Sarah Heff
I love Three Brothers and have been going since they opened. It’s nice to support a local business with really good bagels! Both breakfast and lunch are great – make sure you go early because they do run out of bagels! I had their soup for the first time today and wow was that good too! 10/10 per usual. Always shop local! The bagels are better!
… moreMaria Wahal
I’m sitting in the restaurant writing this review because it couldn’t wait until I got in the car. This is hands down the BEST bagel shop in Pittsburgh. 30 minutes from my apartment but will be driving here as often as possible. I can’t recommend it here enough! We tried the bagel sandwiches and plain bagels with cream cheese – both were absolutely phenomenal. Never thought i’d find a bagel this good outside of NY but they’ve exceeded all expectations!
… moreSusan F
Today I went with the Taylor ham everything bagel, potato leek soup and cinnamon roll. I’m 7 months pregnant and it’s a spiritual experience eating your food. I hope happiness and sunshine fill all your days.
… moreTami Lee
The smell in the store gives a preview for what’s to come. The bagels are absolutely delicious! Homemade, fresh, soft, and so tasty! Many different flavors of bagels from sweet to savory. There is a variety of cream cheeses. Sandwiches and baked goods, reasonable prices, plenty of parking. Three Brothers Bagels is a must try!
… moreJoseph Caporale
Very busy place. But it moves fast
Good tasting bagel
Bacon was Good quality like from a butcher
Sausage was handpressed
… moreThomas Donahoe
Well worth every bit of a 5 star rating. Great atmosphere, high quality ingredients, and most importantly excellent bagels.
We ordered a Turkey Club and a Pastrami, Egg, and Cheese, and both sandwiches were fantastic and reasonably priced. We grabbed a few bagels to try at home, and having them made me wonder why people stand in line in Squirrels Hill for that other place.
Will be back soon and often!
… moreElizabeth Mormer
These are the best bagels in the city of Pittsburgh, however I have had bagel sandwiches where they only put cream cheese on one side intermittently. This is a tragedy for those of us who eat our bagels sandwiches open faced. Please cream cheese both sides of the bagel
… moreJason Fry
There’s a damn good reason they sell out so often! Had the French toast bagel with strawberry cream cheese and it was fantastic. The lemon poppyseed cruller and the Brooklyn blackout cruller are out of this world! Get there early if you go.
… moreSarge
Wow! Grew up in NY and these bagel are the best I’ve had in PA!! Great job 3 brothers bagels!! Love your online ordering system too!
Picture is the veggie sandwich with scallion cream cheese. Enough for two meals!
… moreElena Stipetich
Three Brother’s Bagels offer mediocre bagels for a very high price. I usually find that the bagels taste fine but are chewy and tough to eat. I’ve had no problems with service.
*Edit: removed one star from atmosphere for petty response to my review. Owner needs to learn to take criticism in stride.
… more