Leonard Prencipe
It’s been years since I’ve been to the cove. I love what they have done here with the outside dining. Wonderful atmosphere with the water running near by and the wooded area. We ordered appetizers steamed shrimp and mussels and our entrees filet and crabcake combo, and a crab cake. Unfortunately our server brought everything at the same time. I did say i thought that when we said we wanted the shrimp and mussels as our appetizer they would come out as an appetizer and not with the entrees. The waiter said so did i. Our only disapointment of the night. Well that and my crabcake looking smashed. That being said all colossal jumbo lump in the cake and the filet tasted wonderful. We were unable to go to the whiskey bar as it was closed when we went there. The selection of bourbon look extensive.
… moreDerek Parthree
The cove was a hidden gem I just discovered by accident that has quickly became my go to stop when I’m in York. The creek out back weather permitting is the perfect romantic atmosphere and during these colder months they heat and close.off the outdoor seating area which is also very nice. The inside is always welcoming but I will say is a little in the cold side. Which is nice for a bigger guy like myself.
… moreMichelle Price
Delicious crabcake and strawberry mint mule! Nice atmosphere as well.
… moresamikchha subedi
Came here for drinks and appetizers. The drinks were decent, but the appetizers were extremely disappointing. The place has a beautiful ambiance, which made the poor food quality even more frustrating. We ordered fries and Brussels sprouts—the fries were stale, and the Brussels sprouts were so burnt they were completely inedible.
… moreChristian Hofmann
Spectacular old fashioned here! Food and service is great. I have been to alot of great places but this one I will definitely return to! Definitely not a disappointment. Atmosphere was very relaxed. Music just right, could have a conversation with my group but still enjoy the ambiance. We’ll worth the price!
… moreJames Dietterich
We had never been here before and were unaware that most nights you need a reservation. The hostess directed us to the bar area or the whiskey and cigar bar as these areas were not already reserved. She then came and found us as a reservation decided they didn’t want to sit in the heated outside dining area. The ambiance of the deck seating was fantastic and the heaters keep it cozy. The food and service was absolutely stellar. Our waiter Paul was very thorough and helpful explaining the menus. After our experience here it makes perfect sense why you need a reservation. 5 star experience all the way!
… moreGabrielle S
My favorite local salad place. Their espresso martinis are great as well. Owned and staffed by amazing humans. Thank you!
… moreMichelle Neathery
We were very excited to find a new place to eat in York while visiting family. The setting is charming. The bar is beautiful, and there’s a cigar area. We’ve eaten there 3 times and enjoyed the outside covered area with heaters. The staff were very kind.
The food was 50/50. Some things were delicious. But each time one person’s meal was overly cooked or “old” tasting. The second visit was similar and I blew it off to being close to a holiday and maybe they were short-staffed. I mentioned it to the waitress, but nothing was done. On our third visit, my daughter’s open-face turkey was incredibly dry, like shoe leather. She couldn’t eat it. My meal was the same way, but tolerable. My mother’s meatloaf was also very dry to the point that she didn’t eat it. I mentioned it to the server and held the plates up. She apologized and that was it. No offer to make it right or deduct it from the bill.
I still think it’s a nice atmosphere. The staff were nice, and the food was either really good, or really bad. After 3 tries without any concern, we’ll keep checking for other spots to eat in York.
… moreBrianna K
My husband and I met up with some friends here for dinner and I must say I was truly impressed! I ordered the fish and chips and they were cooked perfectly. Some places struggle with fish and chips when it comes to the batter or how long to fry, but The Cove nailed both objectives! I highly recommend this restaurant to anyone who is looking for some yummy seafood and/or a fancier dinner date night!
… moreTaché Burnett
I recently visited The Cove, and I’m still thinking about the experience! Let me start with the drink that completely stole the show: their Fresh Margarita. I’m not exaggerating when I say it’s the best margarita I have ever had. I only drink margaritas, so I’ve tried them at hundreds of restaurants over the years, and nothing—absolutely nothing—comes close to this one. Perfectly balanced, fresh, bright, and simply unforgettable!
The food was just as impressive. The beef brisket was tender, flavorful, and cooked to perfection—easily one of the standout briskets I’ve had anywhere. And then came the fried cheesecake, which was the perfect combination of sweet, creamy, and indulgent without being overwhelming. It was the ideal ending to an already wonderful meal.
Honestly, I wasn’t expecting to enjoy the food as much as I did, but I was completely blown away. I’m already looking forward to going back. The Cove has officially earned a spot on my favorite restaurants list!
… more