Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
The Magic Oyster is tantalizing the taste buds of oyster lovers with a varied selection of Gulf, East & West Coast oysters, along with other seafood and land-lubber dishes. Inspired by “Island Living,” the interior has a colorful and casual atmosphere and is the perfect place to unwind with friends – enjoying tropical libations, local craft beers, and “Raw Bar” fare. Dinner is served nightly and features signature dishes like the Horseradish Encrusted Grouper, Seafood Cioppino, and Stuffed Shrimp. Customers can also enjoy a drink at the bar or patio during happy hour, featured daily. To keep things fresh, The Magic Oyster also features rotating dinner specials, so you can always try something new!
Seafood eatery & oyster bar with nautical decor, ocean-blue accents, patio dining & an upbeat vibe.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 10999 S Ocean Dr, Jensen Beach, FL 34957
Phone: (772) 877-3139
Website: http://themagicoyster.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
The Magic Oyster | Bar and Seafood Grill in Jensen Beach, Florida
Calling ahead for availability is recommended: (772) 877-3139. Please call after 3pm, ideally at least one hour before your desired dining time.
Magic Oyster Bar and Seafood Grill | Jensen Beach FL – Facebook
The Magic Oyster features a variety of fresh oysters, great craft beers, creative seafood dishes and
Magic Oyster Bar & Seafood Grill of Jensen Beach, FL – Martin County
Open for lunch and dinner. Address. 10999 S Ocean Dr. Jensen Beach, FL 34957. Phone. (772) 877-3139. Visit Website. Tripadvisor ® Traveler Rating.
Reviews
Olga Mikhailova
We often come to this restaurant with our family and always have a great experience.
The oysters are incredibly fresh and absolutely delicious. They have a wide variety of seafood options on the menu, so there’s something for everyone.
The prices are very reasonable, especially for the quality of food you get.
Definitely one of our favorite spots!
… moreThe oysters are incredibly fresh and absolutely delicious. They have a wide variety of seafood options on the menu, so there’s something for everyone.
The prices are very reasonable, especially for the quality of food you get.
Definitely one of our favorite spots!
Hannah Harrison
I’m out of town on a work trip and needed a GOOD meal and yall delivered!! From the moment I sat down-until the very end. Perfect service and delicious food. Sydney was the best waitress!!
I will def be back. THANK YOU again for wonderful service and food tonight.
… moreI will def be back. THANK YOU again for wonderful service and food tonight.
Amy Ziegler
We NEVER have a bad meal at the Magic Oyster and our servers are always amazing! You can’t go wrong with anything you order! I usually get the horseradish grouper and it’s super delicious! 10/10 would recommend!
… moreKallie Gonzalo
My husband and I are 72 and we stopped by on Tuesday last week while on vacation and had such a great experience! We wanted to post a review last week but didn’t get the chance to because we got too busy. We don’t usually do reviews and I don’t recall we ever have but we loved this restaurant and we will be coming back when we are back in town on vacation. To start The short blonde girl about 15-16 working out front I think she said her name was Bailey was genuinely so sweet and welcoming from the moment we walked in she greeted us with a smile and made us feel comfortable right away. She had such a positive attitude and made the whole visit even better. It’s always nice to see someone that young treating customers with so much kindness and respect. She held the door as we were walking in and as we were walking out, it was honestly so cute and refreshing to see. She’s such a great representation of your restaurant you don’t see that very often in younger people. We sat in the booths towards the front of the restaurant in the corner, it was comfortable and The food was very good my husband got the grouper Reuben and I got the Jambalaya and everything was perfect up to the drinks, food, and service. Our server was rude at a certain point she seemed stressed but we understand how hard the food business can be so we didn’t mind it. Everything was affordable and absolutely delicious thank you so much! I would rate it a 9/10 only because the server did get rude towards the end.
… moreJill Booth
I believe our server, Kernan, was amazing. The food was terrible. The server was incredibly kind and some of the best service ever. The manager was an interesting person..We didn’t eat one of the meals at all due to the rancid smell of it and she made our waitress pay for our dinner and refused to take it off our check. The waitress was nearly in tears with how the manager spoke to her. We did not let the waitress pay for our dinner. We paid in full for our meals ($167 and no one liked their dinner) The manager doesn’t understand what it means to be a manager. I do not recommend this establishment at all. But Kernan could get any job she ever wanted, that girl was gracious, kind, positive, and had much better leadership qualities than her manager. Kernan, you are awesome! We loved your great attitude!
… moreScott McClannahan
We visited The Magic Oyster Bar in Jensen Beach on a recent family vacation, and it quickly became one of our favorite spots of the trip.
The first night, we kicked things off with a round of oysters — both Rockefeller and on the half shell — and they were fresh, flavorful, and perfectly prepared. My girlfriend and I split the Lobster Ravioli, and it was absolutely delicious. Rich, creamy, and packed with lobster flavor — it hit the spot without being too heavy.
We enjoyed it so much that we ended up coming back a second time before the trip was over. This time, almost all of us ordered the Fried Seafood Platter, and it did not disappoint. Crispy, well-seasoned, and generously portioned — everything you’d want from a coastal seafood joint.
