Tobin’s Pizza has served delicious pizza to Bloomington-Normal for over 50 years, earning praise from the Pantagraph, who awarded us #1 Pizza in McLean County. Our pizzas are made one at a time, no fillers, always fresh, never pre-cooked or frozen! We offer thin crust and deep dish pizza, as well as take-out, carry-out, pick-up, and no-contact delivery.
Old-school, kid-friendly Italian-American joint with pan pizza, spaghetti dinners & fried chicken.
Susan Pfordresher
Wow! This was a great experience from start to finish. Friendly, cozy, old school atmosphere. We had the Garden deluxe thin crust pizza. Perfect sauce ,cheese and veggie ratio, absolutely delicious! Wonderful service with the owner on site checking in with patrons. Lots of specials and the prices are incredible.
… moreRobin Brayfield
We’ve been customers for 20+ years. My husband loves Tobin’s thin crust and I’m a huge fan of Micheleo’s pan pizza. I do consider the price when ordering. Is it worth it? EVERY SINGLE TIME!! We can easily have 3 meals out of each pizza for us. The quality ingredients and consistency is key to deliver a great pizza every time. We have never been disappointed!!
… moreDrummer John
Tonight my friend and I are in town for work, and when we saw this month’s specialty pizza, we knew we had to go. The Shipwrecked Scampi pizza was absolutely amazing! Well balanced between the white garlic sauce, the sautéed shrimp, fresh scallions and lemon. Have you ever seen the movie, “What about Bob?” I was eating that pizza saying “Mmmmm, mmmm, MMM!” just like Bob did in the movie. Our server Lilli was very kind and prompt with our needs. Thanks again, we’ll be back for sure!
… moreMark Audi
We don’t get to Bloomington, IL. very often, but when we do Tobin’s Pizza is a MUST stop. I was turned onto this delicious pizza several decades ago and the quality food hasn’t changed
… moreJ
I have been here 3 times now and I will say the 1st time we came here the food was great and the waitress was outstanding, very friendly and on point! The 2nd time we came here the service was horrible the waiter we had was ignorant and very slow, the worst part of the 2nd visit was the waiter was training another young man which was very pleasant and friendly unlike who was training him. I sure the guy training doesn’t take any pointers from the guy training him. Our last and final visit was tonight and unfortunately will be our last visit seeing it seems like nothing matters there. This time we placed our order and the order was wrong even after the waitress repeating the order not once but twice and then came back a third time to ask again about the order but still got it wrong. When she brought the 3 pizzas to the table only 1 of them was correct and 2 of them were wrong and Luke warm. This was very annoying due to the fact that we waited an hour for the pizza to get done and then be wrong even after she asked 3 time. Not sure where that 1st waitress went that we had but they definitely need to get better trainer there or hire people that care about your customers. I’ve read they are suppose to be reasonable but until have to say different. The owner doesn’t really seem to care about the issues either.
… moreGenea Grossen (GG Aesthetics)
We were traveling from WI through Bloomington and wanted some good homemade pizza. Tobins had exactly what we were looking for. Friendly, delicious and lots of options.
… moreChristina Eshleman
We love Tobin’s. They have a great variety of food and the quality is very good. We especially like the Micheleo’s pizza, both thick and thin. The sauce they use is absolutely delicious! I also got the biggest salad here I’ve ever had at a restaurant. It was funny how big it was. It’s literally big enough for 3 full meals. The kids ate some of the pepperoni before I could take a picture. I also took a picture of my salad when I was done eating and how it looked in the to-go box. It’s good to know how big it is, though, since we might get one to share with a pizza sometime. This was also the first time we had the onion rings and they were fantastic!!
Another great fact about Tobin’s is they are one of the few who deliver to where we live. Being just west of town, we are limited on delivery options, but the fact that they deliver and they’re one of our favorite places to eat is a win-win!
… moreNicholas Riley
Been to this place 2 times. The food is great. The atmosphere is very dated, but I think that is part of the mastic of it. This 2nd time I went to was with 2 other people, they received their food, and mine took a little while. I’m not real sure why, however it was very good. I do recommend going, just make sure you enter the correct door, it doesn’t look like the right one, but it is. LOL.
… moreJeff Acup
First time here and they are awesome. Ordered two small pizzas to compare different styles. Like them so much we ordered a large pizza to go. Service was outstanding as well.
… moreJ Hh
I went in the dining room and some manager wearing a plaid shirt walked by and coughed on my salad, I was so “thankful”! Tried playing their one arcade cabinet, but these really staunch Gen Alpha kids pushed me out of the way. I should have ordered delivery so I can tip the man who is wearing shorts in the middle of Winter?! The pizza was pretty good, burnt the roof of my mouth and it felt really nice, cheeseburger pizza all the way! Atmosphere was non-chalant and parking lot is niche. Overall neighborhood is a pretty good marketing experience, after I left I came home with pizza, lingerie, flowers, and a lucky charm coffee! Saw a driver scratch one of their own cars!
… more