Social Profile: 
![]()
… View more
With over 40 flavors of homemade premium ice cream to choose from, guests can enjoy their favorite scoop, sundae, milkshake, banana split, classic ice cream soda or ice cream float. Vegan Ice Cream and Gluten-Free Ice Cream options are also available!
Dozens of creatively–flavored cones are doled out at this ice cream shop with a colorful interior.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 15742 N Dale Mabry Hwy, Tampa, FL 33618
Phone: (813) 533-3314
Website: https://www.icecreamiest.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Tanya & Matt’s Ice Creamiest
… ice cream floats and sodas! And of course – toppings! Visit Us. You can find us at 15742 N Dale Mabry Hwy, Tampa, FL 33618 located in the Northdale Promenade …
Tanya & Matt’s Ice Creamiest | Tampa FL – Facebook
GOOD MORNING! We are now open in a morning! Every day at 8:30am from Monday to Saturday. We offer: Homemade Ice cream, Organic coffee, Bakery, Açaí bowls, …
Tanya & Matt’s Ice Creamiest (@tanyaandmattsicecream) – Instagram
Tampa’s largest selection of homemade ice cream for over 30yrs Monday-Thursday 2pm-9pm Friday 2pm-10pm Saturday 1pm-10pm Sunday 1pm-9pm.
Last Updates
Reviews
Jason Ballard
YUM!
Been a customer since the 90s. Such great ice cream and nice employees.
Matt even did an ice sculpture for us one time for Gasparilla.
Add your number at checkout for rewards to save in the future. Give this place a try and leave a rating to help others.
… moreBeen a customer since the 90s. Such great ice cream and nice employees.
Matt even did an ice sculpture for us one time for Gasparilla.
Add your number at checkout for rewards to save in the future. Give this place a try and leave a rating to help others.
Naphatthan Sukphol
I’m from Thailand and i’ve tried many ice-cream here in the US. Never be able to eat as it’s too milky and way too sweet for me. Until i found this place and i just loved it!!!! Not too sweet, many flavor to choose. I got the Chocolate covered cherry…. Was amazing ✨ will def visit again
… moreAnand R
Best Icecream Parlour with Fresh Icecream. I tried the Coconut flavour here and it was superb.
I tried few other flavours as well and everything seemed excellent.
The special mention should be about the freshness of the Icecream. It was neither too much frozen nor molten in nature but it was as an Icecream is supposed to be.
The staff were friendly and helpful. They have outdoor seating arrangement as well as inside and they have sufficient seating available for all the Customers. It was not much crowded but floating crowd here and there.
Outside, plenty of Parking available and it’s easy to find a spot next to the Icecream Parlour.
We would love to visit again and try other flavours soon
… moreI tried few other flavours as well and everything seemed excellent.
The special mention should be about the freshness of the Icecream. It was neither too much frozen nor molten in nature but it was as an Icecream is supposed to be.
The staff were friendly and helpful. They have outdoor seating arrangement as well as inside and they have sufficient seating available for all the Customers. It was not much crowded but floating crowd here and there.
Outside, plenty of Parking available and it’s easy to find a spot next to the Icecream Parlour.
We would love to visit again and try other flavours soon
Tris MacWilliam Yates
This used to be a great place to bring my kids for a cool treat. But since the new owners bought it the place has really gone down hill in service. The flavor selection is not as varied as it used to be and the sugar free flavors are are gone. They’ve been using the excuse that a cooler is broken for about 2 months now. My advice is to fix it or keep losing customers.
… moreJoseph Duran
This is a classic neighborhood ice cream shop. If you live in the area you are a regular, if you don’t live in the area you are greeted like you are a regular! They have a wide variety of flavors and a handful of sugar free flavors as well. The staff is friendly and helpful, and the ice cream never disappoints! The only suggestion we have is more seating options. They offer booths and some outdoor seating but any parties larger than 4-5 it can be difficult to all sit together. We can’t wait to come back!
… moreStephane Queroy
So yummy! I love the Blueberry cheesecake and Ube flavors 🙂 Also the renovations look great. Much more modern and comfortable. The new owners and staff are welcoming and doing a great job.
… moreTheIntrovertedCorner
The place was a great representation of a well equipped ice cream shop.
Dozens of flavors to choose from, many unique to the location.
My favorite was junk in the trunk this time. My ice cream cohort chose almond joy, which has real coconut!
Both flavors were exciting and new, along with the 38 or so other flavor. They seem to be made with real ingredients and have such a natural and creamy flavor.
It’s my new favorite ice cream place!
… moreDozens of flavors to choose from, many unique to the location.
My favorite was junk in the trunk this time. My ice cream cohort chose almond joy, which has real coconut!
Both flavors were exciting and new, along with the 38 or so other flavor. They seem to be made with real ingredients and have such a natural and creamy flavor.
It’s my new favorite ice cream place!
Elle Lee
Truly the very BEST homemade ice cream I have ever had!!! I always recommend them to anyone and everyone that mention desserts.
The price list may be a little older but just showing you what they have for flavors and toppings!!!
Definitely worth the trip from anywhere. They are located in Carrollwood next to Winn Dixie and Bealls Dept store almost across from Sams club on Dale Malbry
… moreThe price list may be a little older but just showing you what they have for flavors and toppings!!!
Definitely worth the trip from anywhere. They are located in Carrollwood next to Winn Dixie and Bealls Dept store almost across from Sams club on Dale Malbry
Greg Mills
I was sitting home today and had the urge for some “IceCream” so I decided to go to Tanya & Matt’s for a cone…I ordered 2 Scoops of vanilla and not only was it delicious but it felt like it weighed at least a pound, I walked to my car and when I sat down my arm bumped something and knocked it outta my hand bounced off my leg and hit the asphalt…I was a little upset because I just spent $8.00 on it so I picked it up immediately and everything stayed intact the IceCream stayed on the cone and did not fall off this young lady knew what she was doing, I just happened to have a plastic knife in my vehicle and was able to cut the bad part off the cone and was able to continue to enjoy my IceCream.
Just goes to show you that when you go somewhere that puts that much care into their Art you will be satisfied.
Way to go young lady great job.
This was on 12/10/2025 around 4:00pm
… moreJust goes to show you that when you go somewhere that puts that much care into their Art you will be satisfied.
Way to go young lady great job.
This was on 12/10/2025 around 4:00pm
Jake Dees
Changed ownership and it has been stripped of all character. The polar bear mural? Gone. The kids gum ball/claw machines? Gone. What replaces it all? White paint, IKEA-looking table tops, and the removal of all the charm that made this place feel like a special local ice cream place. Sad to see Tanya and Matt’s go.
… more