Josh Haas
So I love steak, but the one i got here was under seasoned, over priced, and low quality. I like fat on a steak but this was too fatty. The potato was better than the steak. The bread rolls were bland pretzel rolls that tasted days old and reheated. And there was flies and other fling insects that kept trying to land in my food. Over all not very good. The last nail in the coffin was when a customer asked for a rag to clean up the mess left by the last people. It was a huge waste of time and money. Safe to say i won’t be returning.
… moreAmanda Rice
We were absolutely appalled by the treatment we received at Sunset Steakhouse at Fortune Bay. It was our 22nd wedding anniversary, and we were looking forward to a nice dinner with our family. The restaurant was practically empty when we arrived around 5:15 PM, yet the hostess was extremely rude and refused to seat our group of six.
We even offered to come back later, trying to be polite and flexible, but she curtly told us they were “full for the night.” We then asked if we could sit at the completely empty bar, and she refused that as well, offering no explanation and maintaining an unnecessarily rude attitude throughout.
We ended up having grilled cheese and burgers at a café instead — and honestly, the kindness and service there were far better. For a restaurant that’s supposed to offer fine dining, the lack of professionalism, warmth, and basic courtesy at Sunset Steakhouse was shocking.
Extremely disappointing and disrespectful service. We won’t be back and wouldn’t recommend this place to anyone.
… moreTom Krapu
One of the better restaurants on the property.
The server was very good.
Had a fun wine, and the food was solid.
The only disappointing thing was, they were probably understaffed, so the bar was not open, so you couldn’t wait for your table and have a drink.
… moreGreg Pierce
NY strip smothered with loaded baked potato and green beans. Pretzel rolls for the table before the meal. Steak was cooked to temperature as order at medium rare. Loaded baked potato was cooked wonderfully and not dried out. NY strip is not my favorite Steak but this was loaded with flavor.
… moreMich M
Every single thing we ordered at this steakhouse was perfection. The Caesar salad was crisp and flavorful, the house salad fresh and balanced, and the wild rice soup was rich and comforting. Our filet was cooked flawlessly, and the jumbo fried shrimp were golden and delicious. The sides were equally impressive—creamy mashed potatoes, classic wild rice, and hands down the best baked potato of my life.
The food was outstanding, but the service made it unforgettable. Troy, our server, was friendly, attentive, and genuinely elevated the entire experience. We left full, happy, and already planning our return. Highly recommend.
Would return just for this restaurant, which was almost fully reserved on a Tuesday.
… moreFred Earl
Go there alot lately good food.this time I order something different,food was done less then 5 minutes I received a burger that was barely cooked cold fries.girlfriend got a slicked steak burger with onion and peppers that were definitely just taken out of the fridge steak was one piece not sliced ,watress ask if we needed anything I told her right away I’m not eating this as my blood from my burger was under my cold fries.she had a attitude what do you want me to do about it. And then walked away.then 2 minutes went by I believe was either the cook or manager.asked same thing I responded by telling him I just dont want it no more I was done eating.neither seemed like it was a big deal that my burger was very undercooked Evan after I showed both.then he came back and said don’t worry about the bill.should be more concerned about food safety instead.
… moreKath UEP
Food was excellent. Best meal we had in the area all week. Our server, sweetest, efficient ever. Very small place. Def make a reservation.
… moreKatie Rice
Hostess was horribly rude. Very aggressive and acted like doing her job was the worst task. Definitely don’t recommend
… moreChad Thelen
Between tournament and awards, the convenience of this place cant be best. My hunger level is willing to overlook the lack of flavor. When options are limited. This is a win all day.
… moreKaty Ellsworth
Food is way overpriced, I got a side salad that was tiny with iceberg lettuce for $6. Total disappointment. Steak was very fatty but the fries were good lol. Our waitress was nice but the other waiting staff was irritated we wanted to put two tables together and said we couldn’t do that unless we are on one check. Really? Go to Tavern in the Bay instead ~ way better food, atmosphere and pricing!
… more