Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in
… View more
Straightforward restaurant with a bar & a relaxed ambiance, dishing up seafood, steaks & wild game.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 619 Baltimore St, Gettysburg, PA 17325
Phone: (717) 542-9947
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
The Hoof, Fin & Fowl | Gettysburg PA – Facebook
Refined casual dining in historic Gettysburg, PA with a fresh, made-from-scratch kitchen and amazing
The Hoof, Fin & Fowl | Unique Dining in Gettysburg, PA
Located at 619 Baltimore St, this charming restaurant is a true gem, offering an unforgettable mix of flavors and a warm, inviting atmosphere. Whether you’re in …
Gettysburg restaurant announces upcoming closure – ABC27
The Hoof, Fin & Fowl restaurant, which is located at 619 Baltimore Street in Gettysburg, just announced on Facebook over the weekend that …
Reviews
John C
My spouse had the fish sandwich, I had the Marry Me Chicken. Local wines and a great atmosphere. First time here and it’s now part of our top three restaurants in town. Plenty of free parking and very affordable, a meal with adult beverages went off at $30 a person. Our server Lana was as sweet as peach pie. Speaking of peaches, Lisa got a peach old fashioned made with fresh local peaches. WOW! it was good.
… moreRebecca Lee
We have paid much more for smaller proportions and not as well prepared or cooked.
Our meal was wonderful
Crab legs were cooked perfectly.
Duck was seasoned well.
Steamed clams were perfect!
Staff is knowledgeable and friendly, able to accommodate us quite well.
… moreOur meal was wonderful
Crab legs were cooked perfectly.
Duck was seasoned well.
Steamed clams were perfect!
Staff is knowledgeable and friendly, able to accommodate us quite well.
Emily Good
Cute little spot for food. They are boyb, but do have alcohol available for purchase. We did not have a wait on a Friday night. All our food was delicious.
… moreKevin & Crystal
This is our second time in and it was very good. I’m confused why their overall rating is on the lower side. The food is fantastic!!! We were there for dinner last year on our trip to Gettysburg and stopped in for lunch this year. The food is always prepared exactly how we requested. Server was friendly, the place seems clean. Great location. We really like it here and will be back next time in town.
… moreChristine Convery
This place is a sleeper. Did not come up on any recommended lists but you should not miss it! Also dog friendly on the deck/outside area. The name of the restaurant is honestly a little off putting – they should consider changing it. But every single item we ate was absolutely delicious, even the salad and warm bread (included with entrees). My husband had a bone in pork chop and I had the crab cake entree. Crab cake was one the best I have ever had and the pork chop so good my husband picked it up and tried to eat the remaining meat off the bone. The crab cake came with Brussels sprouts that were so good. Our server was terrific, friendly and attentive. Definitely recommend this restaurant!
… moreEric Leukhardt
We went there for our anniversary tonight. We ordered the lamb chops with rice pilaf and green beans. The other dish was Ahi tuna with rice pilaf and squash. The order took FOREVER to come out. The atmosphere was very strange. The food finally came out and what a huge disappointment. The lamb chops were raw on the inside, and both plates of rice pilaf were hard as a rock. The waitress couldn’t have been better! She looked at the lamb chops and said “oh my god, I’m so sorry”. We walked out and just ate the tuna, which was just “ok”. Definitely a 1 and done for us.By the way, the waitress still got a good tip, wasn’t her fault. The cooks need to go!
… moreBirgitt Adams
We drove by The Hoof, Fin and Fowl and saw that under the sign it advertises with Steamed Crabs, Seafood, Steak & Exotic Cuisine. Well this was a no brainer we wanted to try it out. We looked at the menu online and were excited! Until we saw the menu in person – no burgers, sandwiches etc
The highlight was the bartender and server. Both were nice and friendly. We had the duck breast and Fish and chips. Both were supposed to come with a side salad and rolls. We received the side salad (very small but fresh), no rolls were served. More did any other table get rolls and we overheard them saying “We haven’t have rolls in a long time”.
The duck breast was good, however was sprinkled with duck sauce – not bad, just odd. The Fish and chips were ok, fish was good, coleslaw tart but fresh, and the fries not edible. The fries were double or triple fried, they were hard and saturated with oil.
We had high hopes for this mom n pop restaurant. Hopefully they can fix the issues and make it work.
Again the bartender and server were the best part of our dinning experience. Very kind and nice!
… moreThe highlight was the bartender and server. Both were nice and friendly. We had the duck breast and Fish and chips. Both were supposed to come with a side salad and rolls. We received the side salad (very small but fresh), no rolls were served. More did any other table get rolls and we overheard them saying “We haven’t have rolls in a long time”.
The duck breast was good, however was sprinkled with duck sauce – not bad, just odd. The Fish and chips were ok, fish was good, coleslaw tart but fresh, and the fries not edible. The fries were double or triple fried, they were hard and saturated with oil.
We had high hopes for this mom n pop restaurant. Hopefully they can fix the issues and make it work.
Again the bartender and server were the best part of our dinning experience. Very kind and nice!
Jared Backus
We were very happy with our visit here . The food was great . One of the best burgers I ever had,my girlfriend loved the chicken/avocado wrap and there amazing chocolate cake. I had cream of crab soup and it was the best I ever had for real. Great service by Sarah.
… moreLiss Smith
I am not sure the reason why the ratings in this restaurant aren’t better. My family and I really enjoyed the environment, music, but more importantly, the service and great food.
Not overpriced and no waiting in line to be seated. We will definitely come back!
… moreNot overpriced and no waiting in line to be seated. We will definitely come back!
Carly
I love this place. I love this place so much I want to come back just to eat here again. We had the crab balls, steamed shrimp, Maryland Crab Soup (tastes like Granny’s Maryland Crab Soup”), fish and chips, and a dozen Maryland oysters. It was so good I’m ready to go back and do it all over again in a few weeks. And then I came back later that evening, when I knew not where to go to get a bottle of wine, and got a bottle of Hungry Run watermelon strawberry and it was magic in a glass. I’ll say no more. This place is the giving tree of restaurants.
… more