Social Profile: 
![]()
![]()
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Your local Casper Subway® Restaurant at 41 SE Wyoming Blvd. brings bold new flavors and classic favorites to guests every day. Enjoy our famous Footlongs, 6 sandwiches, wraps, and salads, ordered quickly in the app or online, through convenient delivery, in-restaurant dining, or curbside pickup. We’re proud to offer a fresh alternative to typical fast food with fresh-cut veggies, tasty proteins, fresh-baked bread, and delicious cookies. We’re also here for your catering needs. All Subway® Restaurants are independently owned and operated by business owners who employ talented Sandwich Artists™.
Casual counter-serve chain for build-your-own sandwiches & salads, with health-conscious options.
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Subway Locations in Casper, WY| Subs, Sandwiches, Salads
Subway Locations in Casper: 1905 E 2nd St We’re Open – Closes at 9:00 PM 1905 E 2nd St Casper, WY 82601 234 N Center St. We’re Open – Closes at 9:
Subway® Restaurants | SUBWAY at 4255 Cy Ave Casper (W) WY
Your local Casper (W) Subway® Restaurant at 4255 Cy Ave brings bold new flavors and classic favorites to guests every day. Enjoy our famous Footlongs, 6″ …
Subway Locations in Casper (W), WY| Subs, Sandwiches, Salads
Browse all Subway locations in Casper (W), WY to find a restaurant near you that serves fresh subs, sandwiches, salads, & more. View the abundant options on …
Reviews
Mauricio Soto
First of all, I have never been treated this poorly by a food establishment in my life. The level of unprofessionalism I experienced was honestly shocking.
I placed a DoorDash order for a sandwich, Coke, chips, and cookies. When my order arrived, the cookies were wrong and there was no Coke or chips included at all. I called the store, and the night shift manager with pink hair told me I would have to bring the order in for them to fix it. Mind you, I had already paid a delivery fee to have the food brought to my house, but instead of simply correcting their mistake, they made me go out of my way and drive there myself.
When I arrived, she insisted on seeing the sandwich first, as if she thought I was lying. After looking at it, it turned out I was right about the issues, yet she still tried to argue with me. She claimed some of the order buttons must not have been pressed correctly, but that still doesn’t explain why my Coke and chips were missing or why I received the wrong cookies.
When I asked where my Coke was, she actually looked at the receipt like I was making it up and said it wasn’t on there. I had to physically point to the line where it clearly said Coke. Only then did she acknowledge it, and even then she was extremely rude about it.
On top of that, she tried to make me pay again for a bag of chips that I had already purchased online. Then when I simply switched the cookies to the correct ones I originally ordered, she ran outside chasing after me and accused me of stealing. It was completely unnecessary and incredibly disrespectful. I explained that I was only correcting the cookies to what I had actually paid for, but she continued talking very disrespectfully to me.
This was one of the most frustrating and unprofessional experiences I’ve ever had with a restaurant. I will never come back here again, and management seriously needs to reevaluate who they have representing their business.
Over a sandwich wow. We all know you ain’t making nearly enough to chase someone out the store accusing them of stealing 2.99 cookies. Get a life and learn how to make a sandwich.
… moreI placed a DoorDash order for a sandwich, Coke, chips, and cookies. When my order arrived, the cookies were wrong and there was no Coke or chips included at all. I called the store, and the night shift manager with pink hair told me I would have to bring the order in for them to fix it. Mind you, I had already paid a delivery fee to have the food brought to my house, but instead of simply correcting their mistake, they made me go out of my way and drive there myself.
When I arrived, she insisted on seeing the sandwich first, as if she thought I was lying. After looking at it, it turned out I was right about the issues, yet she still tried to argue with me. She claimed some of the order buttons must not have been pressed correctly, but that still doesn’t explain why my Coke and chips were missing or why I received the wrong cookies.
