Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Welcome to The Bagelry, your neighborhood haven for hand-crafted bagels, delightful flavors, and a touch of healthful indulgence. At The Bagelry, we take pride in our tradition of hand-rolling each bagel with care, ensuring a perfect balance of texture and taste in every bite. Indulge in our array of delicious spreads, baked goods, and premium deli sandwiches, or savor one of our fresh, crisp salads and wholesome, healthy options. And to complement your meal, don’t forget to enjoy a cup of our rich, aromatic coffee imported from Italy. Come experience the warmth, flavor, and nourishment of The Bagelry – where every visit is a journey of satisfaction and well-being!
Address and Contact Information
Address: 170 E Hanover Ave, Cedar Knolls, NJ 07927
Phone: (973) 206-1208
Website: https://thebagelrynj.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
The Bagelry
We love our customers, so feel free to visit during normal business hours. The Bagelry. 170 East Hanover Avenue, Cedar Knolls, New Jersey 07927, United States.
The Bagelry – Cedar Knolls – Order Online
170 E Hanover Ave Unit B3, Cedar Knolls, NJ. Opens tomorrow at 7AM. Drinks. Quick Order. Bagels. Baked Goods. Eggs & Omeletes. Salads. Sandwiches.
The Bagelry | Cedar Knolls NJ – Facebook
The Bagelry, Cedar Knolls. 1188 likes · 5 were here. New location bagel shop offering a variety of hand-rolled bagels, delicious spreads, baked goods…
Reviews
M M
Burnt bagels with hair inside the cream cheese. Do not recommend.
Edit: We called and manager said to come in for a replacement. We drove all the way over and she said she’d only replace the bread!
… moreEdit: We called and manager said to come in for a replacement. We drove all the way over and she said she’d only replace the bread!
Steven Melchiorri
Breakfast platter was tasty and priced right which is uncommon these days! Inside was very clean and food came out quickly. Owner operated and staff were super nice. Highly recommend!!
… moreChristina Franco
Absolutely delicious!! The entire staff is so kind and friendly, even answering the phone with so much joy. The service is always quick, and the food is consistently amazing. I’ve never had a meal I didn’t love! My Taylor ham, egg, and cheese was so good it literally turned my whole day around!
… moreAlexander Kontoleon
Fantastic bagel spot but beware the wait. This place has dynamite bagels. Great texture and taste. (They also have this French Toast Bagel that is insanely good). They also has many flavorful fun cream cheese offerings, and interior is clean and nice. 5 star for food and bagels. But…. the kitchen hasn’t quite figured out balance around keeping orders moving for folks who come into the store order, vs. the takeout order they get from online/over the phone. Once they sort out order flow, this place will be a must go.
… moreJames Vardakis
Really the best bagels around. They’re huge and perfectly baked. Generous with the cream cheese and a great variety of options. The iced coffee is great too! It’s my go-to whenever I’m out here visiting friends and family.
… moreAndrea Hanna Capello
I order already like five times from this place. They never give me the right order. O they add things I don’t like, o they don’t put the ones I like. The food is good but make sure to open and checked you sandwich before you leave.
… moreAlyssa Benson
After going to the Bagelry for close to a year now, I think it’s time we find a new spot. We usually get our bagels toasted and have consistently been getting burnt bagels..this was the worst one yet!! It is completely unacceptable, I don’t know how they can serve a bagel like this. If you like burnt bagels..this is your place!!
… moreJoseph Lawrence
$9.50 for a Taylor ham, egg and cheese should be a criminal offense. Absolutely abysmal move from a bagel shop. At least throw on extra meat or something if you’re going to be the most expensive bagel shop in the area..
… moreRahul
I think this place should be renamed “robbery” instead of “bagelery “
I ordered 1 omelette and two cream cheese bagel. That’s is and my bill after taxes and “tip” for picking up my own food is $30. $30 for an omelette and 2 cream cheese bagel. If this isn’t robbery what is. They charge 3% to use credit card. Then they beg for a tip. Like imagine robbing the customer of $30 and still it not being enough to pay their employees decent wages that they need to beg for a tip for a pick up.
To me this just sounds exorbitant and fleecing the customer with junk fees.
There is an equally average bagel place across the street and they won’t atleast charge you for using credit card.
Ps: I have filed a complaint the my credit card company for the fees they charge. I pay a lot of money for annual fees for credit card, if I have to pay another 3% each time I buy something then either the credit card company isn’t getting my money or I ain’t buying in the first place.
Everything has become a scam these days! Everything just sucks. A man can’t have a simple bagel and cream cheese without having to consider he he needs to sell his kidney
… moreI ordered 1 omelette and two cream cheese bagel. That’s is and my bill after taxes and “tip” for picking up my own food is $30. $30 for an omelette and 2 cream cheese bagel. If this isn’t robbery what is. They charge 3% to use credit card. Then they beg for a tip. Like imagine robbing the customer of $30 and still it not being enough to pay their employees decent wages that they need to beg for a tip for a pick up.
To me this just sounds exorbitant and fleecing the customer with junk fees.
There is an equally average bagel place across the street and they won’t atleast charge you for using credit card.
Ps: I have filed a complaint the my credit card company for the fees they charge. I pay a lot of money for annual fees for credit card, if I have to pay another 3% each time I buy something then either the credit card company isn’t getting my money or I ain’t buying in the first place.
Everything has become a scam these days! Everything just sucks. A man can’t have a simple bagel and cream cheese without having to consider he he needs to sell his kidney
Skavi Ballinas
Decent spot to check out, got a few bagels along with our bagel sandwiches.
Wouldn’t say they were the best, but they weren’t bad either. Do not get the coffee though, that was awful.
… moreWouldn’t say they were the best, but they weren’t bad either. Do not get the coffee though, that was awful.