Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
The Slice has been serving Evansville since 1994 with New York–style pizza by the slice. From classics like cheese and pepperoni to creative flavors like spinach-feta and gyro, every slice is crafted to keep you coming back. Fun yet classy, The Slice offers a gourmet menu with old-school charm. Located steps from the University of Evansville, it’s a favorite for students and locals. The atmosphere is casual, upbeat, and welcoming—the perfect place to relax and enjoy a fresh slice. Proudly cash-only, The Slice stays true to its vintage roots while delivering bold flavors and friendly service. Under new ownership since 2024, it continues the tradition of no-fuss, high-quality pizza in a lively setting.
Hours
| Monday | 11:16 AM–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 11:16 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11:16 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11:16 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11:16 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11:16 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2011 Lincoln Ave, Evansville, IN 47714
Phone: (812) 454-0983
Website: https://theslicein.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
The Slice
2011 Lincoln Ave Evansville, IN 47714 (812) 454-0983 Welcome to The Slice Look forward to seeing you soon!
The Slice Evansville – Facebook
— An Evansville Favorite Since 1993! 2011 Lincoln Avenue, Evansville, across the corner from UE ☎️ (812) 454-0983 ⏰ Hours of Operation: Monday – Saturday: …
The Slice Evansville (@thesliceevansville) – Instagram
An Evansville Fav Since 1993! Gourmet Pizza, Keto Bowls, Salad, & Desserts! Serving Beer, Wine, Sodas & more! 2011 Lincoln Ave., Evansville IN.
Reviews
Christy Masseur
Very friendly, did a gluten free crust for me, fair price, and quick service.
The only thing was it was a little crispy, extra crunchy.
Plenty of toppings & would be fine trying there again (didn’t get to dine in.).
Mine was a carryout.
… moreThe only thing was it was a little crispy, extra crunchy.
Plenty of toppings & would be fine trying there again (didn’t get to dine in.).
Mine was a carryout.
Jenni B
This place is awesome! Great pizza with an amazing vibe. My daughter & I tried 5 or 6 different slices. I liked the pesto slice the best. Rhett liked the gyro slice the best. Tough call!
UPDATE: it has been sold to a new owner. Whole different vibe ☹️
… moreUPDATE: it has been sold to a new owner. Whole different vibe ☹️
Rod Summers
really love the Slice – especially the new layout! same great pizza with a few new twists and variations! have always liked the Slice, but the new renovations under the new owner and his team are fantastic! the place is more spacious, plenty of room and you can catch a game on one of their several tv’s! the place is clean and the service is excellent and friendly! fantastic pizza, great prices, great atmosphere! try it!!
… moreCranjis McBasketball
This place is ran by a bunch of clowns. My girlfriend called them the day before her birthday to schedule a birthday dinner. They quoted us $130 dollars for 4 NY style pizzas and 8 drinks. Then on the day of her birthday we show up and they aren’t even open. Thankfully Lombardi’s was open and charged us half the amount the slice was going to charge for the same amount of food. Don’t waste your time or money with these clown shoe wearing jerks. Go to Lombardi’s instead.
… moreTeeeve
The slice is one of a kind, it’s not your typical pizza restaurant that you’re going walk up to, it is very unique. It’s a staple here in Evansville. The pizza is phenomenal. This is a hole in the wall pizza place that you will not regret going out of your way to find or even making it your weekly lunch spot.
… moreSarah Hartman
Definitely a college eatery, pay by the slice in a dingy restaurant. Staff were friendly and slice prices were very reasonable. Pizzas made fresh and come out hot. Wasn’t too crazy about the classic, but a few different pizza styles to choose from.
… moreBrittany Culver
Awesome pizza the cheese that is used is amazing so many options but the traditional cheese, sausage, pepperoni tend to be what all of my family gets. The sauce is always perfect never overly heavy and never dried out. We go here once a week and everyone loves it kids and adults both!! It is cash only.
… moreVeX
The pizza is mostly all puffy bread, hardly any sauce, toppings are always messy, and it’s just a bad scene there. Do NOT waste your time and money here. Unless you enjoy eating sauceless mild cheesy thick bread. Just Gross!!!
… morezaddy boi
Me and my boys came 10 mins before closing because we thought it closed at 11pm. But John was kind enough to take our order. Best pizza in town!!! and also shoutout to Ashley for giving us 2 free slices of pizza! 10/10 food, 10/10 service, and 11/10 atmosphere!
… moreJayson Smith
What a great place. They literally serve by the slice and cooked fresh. With many options to choose from in this very friendly comfortable atmosphere. A great place!!!
… more