When I asked where my Coke was, she actually looked at the receipt like I was making it up and said it wasn’t on there. I had to physically point to the line where it clearly said Coke. Only then did she acknowledge it, and even then she was extremely rude about it.
On top of that, she tried to make me pay again for a bag of chips that I had already purchased online. Then when I simply switched the cookies to the correct ones I originally ordered, she ran outside chasing after me and accused me of stealing. It was completely unnecessary and incredibly disrespectful. I explained that I was only correcting the cookies to what I had actually paid for, but she continued talking very disrespectfully to me.
This was one of the most frustrating and unprofessional experiences I’ve ever had with a restaurant. I will never come back here again, and management seriously needs to reevaluate who they have representing their business.
Over a sandwich wow. We all know you ain’t making nearly enough to chase someone out the store accusing them of stealing 2.99 cookies. Get a life and learn how to make a sandwich.
Zombie
Let me start by saying wow!!!!! If I wasn’t so hungry from being on the road all day I would have said nope and walked away when she started making my sandwich!!! I ordered a footlong chicken teriyaki that she decided to put rotisserie chicken in steak of the normal white chicken breasts cuts. Has a totally different taste with the sauce and I don’t care for it. Then there was such disrespect on my sandwich just plop everything on there leave it all in a clump , that makes for a great sandwich when all the meat is in 2 piles on either half . The glass doors were sticking due to the filth accumulated all over , when grabbing sauces and the shaking they stuck as well where nothing gets cleaned or wiped!!!! The tables and drink counter could house a staff infection they looked so bad. The floors stick as you walk.
Please if your that fed up with your job , please do not continue customer service work. No one wants to be treated this way. The meal could have been free and I’d still be rubbed the wrong way. My truck isn’t half this dirty!!!!!
P.s. all that was missing was gunshots and this would definitely be the worst subway in America ( coming from a coast to coast trucker with a VIP pilot status!!).
… morePlease if your that fed up with your job , please do not continue customer service work. No one wants to be treated this way. The meal could have been free and I’d still be rubbed the wrong way. My truck isn’t half this dirty!!!!!
P.s. all that was missing was gunshots and this would definitely be the worst subway in America ( coming from a coast to coast trucker with a VIP pilot status!!).
Mike Golczynski
No one makes em saucier! I was stunned to learn that one of your employees actually remembered me from Christmas when I ordered dippers for my special needs son (he called them diapers! He’s doing the best he can every day.) Anyway, I love this Subway mostly because of their strong, anti sicko policy which, unfortunately, means that my son cannot go inside.
… moreMatt N.
Excellent Subway location Toni is slinging salami like a pro , fast & well made sandwiches, very clean store. Ignore old bad dumb reviews .
… moreAnatolii Kyliukh
Issue with Service at Subway in Flying J Truck Stop, Casper
Today, February 28, I arrived at Flying J Truck Stop in Casper, WY at 9:30 PM. Inside, there is a Subway, and I wanted to order a sandwich. However, there were no employees present.
I called, but no one answered. Then I went to the front desk and asked for help. The employee said she would look for someone from Subway.
She checked inside—no one. Then she went outside and saw that one of the Subway workers was just sitting there. When she came back, she said: “I don’t know where they are.”
I decided to wait since the website states that Subway is open until 10:00 PM. It was 9:45, and the employees were still absent. Five minutes later, a worker arrived and said: “We are already closed.”
When I asked why, if Subway operates until 10 PM, she replied: “Well, yes, but we are already closed, we are cleaning.”
Her name is Ray.
I went back to the Fuel Desk and asked if there was a manager available. A lady named Electa came over. I asked what time Subway closes. She said, “10 PM.”
I said, “It’s 9:50 now. That means it should still be open, right?”
“Yes, it is open.”
“Then why can’t I place an order at Subway?”
“I don’t know. That’s not my responsibility. I have no authority over them. I work here.”
Well, thank you for your indifference and lack of responsibility!