The vibe is relaxed and beachy, and the service both times was friendly and efficient. Whether you’re into oysters, classic seafood dishes, or just looking for a fun place to eat with family, Magic Oyster Bar really delivers.
Highly recommend if you’re in the Jensen Beach area — we’ll definitely be back next time we’re in town!
Our only complaint – they don’t open until 4 pm, so no chance of having a quick lunch between swims! (Although they do have a happy hour at 3 pm but you can’t sit in the restaurant, only the bar)
… moreThe first night, we kicked things off with a round of oysters — both Rockefeller and on the half shell — and they were fresh, flavorful, and perfectly prepared. My girlfriend and I split the Lobster Ravioli, and it was absolutely delicious. Rich, creamy, and packed with lobster flavor — it hit the spot without being too heavy.
We enjoyed it so much that we ended up coming back a second time before the trip was over. This time, almost all of us ordered the Fried Seafood Platter, and it did not disappoint. Crispy, well-seasoned, and generously portioned — everything you’d want from a coastal seafood joint.
The vibe is relaxed and beachy, and the service both times was friendly and efficient. Whether you’re into oysters, classic seafood dishes, or just looking for a fun place to eat with family, Magic Oyster Bar really delivers.
Highly recommend if you’re in the Jensen Beach area — we’ll definitely be back next time we’re in town!
Our only complaint – they don’t open until 4 pm, so no chance of having a quick lunch between swims! (Although they do have a happy hour at 3 pm but you can’t sit in the restaurant, only the bar)
D T
Visiting from the frozen underworld that is known as Quebec (Canada). May I be so bold as to paraphrase my dining review with the statement that we have never ever had decent seafood at any Florida restaurants (other than a very good Bonefish Cafe in Orlando, back in 2020).
Our host and waiter were excellent – we also had a second waiter who stopped by to ask if our food and drinks were to our satisfaction. Pleasant and not pushy; A1 service overall.
Our food was really good; grouper sandwich, seafood linguine and jambalaya. The portions were massive “American size”, and yes, we were warned.
The restaurant had a very pleasant casual ambience and was clean.
Prices were very appropriate.
Thanks for a very decent seafood meal Magic Oyster (and staff).
… moreOur host and waiter were excellent – we also had a second waiter who stopped by to ask if our food and drinks were to our satisfaction. Pleasant and not pushy; A1 service overall.
Our food was really good; grouper sandwich, seafood linguine and jambalaya. The portions were massive “American size”, and yes, we were warned.
The restaurant had a very pleasant casual ambience and was clean.
Prices were very appropriate.
Thanks for a very decent seafood meal Magic Oyster (and staff).
Noelle Amon
Happy hour is every day 3pm-6pm only in the bar area/high tops.
Our waiter was Dwayne and we came for happy hour from 315pm-350pm. The only good part of the entire experience was the oysters and magic cakes.
The other items we ordered were clams, mozzarella sticks, pretzel bites and chicken tenders. The pretzel bites were SO HARD. When I say these were overcooked I literally pulled one off the plate and showed Dwayne how hard it was when he checked in on us. You can HEAR how it was clearly over cooked and inedible. Dwayne did not offer to comp or provide us with any other food. I tried to eat what I could but it wasn’t even safe to give my 1 year old son. All he was able to eat was the mozzarella sticks and I gave him two bites of the magic cake.
It was a not the best experience. I used to be a happy hour server and bartender in IL for several years. I typically don’t even bring up if service or food isn’t the best but with pretzel bites? I don’t understand how it was THAT overcooked. I understand it’s happy hour and you get what you pay for.. did I mention that the mozzarella sticks & chicken tenders basically felt like they were microwavable food?
I wish I went to a better happy hour. I’m very disappointed.
… moreOur waiter was Dwayne and we came for happy hour from 315pm-350pm. The only good part of the entire experience was the oysters and magic cakes.
The other items we ordered were clams, mozzarella sticks, pretzel bites and chicken tenders. The pretzel bites were SO HARD. When I say these were overcooked I literally pulled one off the plate and showed Dwayne how hard it was when he checked in on us. You can HEAR how it was clearly over cooked and inedible. Dwayne did not offer to comp or provide us with any other food. I tried to eat what I could but it wasn’t even safe to give my 1 year old son. All he was able to eat was the mozzarella sticks and I gave him two bites of the magic cake.
It was a not the best experience. I used to be a happy hour server and bartender in IL for several years. I typically don’t even bring up if service or food isn’t the best but with pretzel bites? I don’t understand how it was THAT overcooked. I understand it’s happy hour and you get what you pay for.. did I mention that the mozzarella sticks & chicken tenders basically felt like they were microwavable food?
I wish I went to a better happy hour. I’m very disappointed.
Juan guillermo Orozco
As a Private Chef I can say this place its awesome, great quality seafood and great costumer service, my new hidden favorite place!!!
… moreI. P. Dailey
Absolutely stellar! The menu offers something for everyone, and the specials added even more variety, at prices that I considered a value, when accounting for the quality of the fare. The pretzel crusted Mahi was divine, and the cocktails were top shelf. Topping it all off, the service we received from Bailey was exceptional, and I can’t recommend the Magical Oyster Bar highly enough. Kudos to everyone there, keep up the great work!
… more