Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Stuff a Bagel
Our Locations. Stuff a Bagel Farmingdale 234 Main Street Farmingdale, NY 11735 516-420-4287. Stuff A Bagel Bethpage 350 Broadway Bethpage, NY 11714 516-933 …
Stuff A Bagel
Dig into mouthwatering bagels, antipasto platters, salads, and more by visiting Stuff A Bagel Massapequa.
Stuff-A-Bagel – Best Bagel Shop in East Islip, NY
Discover fresh, delicious bagels at Stuff-A-Bagel, East Islip’s top bagel shop. Visit us at 24 E Main St for a tasty breakfast or lunch!
Reviews
Nic Tolino
Excellent bagels, super friendly staff and clean store. New owners who took over years ago really got their system running well. We are EI natives and only venture here for weekend bagels over the past 2 years. Love the addition of fresh pressed juices and even vegan cream cheese for friends and family with dietary restrictions.
… moreSelena Thompson
I got the western omelette with home fries and an egg bagel. The staff were kind and the food was delicious.
… moreJames JT Bruno
I have been going here nearly everyday for around 2 years now. Best bagels on all of Long Island!
… moreChris A
This place is great. Bagels are fresh and well made (as opposed to some of the other near by bagel stores). The people who work there are super pleasant and helpful and the prices are good!
… moreLuc M
I was a regular customer for a while but never again!! Literally had my order messed up more times than have it correct but Dealt with there over priced and overrated food due to travel Convience and friendly environment but when you’re paying high prices for indelible food at times?!! or continuously paying for food to realize your order is wrong is very frustrating!! the owners are completely incompetent!! don’t seem to understand or care. I recommend it’s not worth the HEADACHE, stay away!!!!
… moreHeidi Schmidt
One of the best bagel stores I’ve ever been to. The sandwiches are phenomenal. The store is always super clean and everything in the case is always beautifully presented and super fresh. And the staff are always so nice.
… moreOtis0468
Ester was great with over-the-phone early pick-up order. Thank you for the great service, everyone enjoyed the delicious bagels and coffee
… moreJoseph Mazzella
Best bagels around. This place gets busy so that will add to your wait. But the absolute worst part is that only the owners will ring you out. This can add to your wait time. They need to trust all their workers that they won’t steal from them.
… moreLeo Abbate
First time trying this establishment and just overall great service, great food, and great atmosphere. Everything is fresh and the facility is so clean. I was greeted so kindly in the morning. The staff are very nice! Food prep was quick and done with care. Prices are great!
… moreThomas McNamee
Read this hole thing. I go there five days a week Mon to Fri and get a bagel with egg, ch, bacon and a drink. After I paid today I realized I needed a empty paper cup for a thermos I have later. I told the owner and he tells me a quarter. I said to him I spend about $60 a week here every week and your gonna charge for a empty cup. I was very insulted and told him so. He said well I have bills. I told him if you value my business so little I will go elsewhere. He acted like he could care less. He should because they are always empty lately. They are nor the best bagel store at all not close. They are just down the block from me.
… more