Social Profile: 
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2933 Highway Ave, Highland, IN 46322
Website: http://www.countericecream.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
The Counter Ice Cream & Italian Ice: Premium Ice Cream Italian Ice …
The Counter offers walk-up window service premium ice cream, italian ice, milkshakes, floats, sundaes, and freshly baked cookies.
The Counter Ice Cream & Italian Ice | Highland IN – Facebook
The Counter Ice Cream & Italian Ice, Highland. 5145 likes · 7 talking about this · 1600 were here. Super premium hard scoop ice cream, small batch…
The Counter Ice Cream & Italian Ice (@countericecream) – Instagram
2933 Highway Ave in Downtown Highland, IN Serving premium ice cream, homemade Italian Ice, signature sundaes, and our famous freshly baked cookies.
Reviews
Gissy Rose
Very nice cute place. Lines can get long, but girls at the counter are super sweet. Ice cream was really rich but tasted great. Waffle cones were made fresh. Overall great experience, I will be back!
… moreDee P
First time here Nevaeh up. She was very kind very patient me and my daughter’s were changing our mind over and over again trying to figure out the menu. She was very patient with us. The line was very long. It was 7:40 PM when we went, I believe they close at nine and the line was down to the bottom of the stairs.
… moreJason Popp
I’ve visited this place a few times, and it’s a hidden gem nestled between businesses in downtown Highland. They always offer a good variety and different creations of sundaes and ice cream, which change from time to time. The staff are always pleasant, and you get your ice cream quickly.
Although there’s only outdoor seating, there are a few benches with umbrellas to block the sun, so it’s quite comfortable. During my last visit, I had a pretzel chocolate ice cream creation, and my girlfriend had a PB&J twist creation. Both were very good. I highly recommend checking it out!
… moreAlthough there’s only outdoor seating, there are a few benches with umbrellas to block the sun, so it’s quite comfortable. During my last visit, I had a pretzel chocolate ice cream creation, and my girlfriend had a PB&J twist creation. Both were very good. I highly recommend checking it out!
Rene V
The place has a lot of options, But my opinion is that this place has average ice cream. You can get the same ice cream quality somewhere else. If you’re looking to take your kids somewhere where cheap and family friendly this place is perfect.
… moreY.C. Wu
A very beautiful corner for the ice cream! The staff was nice, and the ice cream was also pretty good. We bought the one scoop with chocolate and coffee flavors and chose the waffle cone. The waffle cone was pretty crunchy. The toppings on the soft ice cream were also very good.
… moreRoo Lopez
The treats here are to die for. I’m so thankful this place is open again for the season. I enjoy taking my friends and loved ones here and stopping by for a quick icecream. Love the service and friendliness of the staff. A must stop by!!!
… moreChris P
Two’s across the board on this one. They messed up My Wife’s order and such a small scoop of Ice Cream in My Float, that it was mostly just orange soda with Whipped Cream. I will also add that the garbage can out by the tables were over flowing with Yellow Jackets all over it. Kinda disappointed on this one.
… moreLillian Mowers
So recently I just purchased a sundae here for my first time. (July 10th 2025) It was one sundae called the salty and sweet. The store wasn’t busy and everybody was getting their orders fairly fast. About fifteen minutes go by watching people that payed after me got their food, I was a little confused. When I looked into the window, I saw girls goofing around and not paying attention. Also the people I came with got their ice cream and finished it already. When I go up and ask if they forgot my one item order and tried to figure it out, they were then arguing as a staff about who messed up loudlyto one another. Then after waiting because two big orders were still able to get theirs before mine. I got a all over the place sundae cup. Never a “sorry about the wait” Just a “here” I thought this was odd because, as a teenager I understand waiting and being patient but this really rubbed me the wrong way. The name on my receipt was “Esperanza”. Ice cream was good andi liked the creative sundaes, just wish the service was nicer. :/
… moreBreeana M
This place came up when I was looking for a place with dairy free options. My receipt said the cashiers name is Abby. She was very pleasant and patient as my kids decided on what Italian ice and ice cream they wanted. She even let us a try a few.
The seating area was clean, the prices weren’t bad, and it wasn’t a long wait time. I will definitely be back!
… moreThe seating area was clean, the prices weren’t bad, and it wasn’t a long wait time. I will definitely be back!
William Shakespeare
Local gem with some of the best frozen treats I’ve ever had. The ice cream is fresh and the quality is amazing. The Italian ice is my favorite. It’s made with real fruit so you can really taste the freshness in it. Congrats on the new location.
… more