Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 34 Raceway Rd, Monticello, NY 12701
Phone: (845) 794-6540
Website: https://tillysdiner.top/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Tilly’s Diner – 34 Raceway Rd, Monticello, NY, 12701 – MapQuest
Tilly’s Diner is a cozy eatery nestled in the heart of Monticello, NY, offering a menu of classic American comfort food.
Tilly’s Diner 34 Raceway Rd, Monticello, NY 12701 – Facebook
Tully, Elm street Closed: Sunday & Monday Tuesday – Saturday 11a-7p *A new rotating weekly menu is up every Tuesday… Absolutely kid friendly!
Tilly’s Diner on Instagram • Photos and Videos
Log in · Open app. Tilly’s Diner. 12701. Diner•644 posts. $$$$•Open until 9:00 PM. +1 845-794-6540 · Top · Recent · In the area · Photo by Joey Schmidt in …
Reviews
Rebecca Kaplan-Fisher
We stopped in for lunch today. Not very busy.
He ordered the beef and lamb gyro and white bean soup, I ordered hot open roast beef. It took almost a half an hour to get lunch to the table, don’t understand why there were only four other people in there.
Wait staff was distant and unfriendly. Typical dining decor hasn’t been updated in years. When we did get our food it was actually tasty, flavorful and good-sized portions. My husband asked for the ketchup for his french fries- she placed an open bottle of ketchup on the table. WILD.
Prices are reasonable for the portions.
My husband really enjoyed the white bean soup he said it was flavorful and tasty. He also said it was one of the better gyro he has eaten, the meat was flavorful and tender.
Might stop in again, and try something for dinner one night.
… moreHe ordered the beef and lamb gyro and white bean soup, I ordered hot open roast beef. It took almost a half an hour to get lunch to the table, don’t understand why there were only four other people in there.
Wait staff was distant and unfriendly. Typical dining decor hasn’t been updated in years. When we did get our food it was actually tasty, flavorful and good-sized portions. My husband asked for the ketchup for his french fries- she placed an open bottle of ketchup on the table. WILD.
Prices are reasonable for the portions.
My husband really enjoyed the white bean soup he said it was flavorful and tasty. He also said it was one of the better gyro he has eaten, the meat was flavorful and tender.
Might stop in again, and try something for dinner one night.
Kristin Klingaman
From NJ with plenty of diners, this diner felt like home We came in for dinner on a weeknight after traveling 2.5 hours in the rain. We were seated right away. Waitress was welcoming and food was served fresh and hot. Food was good and you won’t be disappointed!
… moreHadi Shadkam
Stopped here for a quick lunch. The food was okay, but the service and vibre were better than the food.
… moreAdam Lorber
Being from Long Island, there is no shortage of diners. We came to the Catskills for a 3 day getaway. Tilly’s diner was one of the best highlights of our trip. We were staying at Resorts World but wanted to explore the area. This diner makes everything from scratch and has a great classic old diner feel. The servers were very friendly, the prices were great and quantity/quality of food is amazing. We ended up coming to Tilly’s 3 times over 3 days rather than eating at Resorts World.
We highly recommend this diner.
… moreWe highly recommend this diner.
B.D. Y.
We stopped here on our way to Cooperstown, after flying in from Los Angeles, where there are very few diners. This is a great one. The menu has plenty of staples as well as more creative options.
… moreEmanuel Pascal
Tilly’s Bar is solid for breakfast. They open early, which I like, and it’s a good spot to start the day. Food in the morning is on point and worth going back for.
Lunch is just okay. Not bad, but nothing special. I wouldn’t come back for lunch, but for breakfast, I’ll definitely return anytime.
… moreLunch is just okay. Not bad, but nothing special. I wouldn’t come back for lunch, but for breakfast, I’ll definitely return anytime.
Lil Mateo
My family and I were at the kartrite resort and decided to come here for breakfast. A friend had recommend this diner to us. This place was very family friendly. Food took a little while to come but otherwise delicious. My son loved their hot chocolate.
… moreGeorge Ramirez
Everything about the diner was fantastic! The food was dangerously delicious!! Will definitely come back to Tillys!!
… moreLisa Prosper
We had a great visit at Tilly’s. Recommended by a staff member at the Best Western, Tilly’s was a short walk away. Staff was attentive and friendly. We each ordered the turkey dinner and wow! An incredible amount of food and delicious! We could have shared one meal, but it was so good we both left stuffed. If in the area, I would highly recommend.
… moreDrew Fried
One of our party asked for a Buffalo Chicken Wrap and asked if the sauce used was hot sauce or Buffalo sauce and the answer was Buffalo . When the food came it was hot sauce. When the waitress was questioned , she said this what they use and if you wanr we can it over with no sauce or do you want something else. The person chose something else. When the bill came both meals were on the bill. When questioned at the register we were told we had to pay for the uneaten food or the waitress had to pay for it. How ridiculous is that. She offered the options. We were also we don’t use hot sauce, but it was on every table.
… more