Best Pizza Restaurant in Midtown Savannah”. Stoner’s Pizza Joint is a local favorite for their delicious pizza, their amazing service, and their great dining environment. Featuring spectacular design and an easy dining experience, Stoner’s Pizza Joint guarantees a fun time and is the best place to go in Midtown Savannah for pizza food. It is among the top restaurants in all of Midtown Savannah and is definitely a local must-try!” COVID 19 prepared!!
Justin L
Well, where to begin….?
Short answer: Go-to Sam’s Club food court, or grab a frozen pizza from the Dollar Store. You’ll have a better experience & much better quality food, and fully cooked as well.
Should’ve known better with the “restaurant” being sandwiched between a Subway & a strip mall sushi place.
Ordered a large hand tossed pizza, pepperoni rolls, and cinnamon rolls. Each item was flavorless, undercooked, underwhelming, and quite small, if we’re comparing sizes.
The large hand tossed pizza might have been considered large if one were the size of a leprechaun with a height somewhere beneath the 50th percentile… Instead of being hand tossed, the pizza resembled dough that had been steamrolled over and over, then left outside in the humidity to be turned down by the flies… The taste was reminiscent of softened cardboard, tho I have a feeling hand tossed cardboard would’ve tasted better.
Both the pepperoni and cinnamon rolls were not baked anywhere near long enough to be considered edible; my niece does a better job with her E-Z Bake Oven… Regardless of the amount of sauce & icing one could pour over these dog treats, forcing them down would be a feat not for the faint of heart… The undercooked dough was limp like your grandfather, and just as poor performing regarding the supposed flavor that was nowhere to be found…
Even if I were stoned, I wouldn’t be able to rate this at 2 stars. