Nick Siskoff
Been going here for years. Definitely would have rated them 5 stars in the past but over the last several months I have been getting consistently undercooked food to the point I expect it more often than not now. Prices are great, portions are really good, and the quality was amazing. Definitely has gotten worse recently though unfortunately. I really like the chicken pot pie pasty for lunch and the southwest one for breakfast. If they end up improving on their quality and return to what they once were I’d happily give them 5 stars again. Still would recommend trying.
… moreDarryl Fox
I’ve been getting their pasties for a couple of decades. Hands down, the best pasties on the planet. I’ve shared the veggie with several friends, and they all agree. Service is always pleasant. I highly recommend them
… moreEmmanuel Martinez
Be careful if you’re vegetarian, it’s the second time they have given me the wrong order and I only find out when I get to work, too late to do anything about it.
It’s unfortunate I have to make this review because when I get the right order they are a very good breakfast stop or lunch stop. The southwest and veggie are really good.
… moreTom Szelag
This is a good spot! Small, simple, straightforward. Some good people working there. Good food and honestly a pretty good value especially with how everything seems to be getting expensive these days.
A half-sized portion is plenty for me as a light breakfast on the go. Full-sized is more of a meal.
… moreAmelia Lee
Delicious pastry that I discovered by accident. The service was super friendly and fast. I ordered a sausage pastry with hot sauce and found my new favorite fast food in the city. The pastry was still hot and delicious with its egg and cheese filling. This shop is a great spot for quick, tasty, and cheap food. Loved it and will be back!
… moreVincent Mollica
A true Madison staple. I got the chicken tikka masala on Saturday and had it walking to campus for a movie and it was probably the best thing I’ve ever had there. I got a half and strongly considered turning around and getting another. Much much love.
… moreLeo Shestakov
Tasty but salt is super inconsistent. Got the original once and it wasn’t very salty (how I like it). Went again today to get the curry squash one and it was unbelievably salty
… moreHayden Judd
Huge portion of food & great service. I like that it’s a takeout only place too. I had a Spicy Something and it was so good, big portion of food which I was expecting. I definitely would come back to this place again!
… moreRachel Selm
We’ve lived in the Madison area for 7 years, and I’m sad we just now discovered Teddywedgers. The Chickpea Curry Handpie was phenomenal, and one of the best curries I’ve ever had. I was so happy there was a vegetarian option! My husband loved his cheesy, pepperoni one. We’ll definitely be back!
… moreHannah K
i really love teddywedgers. such huge portion and delicious hearty food. today (9/4) i picked one up in the afternoon and it was severely undercooked… if they need a little more time in the oven please just ask the customer to wait instead of giving them an undercooked pasty. it wasn’t even hot.
… more