrong restaurant. Tolli’s staff have always been nice and helpful. The food is good, and they have a long-standing positive reputation. Give them a try if you haven’t been there.
… moreMike Smith
Went in recently and was treated very poorly by a woman named Karina. Not sure how you keep an employee who is so rude to customers.
Edit: not sure why the owner is pretending like they do not know who their daughter is, but nice try! Try being better people and running a better business.
… moreEdit: not sure why the owner is pretending like they do not know who their daughter is, but nice try! Try being better people and running a better business.
jackeline ortiz
I haven’t been here in a while but we went back yesterday and im doing this review bc i want to Thank Crystal. She wasn’t our waitress but she went above and beyond, she made sure we were good with drinks and made sure we were satisfied with the food she was very attentive not just with us but with everyone(we didn’t get the same treatment from the other girl that was serving us). Thank you so much Crystal.
… more