Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Tobey’s Pizza | Sandy Lake PA – Facebook
It says Tobey’s is permanently closed. It’s not true. Tobey’s in Sandy Lake is open daily from 11am to 8pm.
Tobey’s Pizza, 3308 N Main St, Sandy Lake, PA 16145, US
Great food! Cash only. Take out or picnic table in back. Pizza, hoagies, grinders (very proud of the grinders), pop (soda) and that’s it.
Order Tobeys Pizza Delivery in Sandy Lake | Menu & Prices
3308 North Main Street, Sandy Lake, PA 16145 · Salads. Grilled Chicken Salad (Large). Steak Salad (Large). Small Salad. Served with lettuce, tomato, and onion …
Reviews
Brad Peterson
My favorite pizza sauce of all time! If they don’t put the shaker/Parmesan cheese on the sauce! It changes the taste of it! Which makes the drive over worthless. Because that’s why I go! If they leave that out of it. Which sometimes they do and sometimes they don’t! I politely ask each time to not put it on it. Then I get home and it’s covered in it! I’d eat there once a week if wasn’t a 50/50 chance that it’s gonna be made without out it. Otherwise it’s fantastic! And so is everything else!
… moreAndrew Gelesky Jr
If you’ve never been here, you’re missing out! There’s plenty of good reasons why this place has been a staple of the area for so long. Wedgies and pizza are both Phenomenal! Just remember, Cash only
… moreLarry Kniess
Best little pizza shop around! They had a shop in oil city for years that my wife grew up on and this one (the original) survived and does not disappoint. Owners are great, friendly, and serve to please. If you go be sure to have cash or check cuz they don’t accept cards…
… moreCara
Crust is frozen and tasteless. The appetizers are cheap poor quality and freezer burnt. Sauce is bitter. Just overall poor quality. I could have bought frozen pizza for better quality. I hate to take away from a small business but I just spent almost $100 and nothing was good that we ordered.
… moreMasterSho02
Best Pizza ever! Miss having it in Oil City. But still worth the drive when you get a craving for something better than what’s local.
… moreLesa Shannon
This is by far my most favorite part of visiting home. I miss the Tobey’s in Mercer, but this is every bit as good. If you ever want to expand- you should! SE Virginia please and THANK YOU!
… moreJeff Masters
I drive from Hermitage,Pa. To Sandy Lake For there steak wegies !
… moreJesse Krizon
Been getting pizza there all my life always made the way you order !
… moreselena stevens
We love Toby’s subs and wedges. We stopped in on our way to Franklin and got steak wedges for our lunch. I always add extra steak to ours and they did not disappoint. The food was delicious and quickly done.
… moreJoe Granata
Stopped by on my way home. Got the steak hoagie: delicious! Nice, clean, friendly little place with good food for my first visit.
… more