Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Your local East Orange Subway® Restaurant at 491-495 Prospect Street brings bold new flavors and classic favorites to guests every day. Enjoy our famous Footlongs, 6 sandwiches, wraps, and salads, ordered quickly in the app or online, through convenient delivery, in-restaurant dining, or curbside pickup. We’re proud to offer a fresh alternative to typical fast food with fresh-cut veggies, tasty proteins, fresh-baked bread, and delicious cookies. We’re also here for your catering needs. All Subway® Restaurants are independently owned and operated by business owners who employ talented Sandwich Artists™.
Casual counter-serve chain for build-your-own sandwiches & salads, with health-conscious options.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 491-495 Prospect Street, 85 Dodd St Aka, East Orange, NJ 07017
Phone: (973) 530-2700
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
SUBWAY at 491-495 Prospect Street East Orange NJ
Your local East Orange Subway® Restaurant at 491-495 Prospect Street brings bold new flavors and classic favorites to guests every day. Enjoy our famous …
Subway® Restaurants | SUBWAY at 513 Central Ave East Orange NJ
Discover better for you sub sandwiches at SUBWAY 513 Central Ave in East Orange NJ. View our menu of sub sandwiches, see nutritional info, find restaurants, …
Subway Locations in East Orange, NJ| Subs, Sandwiches, Salads
Sunoco Gas Station /Open 24 Hours. 491-495 Prospect Street. Aka /85 Dodd Street. East Orange , NJ 07017. US · Carvel Ice Cream/We’re Open – Closes at 10:00 PM.
Reviews
Umid Adilov
I stopped by a gas station that had a Subway inside, and I was genuinely impressed by how convenient and efficient the experience was. Even though it’s not a full sit-down restaurant, the quality of the food and service matched or even exceeded some larger locations.
The staff behind the counter were quick, friendly, and professional. I ordered a 6-inch Turkey Breast sub through the drive-thru, and it was ready in just a few minutes. Everything was fresh—the veggies were crisp, the bread was warm, and the sandwich was assembled neatly. They didn’t skimp on the ingredients, which is always a plus.
Inside the gas station store, the Subway area was clean and well-maintained, and everything was clearly labeled and organized. It’s the perfect spot to grab a meal on the go, especially when you’re on a road trip or need a quick lunch during a busy day.
The only minor downside is that there’s no dine-in option, but that’s to be expected in a gas station setting. Overall, I’d rate this location 4.5 out of 5 stars for its speed, freshness, and convenience. I’ll definitely be stopping by again the next time I’m passing through!
… moreThe staff behind the counter were quick, friendly, and professional. I ordered a 6-inch Turkey Breast sub through the drive-thru, and it was ready in just a few minutes. Everything was fresh—the veggies were crisp, the bread was warm, and the sandwich was assembled neatly. They didn’t skimp on the ingredients, which is always a plus.
Inside the gas station store, the Subway area was clean and well-maintained, and everything was clearly labeled and organized. It’s the perfect spot to grab a meal on the go, especially when you’re on a road trip or need a quick lunch during a busy day.
The only minor downside is that there’s no dine-in option, but that’s to be expected in a gas station setting. Overall, I’d rate this location 4.5 out of 5 stars for its speed, freshness, and convenience. I’ll definitely be stopping by again the next time I’m passing through!
Frank Sadykhoff
I ordered a sandwich from them and there is actually mold or god knows what this is on the sandwich. On the turkey, on the bread. Usually I don’t write reviews but this is disturbing disgusting disappointing. Photos will prove it.
… moreJenna
I can’t complaint about their sandwiches, but I asked them if I could buy another footlong sandwich roll, and they wouldn’t sell it to me. They sometimes put way too much meat on their sandwiches, so I wanted to split it up by putting on another roll. I offered to pay for it, I don’t understand why they wouldn’t do it for me.
… moreaxel
So apparently “open 24 hours” at this Subway means only if you’re not too picky about what you actually want to eat. Walked in after 11 PM thinking, you know, since they advertise being open ALL NIGHT, I could get an actual sandwich. Silly me! Turns out after 11 PM, they magically “can’t make” certain sandwiches. Why? Who knows. Maybe the bread goes to sleep. Maybe the veggies clock out. Maybe the toaster has a curfew.
Don’t advertise 24 hours if you’re just going to be a glorified fridge with lights on. If you can’t serve your full menu, say that. Or better yet—just close the store and save us the gas.
Not sure what’s more stale—the bread or the logic behind this policy.
… moreDon’t advertise 24 hours if you’re just going to be a glorified fridge with lights on. If you can’t serve your full menu, say that. Or better yet—just close the store and save us the gas.
Not sure what’s more stale—the bread or the logic behind this policy.
Jem And the Holograms
Ordered a cold cut sub with lettuce and cucumber. I received a sub with meat, sauce, and that’s it. I called to see if they could perhaps remake my sub, but no. They don’t answer the phone!
… moreWerleich karlls
They don’t understand how to prepare what you’ve ordered, they just stand there speaking mujabi, just toast the bread when I said toast the bread please.
… moreDpa Kandel
I went there on Monday night..The sandwich prepared by Ana was really good..I like the way she talks to the customer ..Definitely Recommend..
… moreArthur Charles Fleming 3rd
My daughter bought a sandwich and a large Sprite to go
She took the lid off the cup, and there was a bug sitting on top of the ice
I called the store
The guy I spoke to didn’t feel an apology was necessary
He repeated that it shouldn’t have happened twice
I stopped going to this store a long time ago
The people who work there have no respect for my kind
They’re the type who refuse to put the change in your hand and prefer to slam it on the counter
Steer clear of this establishment…
… moreShe took the lid off the cup, and there was a bug sitting on top of the ice
I called the store
The guy I spoke to didn’t feel an apology was necessary
He repeated that it shouldn’t have happened twice
I stopped going to this store a long time ago
The people who work there have no respect for my kind
They’re the type who refuse to put the change in your hand and prefer to slam it on the counter
Steer clear of this establishment…
Chidimma Nwaogwugwu
Run away! These people have terrible customer service!!! I went through their drive through and added all the toppings I wanted on my sandwich only to come home and see that the only thing that was on my sandwich was meat and cheese. I drove all the way bag to ask for my sandwich to be remade, the man tells me “it’s not my fault you didn’t add the correct toppings, I’m not replacing your sandwich, that’s a waste of money.” I told him that I definitely added my toppings, his machine did not pick up my order. He refused to give me a new sandwich. I then requested a refund, this man refused! I then called the police and the man still refused to give me my money back. The cop basically told me that he could only make him add the toppings I wanted to the sandwich that they already made for me. He could not make him give me another sandwich or give me my money back. I said keep the money and the sandwich, it’s the principle for me. What a stupid way to run a business. You just lost a repeating customer because you were too cheap to lose $12, because I will never step foot there again! What an idiot!!!!!! They definitely don’t care for people of my kind. Black ppl beware.
… moreRachael P.
SUPER clean store,fully stocked with everything u need esp if you work late night or early morning hours. My sandwich was delicious and for once, looked just like the sandwiches on the commercial! My ONLY complaint is that the guy and girl working behind the Subway part were rude. They seemed annoyed to be there at 1am, which is when I went in after work. Other than them, zero complaints.
… more