Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Brick oven Pizza with house-made sauce, sandwiches and sides, subs, Perry’s hand dipped ice cream, shakes and Sundaes, warm pastries, house brewed ice tea, fountain drinks, root beer, many Pepsi products. ’50s ’60s diner style, walls covered in the history of Beaver Valley and its residents. Online ordering with pictures and food descriptions, reserve seating, CHECK OUR FACEBOOK FOR UPDATES, NEW MENU ITEMS, AND LOTS OF PICTURES
Address and Contact Information
Address: Beside Post Office at, 5642 Beaver Pike, Beaver, OH 45613
Phone: (740) 226-8292
Website: https://www.sullysinthevalley.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Sully’s In the Valley
Veteran-owned and operated restaurant in the heart of Beaver, Ohio.
Sully’s in the Valley | Beaver OH – Facebook
We will be open 11:00 to 9:00 today, come have dinner with us before or after the game. ☎️ 740-226-8292 or use online ordering directly from our Facebook …
Sully’s In The Valley – Order Online
… orders. Sully’s In The Valley. 5642 Beaver Pike (Main St), Next door to Post Office, Beaver, OH. Pizza. Subs. Sandwiches. Sides. Salads. Extra Condiments.
Reviews
David Humston
Sully’s surpassed all expectations in terms of atmosphere. The place is really neat with antiques and old signage. I appreciate the family-oriented layout and menu items. The staff were both really nice. But, this Thursday night it was busy, so service was a bit slow. The manager walked around occasionally and asked about the food. They have quite a few ice cream options but we passed on dessert. We enjoyed burgers, onion petals, wings, and fries. The prices are fair. I give everything a “satisfactory” rating. Food was good but nothing special. It was similar to other family diners. I feel the star is the ice cream, which we missed. Maybe next time! I definitely recommend giving this one a go! Budget friendly and an overall pleasant experience!
… moreAdkins Gaming
Had an amazing experience it is a small town gem in Beaver Ohio great food great people me and my partner had the garlic cheese bread it was fantastic I had the Philly cheese steak and it’s the best one I have ever had my partner had the steak burger in her words “very juicy and tender not dry like most steak burgers then we finished with some ice cream mine and hers response we making this a new favorite date night spot
… moreLichlight
Cute retro diner with amazing food. Has easily became a great choice for regular stops. You feel like you get your money’s worth for sure. Potato skins are on point! Monster dog has great flavor <3
… moreTL Kessel
Food was absolutely delicious! Great service! Will definitely go back when I’m in the area! Our group had a mushroom Swiss burger, tenderloin sandwich, Philly cheese steak and a spicy chicken sandwich with pickle chips, house made potato chips and fries. Everyone’s food was great! Highly recommended!
… moreHolly Becher
Husband and I stopped here for lunch while on our 25th anniversary vacation near Beaver in a remote cabin in Jan. 2025. We loved this place so much, we are planning to go back for our 26th anniversary next month! Sully’s has such a wide variety of food and fun treats. You will surely have trouble deciding what to order! Yum!!!
UPDATE: We went back for our 2nd visit in Jan. 2026, again for our anniversary trip. Food was amazing again! We had the philly cheese steak sub and spicy chicken sandwich with some sides of breaded mushrooms, banana pepper rings, and hot pepper cheese balls. We talked with the owner, Steve, for over 20 minutes. What a neat guy! We also got a dessert on the house for our big day! Thanks so much for the hospitality!!! Sully’s, we will be back!! This is a must-stop eatery!!
… moreUPDATE: We went back for our 2nd visit in Jan. 2026, again for our anniversary trip. Food was amazing again! We had the philly cheese steak sub and spicy chicken sandwich with some sides of breaded mushrooms, banana pepper rings, and hot pepper cheese balls. We talked with the owner, Steve, for over 20 minutes. What a neat guy! We also got a dessert on the house for our big day! Thanks so much for the hospitality!!! Sully’s, we will be back!! This is a must-stop eatery!!
Lexi Wagel
Came from 2 hours away to see a christmas cave event. Was recommended Sally’s. They did not disappoint. Food was very good. We came in with a rather large group and they all enjoyed the atmosphere and food! Staff and owner was very friendly, would definitely recommend this others. An if im ever in the area again. I will definitely come back!
… moreMary Mahoney
Super friendly, super clean and super good fresh food! We had the hamburgers that are made from scratch. Photo is of Sully burger with coleslaw and it was super yummy! Bonus points for the toasted bun!! Gold bond malt completed this awesome lunch!
We could tell the owner really cares about the food and the appearance of his place.
Great stop!!
… moreWe could tell the owner really cares about the food and the appearance of his place.
Great stop!!
Candy Dishong
I’ve only been at Sully’s once so far, but I loved it. The burger was excellent and the pizza was also good. I think they put the toppings on after the pizza is baked, so the toppings weren’t done to my preference, but it was still good. The atmosphere is excellent and the staff were super friendly. I hope to go back again soon even though it’s an hour away for us.
… moreJane “MJ” Marcum
Great food, very clean, staff was friendly and helpful. Must recommend the banana split. We got hand dipped Perrys ice cream in our banana split black raspberry, study break, and banana cream pie with Carmel drizzle instead of hot fudge, delicious combo! Pizza was cooked in fire brick over very good crust. Highly recommend the potato skins.
… moreJuli
Gorgeous retro atmosphere. I work nearby and ordered to go a couple days. Large salad is XL and wonderful!!! Sully Burger with slaw perfect!!! Loaded Tater Tots with sour cream…OMG! Gotta stop on the way home for some ice cream!!!
… more