Address and Contact Information
Address: 26 Wrightstown Cookstown Rd, Cookstown, NJ 08511
Phone: (609) 286-2170
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
The Sandwich Shop | Cookstown NJ – Facebook
The Sandwich Shop, Cookstown. 5537 likes · 51 talking about this. Breakfast/Lunch All Day & Mon til 7pm -Vantage Plaza, 26 WrightstownCookstown Rd….
The Sandwich Shop – Cookstown – DoorDash
Get delivery or takeout from The Sandwich Shop at 26 Wrightstown Cookstown Rd in Cookstown. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your …
The Sandwich Shop LLC – Delicious Eats in Cookstown, NJ
Located at 26 Wrightstown Cookstown Rd, Cookstown, NJ 08511, The Sandwich Shop LLC has quickly become a go-to spot for delicious, high-quality meals at an …
Reviews
Sherry Jankowsky
Very busy sandwich shop in a small town. Haven’t been to this particular place in many years. I think it has changed ownership since. Stopped in ordered two subs to go (an Italian and a roast beef and cheese.). $30 for two subs. I guess it’s about average these days. The subs are heavy, so I assumed they were going to be worth it based on weight alone. The meat was fresh and plentiful good quality lunchmeat All of the toppings were fresh. Order was done exactly as we asked. The bread is the part that makes the sub and they were on point. Overall, a very good sub. The staff is very good at what they do. They are quick and efficient and very nice to deal with. Definitely a go to if you are in the area just check the hours as they are not open late.
… moreJeremy A. Hill
What better way to put it than quite literally THE go to sandwich shop in the local area. It’s a good idea to call in the order cause this place is usually jampacked. Make sure you take a look at that menu prior to because they get straight to the point. What do you want because…we know it’s gonna be good!
Slam back a breakfast with a cup of Joe or smash a sandwich with something to wet your whistle, you won’t be disappointed.
… moreSlam back a breakfast with a cup of Joe or smash a sandwich with something to wet your whistle, you won’t be disappointed.
Candace Hill
Very hard working people here! They are always busy, but that’s because the food is great. Employees are kind, prices are fair, and they have a nice selection of options to choose from.
Not a sit down kind of place, but they do have a few barstools if you choose to.
… moreNot a sit down kind of place, but they do have a few barstools if you choose to.
M L
I love a good sammich, so figured I’d give this place a shot. One shot was plenty. The sandwich was ok. Nothing wrong with it. Not among the best I’ve had, and not among the worst. Solidly acceptable in quality. But holy crap was it expensive. $22!!! Way more expensive than it should have been. I thought the prices were high when I got it, but for a a great sandwich, I’d gladly pay it. But not for just an acceptable one. Plus, the buns are narrow/skinny, so it looks like a lot of meat in the pictures, but it’s just an illusion. It’s a regular amount of meat, just on a skinnier bun.
And then the chilli. I mean, it’s chilli. How do you mess it up? Well, one way is by using the greasiest meat you can find. There was so much oil in it that I could bearely taste anything besides the oil. Barely any spiciness either, but that’s fine, because chilli doesn’t have to be super spicy. I never hold that against it. But this stuff wasn’t spicy, super oily, and barely tasted of anything at all. For the amount of chilli, I think $6 was an everage price, but for the quality I got, I wouldn’t have even taken a free bowl
A large hoagie and a cup of chilli was almost $30. Insanity. I could have gotten a nice steak dinner at a decent steakhouse for that much. I could have gotten a full rack of out of this world ribs, with sides, for that much. If you love their food, then by all means support them. And if you’ve never been there, give it a try. maybe they make everything just the way you like it. But for me… it was a disappointing waste of money and I will definitely not be going back. I hate disappointing food, but I hate it even more when I pay a lot for it.
… moreAnd then the chilli. I mean, it’s chilli. How do you mess it up? Well, one way is by using the greasiest meat you can find. There was so much oil in it that I could bearely taste anything besides the oil. Barely any spiciness either, but that’s fine, because chilli doesn’t have to be super spicy. I never hold that against it. But this stuff wasn’t spicy, super oily, and barely tasted of anything at all. For the amount of chilli, I think $6 was an everage price, but for the quality I got, I wouldn’t have even taken a free bowl
A large hoagie and a cup of chilli was almost $30. Insanity. I could have gotten a nice steak dinner at a decent steakhouse for that much. I could have gotten a full rack of out of this world ribs, with sides, for that much. If you love their food, then by all means support them. And if you’ve never been there, give it a try. maybe they make everything just the way you like it. But for me… it was a disappointing waste of money and I will definitely not be going back. I hate disappointing food, but I hate it even more when I pay a lot for it.
Fan Li
Sandwiches are delicious! My husband has been ordering the roast beef sandwiches here since he discovered this small shop. It can get quite busy, so be sure to order in advance.
… more#Hashtag SteveJ
Nice sandwich shop. Super friendly service! Great selection was sandwiches, soups, hot sandwiches, cold sandwiches, potato chips, sodas, salads! Small inside with a few seats. Nice big sandwiches full of meat.
… moreChristina Mitchell
I just tried this place today for a take-out lunch, and it was excellent. They freshly sliced the meat and cheese to order, which I can really appreciate! I ordered the Super Italian, and they didn’t skimp on meat, plus the price was a good value. The bread was fresh and soft, too. I will definitely be back!
… moredoug mcgill
They have the best sandwiches around. Employees are kind and courteous. It’s nice when you can find good food and the customer service is even better.
… moreCey Lan
The breakfast burritos are out of this world!! Everyone here is super nice & friendly, and love the fact that I can order online through Clover. Will definitely keep coming here☺️
… moreSteve Lipman
The best place around to get delicious Italian subs. I can vouch for their subs, sandwiches, mozzarella sticks, and cheese fries because they’re my usual order. But, if the rest of their menu is as good what I usually order you can’t go wrong. I absolutely love this place and you won’t be disappointed !
… more