Valery Gonzalez
We ordered a stuffed crust 18″ pizza 50/50 with works and brushetta. Slice sizes were large enough to fold. Crust was interesting. It was easier to rip the bottom crust than it was to cut it. The brushetta had a nice garlic butter flavor with basil but the works didn’t seem to have much flavor. There wasn’t much sauce. The crust as seen in the video was very minimal. I cut an entire slice open and there’s barely any cheese its mostly air. The pizza did include 2 cups of marinara. The employees are pleasant. The pricing wasn’t very clear until I asked what the extra charges were for. They do offer a military discount [thank you].
… moreJo Occulis
Great service all around hands-down! Allison and Jorge provided great customer service And made us feel so welcome we will definitely come back. Everything tasted delicious from the garlic parm sandwich, to the lasagna and the garlic knots and also the soup. They have earned some new fans my wife and I will always be around from now on!
… moreKassi Cusumano
Absolutely delicious!! By far one of the best pizza places we have found since moving to Florida and it’s been well over a decade! It’s about 45 minutes from us but 100% worth the drive and we will definitely be back. The pizza was thin, crispy and had the perfect amount of sauce and cheese. So so good. The garlic “knots” aren’t quite knots and were lacking garlic so those could definitely be improved upon but they were light and airy. Tasty for sure, but definitely not a traditional knot. Highly recommend if you’re looking for some authentic NY/NJ pizza!
… moreJudith dawson
First time here and it did not disappoint! Tommy was awesome, he is so friendly, helpful and provided great service! Food was a m a z I n g! I have watched their FB reels for months now and so glad I finally went! Definitely will be back to try their garlic knots pie crust!
… moreAmber Robles
This place nails true New York–style pizza. The crust is perfectly thin with that classic fold, the sauce is spot on, and the cheese ratio is exactly what it should be. You can tell it’s made with care and tradition. Every bite tastes like something you’d grab from a neighborhood spot in NYC. On top of that, their daily deals are fantastic and genuinely remind you of the kind of specials you’d find back home in New York. Great quality, great value, and consistently delicious. This is now our go-to pizza spot.
… moreAshley Larson
The staff, Tommy and Allison were so kind and attentive. We ordered the garlic knots and mozzarella sticks for apps. Both were so good, but the garlic knots!! Oooo weee! We are coming back just for those. We then ordered the chicken parm pizza and the meat pizza. We asked Tommy to upgrade one each with the garlic knot crust and the stuffed crust based on what he thinks would be best for them. We got the chicken parm with a stuffed crust and the meat pizza with the garlic knot crust, again 10/10! We also tried a cannoli and a jersey bomb (just know this thing is a dessert for the whole table), but both were also amazing. You won’t be disappointed with this place!
… moreJG
I’ve been wanting to try this place for many months since it popped up as a Facebook ad for me. We drove over a hour to get here to try it. The waiter/cashier was very pleasant and the food was really good. I’d give the pizza a solid 7/10 and appearance was 10/10. It was seriously one of the best looking pizzas I’ve ever seen. We got the garlic knot crust which was fun. My mom got a sub which was massive and she said it was extremely tasty too. I will definitely be back next time I’m in the area. There isn’t much for good pizza near Disney so I’d make the bit of an extra drive and come here next time I stay at Disney.
… moreAngelina Muniz
Was in search of a good pizza place in the area and found jersey shop. This place had AMAZING garlic knots and food. Shout out to Tommy for the great service. Would definitely come again!
… moreMaria-Fernanda Vera
The food was sooo good ! We will def come back again. Best is the best I’ve had in the area. The calamari is amazing. Allison was amazing ! She was so sweet and attentive and def gave some good recommendations. The jersey spot will be seeing us soon.
… moreEli Zaragoza
We decided to try this place for the first time after seeing it on TikTok, and it did not disappoint! Everything we ordered was delicious, and the service was excellent. We’ll definitely be back.
… more