David Botros
A must-do dining experience!
My visit to The Old Post Office Restaurant – Fish boil was absolutely fantastic. The entire experience felt so unique—it was much more than just a meal. Watching the fish boil while hearing the history behind it was both entertaining and informative.
And the food itself was incredible. The fish was as fresh and delicious as it gets, don’t forget to add the table spice and butter. I’m still dreaming about the cherry pie. It was the perfect ending to a memorable meal.
I can’t wait to go back and do it all over again. If you’re looking for a great meal and a fun experience, this is the place!
… moreFelicia Chang
Delicious breakfast spot with a dog friendly patio. The views are so nice from the outdoor seating area. The pancakes were incredibly fluffy and delicious. The classic eggs, sausage and sourdough toast were all very fresh and tasty as well. Highly recommend to start your day here.
… moreDonita Micile
We had a wonderful experience at the traditional fish boil! It was both fun and informative to watch the boil take place before being seated at our assigned table. The servers were efficient and even de-boned the fish right in front of us, which was a nice touch. I also appreciated that there were a couple of alternative options available for those who don’t eat fish.
The meal itself was delicious—especially with the vessel of melted butter to pour over the fish, potatoes, and onion. The cherry pie at the end was the perfect sweet finish. The setting made the evening even more special, as we enjoyed a beautiful sunset view over the lake from our table.
Another highlight was that our dog was welcome, which made the outing even better. Overall, a great experience combining tradition, great food, and a scenic atmosphere. Highly recommend!
… moreMaddi Hohl (MajesticMango12)
One of my favorite restaurants in the whole peninsula. They provide a great history lesson when cooking about 30 minutes before dinner. They have great seating inside and outside. The workers are all very friendly and provide attentive service. We went there for breakfast and dinner in one day because we enjoyed it so much!
… moreWendy B
We visited The Old Post Office Restaurant with a bus tour of 45 people and the staff ran this place like a well oiled machine!! We loved the experience of an authentic fish boil. The boil master was entertaining and the food was delicious!
… moreSharon Luo
The Old Post Office fish boil is a must-do for us every time we’re in Door County. Watching the boil-over is always such a fun tradition, and the staff make the experience special by explaining the process. The whitefish is fresh and delicious, with hearty sides of potatoes, onions, and bread. Friendly service and a welcoming atmosphere make it a classic we always look forward to.
… morecrack95
Great experience. We went for the fish boil, get the 30-45min before and they explain the heritage of the fish boil and do a boil over. The waitress will mostly debone your fish, found a couple, for you. We are out side, moan what a view from the patio
… moreRenee Walsten
The fish boil is amazing! Fresh white fish caught locally. Prepared in a fun informative demonstration. Wait staff are friendly, efficient and knowledgeable.
The meal is delicious! And it’s a great value.
… moreKari Owens
We have been to Door County twice now. The fish boil at the Old Post Office was on our ‘must repeat’ list. We (2 adults and a teen) enjoyed the pre-meal excitement of watching the food being cooked outside in the kettle over the fire. The fireball is always exciting!
The food includes 2 significant fish steaks, potatoes, onions, cole slaw, and 3 kinds of fresh bread… with lots of melted butter. There is homemade cherry pie for dessert. (A la mode costs extra).
Our server was pleasant. We appreciated that she de-boned the fish for us.
All in all, a fantastic and very filling dining experience.
… moreMaria Martinez
Great fish boil experience in a picturesque environment! Reasonable prices for the amount of food too. A quick walk across the street after dinner to watch amazing sunsets.
… more