Sarah B
If you’re anywhere near Berlin, Maryland, or even just passing through! Do yourself a favor and stop at Cap’ns Slice. This isn’t just pizza… it’s an experience.
From the moment you walk in, the atmosphere hits you. It’s fun, welcoming, laid-back, and full of personality — the kind of place where you instantly feel like a regular. The vibe alone makes you want to hang out, grab a slice, and stay awhile.
And let’s talk about Yancey, the owner. Absolute legend. Yancey has been in the game since the OG days, and you can taste that experience in every single bite. This isn’t basic pizza — this is iconic pizza. Perfect crust. Killer sauce. The kind of cheese pull that deserves its own slow-motion video. And the toppings? Creative, bold, and next-level. Yancey doesn’t just make pizza… he crafts it.
You can tell Yancey genuinely loves what he does. The energy, the fun-loving personality, the pride in every pie — it all shows. And now he’s even got his own beer with his face on it? Come on. That’s next-level cool.
Whether you’re a local or visiting from out of town, make the trip. Seriously. It’s well worth it for the atmosphere, the creativity, and some of the best pizza you’ll ever have and Yancey!
Cap’ns Slice isn’t just a pizza shop — it’s a whole vibe.
… moreAbbey Senesi
Amazing, authentic NY pizza for a great price! The best we’ve had in years. We drove an hour to Berlin, and would do it again just to come for the pizza.
… moreDeborah Matties
We stop by all the time for a huge slice on our way out on the town. Always a selection of creative offerings as well as popular standards. This is a takeout place with a dozen cute high top seats if you just want a quick slice. Large selection of pizza friendly drinks. We usually have a Peroni or Slice Shop (Burley Brewery-Local)but lots of other options. We always like to sit in the window and people watch. Parking lot across the street as well as on street parking. Fun stop!
… moreJessica Nusbaum
Absolutely love this place! Delicious, unique pizzas and awesome staff. The slices reheat well at home, so don’t be afraid to get extra for leftovers. I’ve been getting pizza from here for about a year and will definitely keep coming back!
… moreBethany Hart
The best pizza you can get in the area. Fresh ingredients, unique flavor combinations, and the ability to try an array of different slices make this a must-try. Worth the trip to Berlin for this pizza, you won’t be disappointed with everything this town has to offer.
… moreIsaac Senesi
This is, excuse my language, damn fine pizza. Probably the best in the whole Delmarva peninsula. It’s worth the drive if you’re far away, and worth the wait if there’s a well-deserved line out the door. These are dudes who know their pizza, and do it right. So grab a hot slice, a cold drink, and watch your problems seem to fade away.
… moreCristina Cash
Most delicious pizza on the Eastern Shore. They always have a verity of slice pies available so you can try different flavors. Check out their instagram/facebook to keep up with new and exciting items. My favorite – Davy Jones. You won’t be disappointed.
… morevence benedict
When visiting the town of Berlin Maryland,this pizza shop is a must visit. It’s not your typical pizza shop slinging cheese and pepperoni pizza slices across the counter. (Although you can get cheese and pepperoni slices). The owner of this shop creates pieces of art that you eat! That’s rite, his pies are pieces of art.once you step inside you will understand. I can’t begin to tell you which is my favorite. They’re all my favorite! Since my first visit I’ve spent more time in his shop than my own kitchen. Every trip is something new and very different. But trust me when I say this , It all works! Stop in and grab a slice or 2 and you’ll understand. I won’t eat pizza anywhere else since my first slice.
… moreAllison Blakeman
We love this place. Their usual offerings are so so good and their special pizzas are always tasty, too. Their pesto and vodka sauces are my absolute favorite. It’s so nice being able to stop in and just pick up a couple of slices if we don’t feel like getting a whole pizza. Plus you get to try all the different kinds!
… moreLaura Davis
Wonderful pizza. Friendly staff, reasonable prices. Great spot to grab a quick slice for lunch. Make sure to ask about the special!
… more