Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 416 N Columbus St, Lancaster, OH 43130
Phone: (740) 808-8222
Website: http://www.tiberiospizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Tiberios Pizza
We also offer carry-out and delivery for your convenience. Visit Our Dining Room at. 416 N Columbus St. Lancaster OH 43130.
Tiberio’s Pizza | Lancaster OH – Facebook
Tiberio’s Pizza. Since 1990, Tiberio’s has been a Lancaster staple for generations. Homemade pastas pizzas stromboli. Pizza place · $$ · (740) 808-8222.
Tiberio’s Pizza, 416 N Columbus St, Lancaster, OH 43130, US
Situated at 416 N Columbus St, the restaurant offers a welcoming … Small seating area inside, decent size bar. Service was slow, it appeared to …
Reviews
Katie
I very much debated posting anything. I ordered for delivery. Delivery took approximately an hour, which seems to be the average for a Friday night no matter where you in Lancaster. Delivery driver was super nice. He was the highlight of this experience.
When my order was delivered everything seemed fine. Top of the pizza looked good. Go to take a bite, instant taste of charcoal. Look at the bottom and… see the photos. I am floored this was sent out the to a customer. The crust was so hard from how burnt it was, my teeth couldn’t go through it. There is no way whoever cut this pizza did not know it was burnt.
I paid $18 for a medium (12″), 1.5 topping pizza. That pizza was cut into 16 pieces. 1 of those 16 pieces was light enough to be eaten. That means I paid $18 to be able to eat 6% of a pizza.
… moreWhen my order was delivered everything seemed fine. Top of the pizza looked good. Go to take a bite, instant taste of charcoal. Look at the bottom and… see the photos. I am floored this was sent out the to a customer. The crust was so hard from how burnt it was, my teeth couldn’t go through it. There is no way whoever cut this pizza did not know it was burnt.
I paid $18 for a medium (12″), 1.5 topping pizza. That pizza was cut into 16 pieces. 1 of those 16 pieces was light enough to be eaten. That means I paid $18 to be able to eat 6% of a pizza.
Family In Christ
Ordered a 16” pepperoni pizza extra sauce and a 14” cauliflower pepperoni.
16” was decent. Should be more pepperoni for $25.50. I did not notice extra sauce but it was on the receipt.
Cauliflower ended up being a 10” pizza for $18.50!
They also charge credit card fees. This charge should not be passed to the guest without their knowledge. It really looks bad for a business nowadays.
Prices do not match their website. See below.
Average pizza overpriced. Probably wont order again. There are too many good pizza places around with better product and more reasonable prices.
… more16” was decent. Should be more pepperoni for $25.50. I did not notice extra sauce but it was on the receipt.
Cauliflower ended up being a 10” pizza for $18.50!
They also charge credit card fees. This charge should not be passed to the guest without their knowledge. It really looks bad for a business nowadays.
Prices do not match their website. See below.
Average pizza overpriced. Probably wont order again. There are too many good pizza places around with better product and more reasonable prices.
JTKarle Milbaugh
I am not sure what happened during some of the other reviews but we just ate at Tiberios two nights in a row ! The food was good, came out hot and everything tasted great. LOVED the Garlic Parmesan sauce! The service Wayne provided was absolutely stellar. Everyone was so friendly. Samara did an awesome job when Wayne was with other clients. The two of them went above and beyond for us! And when the manager, Erin, checked on us to make sure everything was perfect, we had nothing but rave reviews! From the Staff, to the food and atmosphere everything was on point! We will be back for sure and highly recommend.
… moreKeenan
Great pizza place. We got a pizza and stromboli. Besides the minor hick up in the kitchen, which they made right, food was awesome. Topped nicely and crispy crust. The steomboli was filled generously. Their marinara is sweeter and seasoned with herbs which balance the sweetness out.
… morekelsy nye
First time here and I am not disappointed. Everything from the appetizers to my personal pizza was delicious. And the portions were very generous. Would definitely come back when in town in order as delivery
Garlic Bread with cheese
Fried ravioli
All the way personal pizza
Pepperoni pizza
… moreGarlic Bread with cheese
Fried ravioli
All the way personal pizza
Pepperoni pizza
Phil Hicks
I’m from Columbus and am a picky pizza snob. This place is delicious! We travel two hours round trip just to enjoy. Service is great with a cool sports bar atmosphere. New owners stepped it up!
… moreCasey Chapman
Absolutely amazing. We got to go one night and loved it. We decided to eat in one day and everything was amazing. From the service to the food and our drinks never went empty! Top notch service and the cook even came out and checked our food and made sure everything was good
… moreLacie C
I have eaten here twice and both times were disappointing. I only came back a second time to give it another shot. The food is ok at best. Definitely not worth the hype some people have with this place and definitely not worth the price. Our service was also disappointing. We never ask for much and didn’t when we were there but our waitress barely spoke to us or looked at us, then threw forks onto our table and walked away. She was nice and pleasant when she did actually talk. It seems like the whole place is being ran by high school kids without any adults present. The tables and utensils look gross, like they’ve hardly been cleaned. The whole place looks kind of dirty overall. I will not be back after the last experience we had there. I don’t want to pay 30 dollars for a pizza that tastes and looks like it cost $3 to make.
… moreLoree Lambert
My family and I ABSOLUTELY LOVE this place. Quick and Amazing service. My favorite servers are Myah and Emma they are awesome. The manager Erin always makes sure we have everything we need. I come here 2 times a week. Best pizza in town!!
… moreStuart Poe
Everything was really good except the bill. I think $27.50 for a medium all the way pizza is a little high. It was good but not that good. Wings weren’t bad, but again, maybe a little overpriced with the store bought blue cheese. Let me know if I’m wrong.
… more