The Review
I’m really glad I didn’t believe the bad reviews. I drove 40 minutes with a gut instinct and photos that looked like my type of pizza (real pizza ), not the chain crap I can buy frozen pizza for that. Maybe those customers haven’t had real pizza before? The place has been remodeled since the photo was taken on Google Maps, so don’t be scared because it’s great. I belive it’s new owners but I didn’t ask. Every employee was friendly to me
… moreAEBCPAMA
Ordered a takeout pizza and calamari, asked for the pizza to not be sliced. Told 15-20 minutes for pickup. Got there in 15 minutes, paid for it, then had to wait another 15 minutes for the sliced up pizza. Calamari was good but stone cold, pizza was disappointing. This was my first and last visit here!
… morecorey bentz
The pizza was pretty much cardboard with toppings. The pizza wasn’t cut all the way through. The bottom was definitely overcooked. The bread is basically indestructible. Gonna do a durability test later to see how strong it is. Worst pizza I’ve had in berkshire county.
… moreClarissa Harford
The cheese on the pizza was falling off and it definitely could’ve been cooked a bit longer.
The Caesar salad!?? Was a joke! $13 for this!?? Soggy and I don’t know what was going on with the cheese .
Teddys has lost its touch.
… moreMatt Jones
Teddy’s is making some pretty solid food and the restaurant has an incredible atmosphere with great beer selection.
Awesome wings, the “hot” hot sauce wasn’t super hot, but the flavor was there and the wings were crispy.
Got a nice fresh garden salad too, which didn’t have any brown, wilted lettuce that usually plagues pizza place salads. Great house dressing as well. Huge too, well worth the money.
The pizza could use some work though. The previous owners did a greek style Eastern Mass pan pizza that I loved, buttery with a nice airy crust. The pizza I had yesterday had a really thin and crunchy crust. Parts of the bottom of the pizza bubbled up so the bottom of the pizza was soggy in parts and overall the dough was a bit sweet for my taste.
While I may not come back for the pizza often, I’m looking forward to trying the wings again and maybe grabbing a couple of subs.
… moreNorm Cullerton
I love this place. The subs are great, pizza is outstanding. An the staff is awesome. Best little mom and pop shop around!
… moremike p
Lately this has really gone down hill. Pizza was delivered to me practically raw my last order, and now they are closed on random days when online says they’re open. They even charged me for an order on one of those days they weren’t open but according to Google they were, and refused to refund us, asking for an order number when there was none provided. Order at your own risk
… moreTori McClure
I ordered Teddy’s Pizza tonight and all I wanted was pepperoni and cheese. They charged me an extra $2 for the pepperoni and then they didn’t even put it on the pizza. The pizza is also under cooked and floppy. They didn’t even cut it. I also paid $6.99 for a nibble of salad. Unfortunately, I will not give this pizza joint another chance.
… moreCarlo Petrucci
It was my first time ordering Teddys. I got a calzone and mozzarella sticks. The calzone was not very good. It was lukewarm at most and some of it was cold. Also I think the dough was a little underdone. Lastly for the calzone it had pizza sauce in it which I found odd considering calzone’s don’t normally have that. The mozzarella sticks were ok but nothing to write home about. Overall I would not recommend this establishment there are better places in the area.
… moreSage Smith
The pizza is terrible. We ordered a medium buffalo chicken and a small garlic based tomato pizza. We got the pizza and instead got a small buffalo chicken pizza and medium tomato pizza. There was no sauce on both the pizzas. Very dry and gross. When we called to let them know, they said there’s nothing we can do. Also when we said there was no buffalo sauce on the pizza, they said we could come pick it up. Nobody wants to drive back to get sauce. We will never order from here again. Terrible pizza and ridiculous service.
… more