Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Low-key outpost serving American breakfast-thru-dinner fare such as eggs, burgers, beer & wine.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 63 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Phone: (631) 749-1998
Website: http://www.theislandersi.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
The Islander
A classic family restaurant on beautiful Shelter Island. We specialize in classic comfort food for the whole family. We are open for breakfast and lunch 7 days …
The Islander | Shelter Island NY – Facebook
We offer custom catering with or without our food truck. Call or stop by and let us help you plan your next event. 631.749.1998
The Islander (@theislandersi) · Shelter Island, NY – Instagram
A family restaurant on beautiful Shelter Island, specializing in classic comfort food. Check us out in the Winter 2026 edition of Newsday’s FeedMe Magazine …
Reviews
Mike McGill
I just want t say I was there yesterday with our group knights on Bikes we had 17 bikes and 25 people and the waitress was fantastic she gave us unbelievable service with a great attitude doing it. The cook inside was working his tale off as well getting the food out very quickly for us. I can’t say enough the service and food was great. Thank You from our entire group
Mike President Knights on Bikes
… moreMike President Knights on Bikes
Sylvia
Just good diner food. Tacos and Fish and chips were tasty. French fries and salad with dressing, decent. The best part about the place is the cleanliness. The single server who was helping us on Monday, September 8 was a constant stream of activity, cleaning surfaces sweeping, just making sure everything was perfect. The islander is lucky to have her.
We came too early in the day for burger night. But we hope to come back on Monday for burger night.
… moreWe came too early in the day for burger night. But we hope to come back on Monday for burger night.
Vincent Ty
The tomato soup was the creamiest yet strong tomato taste I ever had. The shrimp taco was alright.
… moreMartha Gallen
Burger and fries were great, definitely would recommend the fried pickles!!! Waitress was very nice and attentive. We waited for the food a bit but that was the only negative
… moreJeff Kubala
Good variety. Quick moving. Cash only. The regulars keep their mugs hanging below the specials board. Many different local beers available. I liked the pancakes and sausage.
… moreTricia Johnson
Great breakfast food, but coffee could have been much better. Nice simple decor, and very clean. We definitely would go back.
… moreTerri Wise
Needed some lunch this was recommended to us. We had a very good meal!!!
… moreHenry
I’ve gone here my whole life, but two disappointing experiences recently.
1. On a weekend morning it was well understaffed with mediocre service, overheard multiple people get incorrect orders, the server was unable to communicate in English with the new employee who was supposed to help her I guess? She was getting upset at him.
2. (different day) A cash only restaurant should be able to break an 100$, I was sent to Chase myself when they didn’t have change.
Food is consistent but service definitely is not.
… more1. On a weekend morning it was well understaffed with mediocre service, overheard multiple people get incorrect orders, the server was unable to communicate in English with the new employee who was supposed to help her I guess? She was getting upset at him.
2. (different day) A cash only restaurant should be able to break an 100$, I was sent to Chase myself when they didn’t have change.
Food is consistent but service definitely is not.
Christine R
This diner did not disappoint! Jenna was so kind to everyone she spoke with, the restaurant was clean and the food was delicious! Excellent pick!
… moreShana Barone
This place is a delight. The decor is charming and bright and the menu is excellent. We had omelettes and pancakes and our little one had chicken nuggets and fries. The salads looked super fresh and big, and the burgers did as well. Friendly service and conveniently located in the middle of the island. We will definitely be back. Go here with family, friends, or even alone. Many people got take out while we were there too.
… more