Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Three Guys From Italy | Kenilworth NJ – Facebook
Fun fact: we host private customized parties. Here’s a recent baptism for a sweet little girl.
Barstool Pizza Review – Three Guys From Italy (Kenilworth, NJ)
Dave reviews Three Guys From Italy, and the owner is wants to know where everyone is from. Download The One Bite App to see more and review …
Three Guys from Italy (@3.guys.from.italy) · Kenilworth, NJ – Instagram
Italian restaurant and pizzeria. Dinning and take out available. 908-272-2553.
Reviews
Christopher B
Nestled away on a quiet street, this unassuming Italian restaurant delivers an unforgettable dining experience. Despite its modest appearance, the food here is exceptional. We shared a variety of dishes, each bursting with flavor and authenticity. The service was impeccable, adding to the overall enjoyment. Don’t miss the fresh hot bread and antipasto salad. Portions were generous, allowing us to bring some home for later. For a genuine taste of Italy, this hidden gem is a must-visit.
**Side Note:** It’s worth mentioning that this charming establishment operates on a cash-only basis, with no option for credit card payments. However, fear not if you find yourself short on cash, as they conveniently provide an ATM machine onsite for your convenience.
… more**Side Note:** It’s worth mentioning that this charming establishment operates on a cash-only basis, with no option for credit card payments. However, fear not if you find yourself short on cash, as they conveniently provide an ATM machine onsite for your convenience.
Michael Krauthamer
We stopped in for lunch on our way into NY. Absolutely fantastic pizza! Perfectly crispy crust and overall excellent. While we were there, they were preparing trays of food for a big event. If you are looking for authentic and delicious Italian food, Three Guys From Italy is your place to go!
… moreJeffrey Gal
Great spot for a good Itlian meal
Had the veal & eggplant parmigiana ,and the pizza is great too
… moreHad the veal & eggplant parmigiana ,and the pizza is great too
The Commish
The food was good. I will say the cannolli was the best I’ve ever had.
… moreSamuel Molinari
Went for lunch but could not pass up the veal parm. Nick, the owner, treated.us like gold. We ate.outside.and it felt like we stepped back in time. We moved away from this area about 15 years ago but the food is as good as ever. Wife has the eggplant parm and she was as happy has i was.
… morebridget burbano
wanted to eat here but they don’t take card or apply pay which like it’s 2025 ?! What?! But ok fair to each their own. But on top of that , the man was super rude , shouting at me because in his words “ You don’t have money why come “ .. sorry but the customer service is trash
Basically I won’t ever be trying the pizza here & you shouldn’t either 🙂
… moreBasically I won’t ever be trying the pizza here & you shouldn’t either 🙂
Lacey Mizell
Excellent and authentic Italian spot in Kenilworth, NJ
Visiting from Chicago, this is the real deal.
Mussels and Escarole and beans were superb!!
… moreVisiting from Chicago, this is the real deal.
Mussels and Escarole and beans were superb!!
Lauren G
Unfortunately, it was our first and last time here. Every other review here that states about rude wait staff, is sadly 100% accurate.
We were asked to move to a different table because of the large party behind us but then no more than 5 minutes later, a couple was sat at that exact table who appeared to be “regulars.”
You are NOT allowed to order a personal pizza or a slice for dinner, it was a hard no. They don’t want to please their customers in any way shape or form. Period. The “regulars” seem to get treated like gold, what a shame.
You also cannot order a sandwich for dinner, another hard no. Husband want chicken cutlet broccoli rabe. A shame a non chain restaurant truly do not care to have happy repeat customers. We won’t return nor will we recommend.
No options for salad dressing so if you choose to come to this establishment, bring your own.
The steep prices do not reflect the quality of food presented.
It’s also cash only. Really poor firsf (and last) experience and couldn’t agree more with the rest of the poor reviews!!!
… moreWe were asked to move to a different table because of the large party behind us but then no more than 5 minutes later, a couple was sat at that exact table who appeared to be “regulars.”
You are NOT allowed to order a personal pizza or a slice for dinner, it was a hard no. They don’t want to please their customers in any way shape or form. Period. The “regulars” seem to get treated like gold, what a shame.
You also cannot order a sandwich for dinner, another hard no. Husband want chicken cutlet broccoli rabe. A shame a non chain restaurant truly do not care to have happy repeat customers. We won’t return nor will we recommend.
No options for salad dressing so if you choose to come to this establishment, bring your own.
The steep prices do not reflect the quality of food presented.
It’s also cash only. Really poor firsf (and last) experience and couldn’t agree more with the rest of the poor reviews!!!
Mel B
Been coming here since I was a child ! Off the boat and always good!! The best bread ever too. Thanks for all the birthday dinners and memories !
… moregerry cascarano
My favorite Italian restaurant in NJ. I love how it is half pizzeria half restaurant because it offers both amazing pizza and great options in the restaurant. I really enjoy their penne vodka and I love their potato croquettes. The service is great and the waiters are very friendly. I haven’t had any issues and they are very fun to get along with.
… more