Emily Buswell
The Bakeshop on Kelley provided desserts for our 150-person wedding in September, and we couldn’t be happier with the experience. Denise was informative and easy to work with throughout the process. She made brownies – some beautifully decorated with frosting and others left plain – and an amazing assortment of mini donuts, including maple bacon, Oreo, apple cider, Fruity Pebbles, Salted Caramel, Cinnamon Toast Crunch, Reese’s, and classic glazed.
She was also accommodating of guests with nut allergies, which was greatly appreciated. Denise handled delivery and set up, and the dessert display was beautiful!
In the whirlwind of our wedding, my husband and I didn’t get a chance to taste the desserts that night (though we kept commenting on the mouthwatering smell of the maple donuts every time we passed the dessert bar!). We did sample some donuts the next morning, and they were still fantastic.
We’re so grateful to Denise for making everything easy, and are so happy we relied on the Bakeshop on Kelley to provide our favorite sweet treats on our special day!
… moreRyan Garner
Great breakfast and even better service! We stopped in last minute to put together a pastry platter for a combined bachelorette/bachelor party, and the staff went above and beyond to help us choose options that would work for a group. Everything was fresh, delicious, and beautifully presented. They made the process easy and stress-free, and the pastries were a huge hit. Highly recommend!
… moreDaniele Guest
Overdue review but back in dec I called Kelley St in desperate search of a cake. It was a last minute request. We don’t need to go into how last minute it was. They have timelines and required advanced notice that should be respected. Even still, they really came through for me in a huge way and baked the most beautiful and delicious irish cream cake I’ve ever witnessed. Many thanks to all the bakers at the Bakeshop on Kelley St.
… moreSteven Griswold
This place is fabulous. The treats are delicious and the service just as delicious! To the lady who helped us who told me she made the s’mores donut (didn’t get your name), you’re awesome and the donut was INCREDIBLE!
… moreAlex Chatigny
I love the Bakeshop on Kelly st. Staff is incredibly friendly, and skilled. This was the first place I ever tried an apple cider , absolutely amazing! Highly recommend their bacon egg and cheese sandwiches on their fresh baked croissant or bagel
… moreCarisa Caruso
I’ve been going to this bakery for the last few years , unsure if something has changed the last 6months/year but the quality of some the items seems to have changed. I’ve stopped the last few weeks to grab cannolis and they are never filled all the way and the middles have nothing inside most – and for $3 a cannoli for a small – that’s just unacceptable- the filling is delicious and the other items I have gotten are also still very good – but it seems the quality has been going down unfortunately and this seems to be the new standard as this is the third time this has happened in the last few weeks. Hope they regain the quality they used to have for the items they sell.
… morePatty Martin
I ordered 3 pies for the holidays. The crust on all 3 was hard and thick making the pies impossible to cut without making a mess. The apple pie did not get a thumbs up from my guests. The chocolate cream was okay but was mostly whipped cream with little chocolate cream. The banana cream was delicious. Unfortunately, I only got a 5 inch pie at the outrageous price of $23. Seriously, $23 for a tiny pie. I was SHOCKED to pay $85 for 3 pies!
… moreMonica Hernandez
I could not be happier with the Bakeshop on Kelley Street. They were a joy to work with for my daughter’s first birthday celebration. Our guests raved about how moist and delicious the cake was, and both the cake for guests and my daughter’s smash cake looked exactly as I envisioned. They even decorated the pastry tray we ordered to match our sunshine theme, which was a sweet surprise! Each time I called or emailed, they were so pleasant and sweet and professional. They were also very accommodating when I called a few days before with some last minute changes. Everything was beautiful, delicious and the service was great. Cannot recommend enough!
… moreJennifer F
I ordered a birthday cake 1.5 weeks in advance, and when asked what time I’d be picking up the cake, I told them noon. On April 4, I walked in to pick up the cake at 12:30, 30 minutes after the time I said I’d be there, and it wasn’t done yet. Being that I had family coming in from out of state and many errands to run, I was a bit disappointed that I had to wait, about 20 minutes or so. On the positive side, though, I was feeling assured that at least the cake was fresh.
Fast forward to the same evening we ate the cake. To our surprise, it was tasteless, like an ingredient was missing or something. I’ve never really had a cake I didn’t like, until I had the Bakeshop’s. The cake was for my daughter who came to visit from Oklahoma. $45 for a cake that was not good.
And you can tell in the photo that the cake was messed up in the left corner.
… moreJennifer Normand
We ordered two 50 piece assorted dessert trays for our wedding last weekend from here And they were beautifully arranged on the trays and packaged for transport, Everything was delicious. There was not one thing left on either of the trays at the end of our wedding.
Would highly recommend them in the future
… more