Brandy
Mr. Jerry is one of the most generous, wonderful human beings on the planet. This particular day was a very hard one for me and I just needed some comfort food. I phoned in my order for one of his delicious traditional potatoes and some of his loaded baked potato soup to hit the spot. Upon pickup, we were talking about how hard it is to keep the Christmas spirit going for our friends and loved ones during the holiday time. He told me to keep going and push through to keep that excitement for my special needs son, reached into his pocket and pulled out this very special patch to give him that no one else has. This kind gesture will not only make my son feel special, but so loved by a kind individual who thought of him today. The food was fabulous and fresh as always .Thank you, Mr. Jerry. For always serving the best food, helping your community, and brightening up a customer’s day by making her son feel so special. If you haven’t eaten at Super Taters yet, please call in your order and try it for yourself. There isn’t a bad item on the massive menu. You won’t be disappointed. Tell him Brandy sent you.
… moreElia Kazan
Delicious. I would say for the price point ($13), the traditional should have a lot more bacon added to it. There was not much there. But I guess I could have asked for extra. If you order, definitely ask for meat toppings as that will fill you up. The cubano sandwhich is delectable, I really liked the bread it was served on, and the meat was tender. I also recommend the “corn and crab” soup
… moreOverKill
Found this place on Google maps and it looked interesting. Let me tell you…. this place is absolutely fantastic! Extremely friendly service. Great selection. Couldnt ask for a better local food place. We will be back.
… moreMadyson Briggs
Absolutely incredible! The atmosphere was very welcoming and the potatoes are DELICIOUS! I will definitely be making this my go-to spot. Thank y’all ❤️
… moreCrystal
I ordered the chicken bacon ranch Panini, corn and crab chowder, and potato salad. The Panini was absolutely fantastic and I will definitely be ordering that again. The potato salad was also very good. My only critique is the corn and crab chowder had way too much black pepper.
… moreLauren (Rose)
Had this on my “to eat” list for a very long time, finally made it out there, and was very excited by all the different options and variations on the menu. I ordered the Spicy Ragin Cajun with chicken, not only did I not get chicken, but what I think was ground beef, the menu prices were liquid papered out, I paid $20, later upon looking at the menu on their website the potato was listed as $14 , not sure where the extra $6 came from, I didn’t make any changes/substitutions. My friend got the Chili Cheese and added broccoli, she paid $21, it’s listed on the online menu as $12, so her added broccoli was $9?!?! I know I’m coming from a negative perspective bc of the pricing, but in honesty the potatoes were not great at all. Potatoes were not soft, very little butter, overall not good. Very disappointing.
If I ever come back would definitely split 1 potato for this price
Edit: to the owners reply, the screen shots of the menu are from your official website, I have also posted a pic of what I was charged on my credit card, as to the sour cream cost, you actually gave us the sour cream after we paid ….
… moreHeather Smith
Jared!!! You did not disappoint!!
Jared, you are a truly generous and heartwarming man that goes above and beyond for his business and customers. The fact that you have been open for 11 years now is beyond comprehension! All glory to God for allowing you to stay open during Covid and even have an increase in sales during that time!
Anyways, the food was absolutely delicious and considering I live close by.. I’ll be back for more☺️
I pray that God continues to bless you, your family, and your business for generations to come!
… moreSequila Paul
Had the toadstool potato, it was absolutely delicious. Tried the classic smash burger for the 1st time.. let’s just say it was the real deal.. not that cheap beef. Service was quick, friendly and the food was 10 outta 10!!
… moreMex1823
If you’re looking for a place that believes “portion control” is a personal insult, Super Taters is your spot. ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
I ordered one plate and I’m pretty sure they accidentally gave me enough food to feed a youth baseball team and their coaches. The portions aren’t generous… they’re borderline heroic. You don’t leave Super Taters hungry — you leave with a to-go box, a plan for tomorrow’s lunch, and a slight concern about how you’re going to button your jeans.
And the food? Always fresh. Not “it was fresh today” fresh. I’m talking consistent, every-single-time fresh. Hot, seasoned right, and delicious in a way that makes you close your eyes for a second and nod like you just heard good news.
But the real secret ingredient? The way they treat you. Walking into Super Taters feels like you’re their long-lost cousin they haven’t seen in forever and 47 days. They greet you like, “Where you been? Sit down. Eat.” And then they proceed to serve you an amazing meal like they’ve been saving up recipes just waiting for your return.
Five stars. Bring your appetite. And maybe stretchy pants.
… moreMcKinley Proffitt
Food was great, my shrimp wrap had an odd taste though and my shrimps were mushy but that could have been from getting cold. I wasn’t aware that if I sent in my boyfriend it would be almost 60 for 3 meals but if I knew how big the tater boxes were I would have made him just get three of those. You get a large portion for a decent price on that one. The wrap was relatively small and he didn’t see in the fine print it was $2 extra for cheese. Other than that it wasn’t terrible for our first time trying and would definitely like to just get me a tater next time!
… more