No one takes accountability for anything. Complete disorder. When they should be serving customers, they sit outside. When they should be paying attention, they don’t see anything. Shameful and unacceptable.
This is unacceptable service! I specifically stopped at this truck stop to refuel and grab food, but instead, I was completely ignored. If your posted hours say you’re open until 10:00 PM, customers expect to be served until that time—not to be turned away early because employees decide to close whenever they want.
If anyone is planning to stop here, be prepared that Subway might be closed even if their schedule says otherwise. Or the staff might simply not be there, and no one will help you.
I would not recommend this truck stop for a stop and will definitely never return!
… moreToday, February 28, I arrived at Flying J Truck Stop in Casper, WY at 9:30 PM. Inside, there is a Subway, and I wanted to order a sandwich. However, there were no employees present.
I called, but no one answered. Then I went to the front desk and asked for help. The employee said she would look for someone from Subway.
She checked inside—no one. Then she went outside and saw that one of the Subway workers was just sitting there. When she came back, she said: “I don’t know where they are.”
I decided to wait since the website states that Subway is open until 10:00 PM. It was 9:45, and the employees were still absent. Five minutes later, a worker arrived and said: “We are already closed.”
When I asked why, if Subway operates until 10 PM, she replied: “Well, yes, but we are already closed, we are cleaning.”
Her name is Ray.
I went back to the Fuel Desk and asked if there was a manager available. A lady named Electa came over. I asked what time Subway closes. She said, “10 PM.”
I said, “It’s 9:50 now. That means it should still be open, right?”
“Yes, it is open.”
“Then why can’t I place an order at Subway?”
“I don’t know. That’s not my responsibility. I have no authority over them. I work here.”
Well, thank you for your indifference and lack of responsibility!
No one takes accountability for anything. Complete disorder. When they should be serving customers, they sit outside. When they should be paying attention, they don’t see anything. Shameful and unacceptable.
This is unacceptable service! I specifically stopped at this truck stop to refuel and grab food, but instead, I was completely ignored. If your posted hours say you’re open until 10:00 PM, customers expect to be served until that time—not to be turned away early because employees decide to close whenever they want.
If anyone is planning to stop here, be prepared that Subway might be closed even if their schedule says otherwise. Or the staff might simply not be there, and no one will help you.
I would not recommend this truck stop for a stop and will definitely never return!
Kuldeep Dhillon
On thanksgiving there was only one man working and there was bucnch of orders online and waiting line but that serving guy was very polite and management should put two guys working on this day
… moreNoemi Soto Miramontes
I called to see if it was open phone picked up then hung up right away , called back they answered then asked if they hung up on me and he said yea I did ,then hung up again the I called back asked if I could speak to the Manager then he said that in the morning I could then hung up again very rude for no reason.
… moreMike C
I ordered a Subway from this Subway. I saw a video by YouTube celery who got mad over a note which showed CARE. They remember him by name and all the sauces he ordered. Now that’s customer service. TMDWU !!! Best Subway this side of Casper dood.
… moreChad Macinnis
I heard everyone around town talking about this gothic wizard and his saucey subway from subway, I knew I had to seek out the sauces. Boy! I was not let down, after receiving my sauce subway and letting it cool off on the counter overnight I dug in and was practically swimming in all the sauce. Definitely gonna need a diaper after this sub. 10/10 toobs.
… moreThe Goat Queen
Shout out to this subway (not a sponsor) and everything they do for the Gothic community. Everyone’s welcome here, even if you can’t control your bowels (side effect of excessive sauce intake). Don’t listen to the fake goth haters, this subway is the real deal for exquisite food hacking snacking action. The goth wizard trying to cast a spell on this place has been afflicted by drunkium which sadly causes an impairment to reading comprehension, the dippers were awesome. Will be back, great place for a place to bring a date if they’re between the ages of 18-21. Ch’yeah! Legal.
… more