j handy (Handyman review)
Pizza was very good! We ordered the Brooklyn and the flavors reminded me of the street fairs when i was a kid back in NYC (sausage peppers and onion) crust was crispy and well cooked! I dont think the dough anywhere down here in FL can match NYC but maybe its the water…. i like the decorations and it was very clean! Service was fine. Im not a fan of people talking to their earpods while ordering but its 2026….. overall great dinner
… moreBrandan Leak
I must’ve been the first customer of the day and I walked in about 12pm. Greeted politely by a young man who took my order for 1 pepperoni slice and a cheese slice. I know “Last Night’s” pizza when I see it. I’m not sure I will risk my already short lunch break on another try.
… moreJeanice Martin
The best pizza I’ve had in a while! Tried the pepperoni and meat lovers… both were AMAZING!!!
… moreChung Ng
Pizza is good but the crust was very tough. I asked for extra crispy and I don’t think they know what that means. Maybe is a grand opening. Not sure and I didn’t know they charge a surcharge for using a credit card.
… moreMariah Matt
The NY Pizza Place @thenypizzaplace
Tamarac, FL
Follow @eatzwithsweetz on ig and fb for more!
New to the neighborhood so I had to swing in!
Here’s what I had:
Garlic Knots
NY Style Pizza 20″
Limoncello Cake
Everything was fresh and delicious
When are you stopping by?
#TheNYPizzaPlace #Tamarac #GrandOpening #NewRestaurant #Pizza #NYstyle #GarlicKnots #Limoncello #PizzaLover #LetsDrinkz #EatzWithSweetz #LetsEatz
… moreRay Montalvo
Thrilled that this space has been taken over by a team of people that brought an updated look and feel to it! The pizza quality does reminds me of that well known NYC brand all of us transplants remember fondly. Welcome to the neighborhood. May you have great success!!!
… moreAndrea M
I finally got around to trying this place and I regret not trying it sooner. Their pizza hit the spot! The crust was delicious with the perfect amount of crunch and chew, no cheap sweetness to the sauce, and the bake was spot on. I’m happy they moved into the neighborhood and I can’t wait to try the rest of the menu.
… moreDaiana Alexandra Rojas
First time trying this place (we ordered take out) and the staff was so friendly. I had a few questions since it was our first time trying this restaurant and the guy was so kind and patient. The pizza was delicious! Super big pies which surprised me but they were so so good. The pepperoni pizza was amazing and the garlic rolls with the side or marinara sauce was crazy good! That marinara made my night lol. Can’t wait to try some of the other pizza and dishes they offer
… moreYanick
Overpriced 14″ pizza for $23. Let’s not insult a great NY Pizza with pizza from the NY Pizza Place. This is far from a real NY Pizza. I am a born and raised New Yorker and this burnt pizza was the worst pizza I’ve ever had. Waste of money, I attempted to eat one slice but too burnt to finish so it went to the garbage. Never again.
… moreAmy Pisani
I recently visited The NY Pizza Place and it was a fantastic experience from start to finish. The staff were super friendly and welcoming, creating a laid-back and comfortable atmosphere.
The pizza was great — perfectly crispy crust, fresh toppings, and just the right amount of cheese. I had the Lasgana pizza and it had a great balance of flavor. You can tell they really care about quality ingredients.
Service was quick, prices were fair, and the place was clean and cozy. It’s clear that this spot can become a local favorite. Definitely coming back soon!
… more