Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
A big menu of pizza, pastas & sandwiches, plus kids’ fare, served in an upbeat faux-rustic room.
Hours
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 275 S Main St, Colchester, CT 06415
Phone: (860) 537-3996
Website: http://www.theplumtomato.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Colchester Menu – The Plum Tomato
To see our most updated menu, please visit our online menu powered by Toast –. https://order.toasttab.com/online/the-plum-tomato-colchester-ct-275-s-main-st.
The Plum Tomato – Food So Good, It’s Addictive.
… Colchester Menu · Salem Menu · East Lyme Menu · Weekly Cravings · Beverage Menu. Parties. Birthday Parties · Field Trips · Catering · Contact Us · General …
The Plum Tomato Colchester CT – Order Online
Order online from Colchester CT, including Appetizers, Salads, Wings/Tenders. Get the best prices and service by ordering direct!
Reviews
Angie Cordeiro
Health hazards, vanishing service, and a ruined holiday evening
I am honestly in shock at how horrible this experience was. Our party of 4 stopped in for what we hoped would be a nice dinner before a scheduled drive through the Christmas lights; instead, we left hungry, frustrated, and appalled.
The issues started immediately. We stood by the “please wait here to be seated” sign only to have someone yell at us from across the restaurant to just sit wherever we wanted. Despite the restaurant being more than half empty, the service was nonexistent. After taking our initial drink and food orders, our waitress completely vanished.
After 30 minutes of sitting with empty glasses, we had to flag down a different waiter just to get soda refills. After 50 minutes of waiting with no food, we finally asked to cancel our check because we had a schedule to keep. The waiter claimed they were “busy” with a nearly two-hour backup for takeout, which was a blatant lie—we were there for nearly an hour and did not see a single person come in for a pickup. There were at least four people in the kitchen, another 2 serving and only a handful of tables occupied; there was no excuse for that kind of delay.
When the food finally arrived, it was insulting.
The Meatballs: Served steaming hot on the outside but piping cold and pink/raw in the middle. It was clear they were tossed in a microwave and not actually cooked through. (The pink is hard to see in the pictures but you can clearly tell by comparison which one is cooked and which is noy)
The Calzones: These were a joke. It was a massive pile of dough filled with cold, skim-milk ricotta and a tiny sprinkle of mozzarella that hadn’t even begun to melt—it was still in its shredded form. My pepperoni calzone contained exactly three slices of pepperoni.
When we finally got our waitress to return to the table to show her the undercooked, inedible food, she offered no excuses or apologies. She acted like it was a chore to deal with us. We refused to pay for such a pathetic attempt at a meal and had to run to the McDonald’s next door just to ensure we actually ate something cooked before our event.
The inability of a pizza restaurant to make a simple, cooked calzone is pathetic. We will never be back, and we will be sure to warn everyone we know to avoid The Plum Tomato.
… moreI am honestly in shock at how horrible this experience was. Our party of 4 stopped in for what we hoped would be a nice dinner before a scheduled drive through the Christmas lights; instead, we left hungry, frustrated, and appalled.
The issues started immediately. We stood by the “please wait here to be seated” sign only to have someone yell at us from across the restaurant to just sit wherever we wanted. Despite the restaurant being more than half empty, the service was nonexistent. After taking our initial drink and food orders, our waitress completely vanished.
After 30 minutes of sitting with empty glasses, we had to flag down a different waiter just to get soda refills. After 50 minutes of waiting with no food, we finally asked to cancel our check because we had a schedule to keep. The waiter claimed they were “busy” with a nearly two-hour backup for takeout, which was a blatant lie—we were there for nearly an hour and did not see a single person come in for a pickup. There were at least four people in the kitchen, another 2 serving and only a handful of tables occupied; there was no excuse for that kind of delay.
When the food finally arrived, it was insulting.
The Meatballs: Served steaming hot on the outside but piping cold and pink/raw in the middle. It was clear they were tossed in a microwave and not actually cooked through. (The pink is hard to see in the pictures but you can clearly tell by comparison which one is cooked and which is noy)
The Calzones: These were a joke. It was a massive pile of dough filled with cold, skim-milk ricotta and a tiny sprinkle of mozzarella that hadn’t even begun to melt—it was still in its shredded form. My pepperoni calzone contained exactly three slices of pepperoni.
When we finally got our waitress to return to the table to show her the undercooked, inedible food, she offered no excuses or apologies. She acted like it was a chore to deal with us. We refused to pay for such a pathetic attempt at a meal and had to run to the McDonald’s next door just to ensure we actually ate something cooked before our event.
The inability of a pizza restaurant to make a simple, cooked calzone is pathetic. We will never be back, and we will be sure to warn everyone we know to avoid The Plum Tomato.
Marina
I ordered a large Leo Da Vinci pizza…12 shrimps for a large! Shrimp is the main ingredient in that pizza. 12 shrimp for $28.99? Really is shameful. I understand prices go up, but the quality of the food should NOT go down.
… moreMoriah Turcotte
I mean yes the food is amazing — but the service is what really separates this place. Liz, Jaden, Kim — they are incredible. They are attentive, kind, friendly. Honestly they treat you like family. They remember our order! Incredible servers. Come and eat here- you won’t be disappointed! -Ryker and Moriah
… moreKiara Irizarry
I try my best to go somewhere multiple times before leaving a review. My family was hoping this would turn into one of our go to spots but after tonight we probably won’t return. A deal breaker for us is inconsistentcy. We came by a few weeks ago and everything was pretty delicious. Tonight the margarita pizza was extremely undercooked, the fries tasted like they were fried in old oil and the sandwich was cold. It’s too bad because the service was good and we were looking forward to it.
… moreA B
Really good pizza restaurant. They make a great New York/New Haven style pizza. This is my favorite go to spot for pizza. They do sell by the slice which is nice because it’s hard to do a whole pie anymore. Sometimes their crusts are too large and their prices for a slice went up significantly recently (which means less purchases for me). Sauce is good. They will warm up the slices for you. They generally have good food handling here as well. Occasionally some of their young male employees will touch your slice while sliding into the take out box (yuck) but most of the employees know to use a glove or parchment paper.
… moreJonathan Berman
Needed to grab lunch in Colchester when friends came to visit. Varied menu that allowed us to order snd est family style. Great prices. Great dining room, fanulous service. Best, plenty of time to talk on a slow midweek afternoin.
… moreCarrie VanCamp
Plum Tomato continues to be our Go-To restaurant every time! The servers are attentive and friendly and our pizza is always cooked the way we like it. In addition, we love the locally sourced ingredients and beverage offerings. Jayden, Liz and Kim treat us like family in the dining room and the takeout staff do as well. Keep up the great work Plum!
… moreBrian Bergeron
This is our favorite place! Liz, Kim, and Jaden are all phenomenal and make our Friday nights so enjoyable. Woodfired pizzas are great and they will even make us a special Nashville Hot Chiclen Pizza which is not on the menu. Whenever our out of town guest visit us they always want us to take them to the Plum Tomato! Best pizza place ever!!!!!!!
… moreJustin Lopez
I enjoyed the death kiss and godfather pizza. Great service, atmosphere, and food.
… moreRyker Turcotte
Our favorite place to come on any night of the week! The servers are the real highlight. Always friendly and saying hi, checking on us— they refill my glass before it’s empty! Jaden, Liz, and Kim feel more like friends than servers! The food is also good every time. Worth the visit!
… more