Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in
… View more
Located at the Shelter Island Country Club, 1901 bar and grill is a welcoming spot for both club members and the public. We serve up delicious lunch, dinner, and happy hour favorites in a laid-back, family-friendly setting. Whether you’re finishing a round of golf, meeting friends for drinks, or bringing the family out for a meal, our menu and atmosphere have something for everyone. From fresh bites to cold beverages, we’re proud to be a go-to gathering place for locals and visitors alike. Join us for good food, good drinks, and great company — no membership required.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 26 Sunnyside Ave, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
Phone: (631) 749-5466
Website: https://the1901grill.com/
Related Web Results
Experience the Best of Goat Hill – The 1901 Grill
“The 1901 Grill was amazing! We had a great dinner with … Connect with us. Home. The 1901 Grill. 26 Sunnyside Avenue Shelter Island Heights, New York 11965.
Menu – The 1901 Grill
Lunch at The 1901 Grill. The 1901 Smash Burger. 22. Two patties, American … 26 Sunnyside Avenue Shelter Island Heights, New York 11965. 631-749-5466 …
The 1901 Grill at Goat Hill (@the1901grill) – Instagram
Thursdays on Shelter Island just got a whole lot smarter! @thinkinctrivia is headed to @the1901grill every Thursday beginning May 29th at 6pm. Gather your …
Reviews
Alexa
First time here since this location changed hands and became 1901. Service is outstanding, well coordinated and friendly. Not always something you experience this early in the season at other island venues. 1901 offers casual, good food. I ordered the fish and chips – fish was solid, french fries could be upgraded to a more tasty fry. Portion size for this entree is small, thus four stars. Another family member had the pulled pork sandwich and that was very good and filling. Overall, a solid choice for you to try – casual and tasty fare with a lovely view. .
… moreDon DeVries
Great smash burger at reasonable price. Very good beef flavor. Crisp and juicy. Perfect for lunch, dinner or after golf game. Enjoyed a side salad with blue cheese dressing. Fresh and perfect substitution for Fries.
… moreAndrew Puschel
This place is great! We (four adults and two children) went here on a rainy day and the food is great, the vibe is chill, local, and welcoming—casual and family-friendly without being only families. Views are great with blue sky or rain. Staff is friendly. The new owner came up and greeted us—wonderful guy. Highly recommend! We’ll be coming back!
… moreEden Benton
Super solid lunch with a pleasant view. Got the smash burger & Caesar salad, both were great! TBH wasn’t expecting much from the salad and was very pleasantly surprised, lettuce crispy and perfectly dressed.
Would recommend
… moreWould recommend
Mark Mobius
The food was even better than the spectacular views and comfortable summer dining atmosphere. We all loved the baked brie, the brussel sprouts, and the seared tuna appetizers.
A high value experience at a refreshingly reasonable price for the area.
… moreA high value experience at a refreshingly reasonable price for the area.
Angela Morales
Julia gave my table great recommendations and paired us with great wine. She made us feel welcomed and our other server as well when she checked in on us for dessert. Love the Buffalo wings and smash burger is a favorite! Had the salmon which was fantastic.
… moreAbbie Cooper
We have been to the 1901 grill multiple times this past summer. Each time our meal has been great. The atmosphere is lowkey, the staff is friendly and the food is always solid. We’ve arrived with large parties and have always been able to sit quickly. We also love sitting at the bar enjoying the burger + beer special on Sundays while watching the game. Great addition to the Shelter Island restaurant scene!
… moreMia DiOrio
Great food for very reasonable prices! ai especially love the smash burger and buffalo wings. The views from the deck are beautiful. I definitely recommend this hidden gem of a restaurant!
… moreErin Connolly
1901 is such a great lunch spot on shelter island. Maggie, our server, was lovely and very attentive. The food is always phenomenal and sitting in the gazebo while golfers play through the course is very relaxing. Couldn’t recommend more.
… moreSteamboat Shelter, LLC
Wow !!! What an experience at the 1901!!!! Saw the Buffalo wings going to another table – looked and smelled great. We ordered them and they surpassed the what we saw and smelled. Katherine the bartender suggested the smash burger – chef Casey nailed it !!!!
Oh – and the pints of miller lite were cold and fresh.
Did I mention the views to the south of the south fork and to the north of
Dering Harbor.
A MUST stop on Shelter Island.
… moreOh – and the pints of miller lite were cold and fresh.
Did I mention the views to the south of the south fork and to the north of
Dering Harbor.
A MUST stop on Shelter Island.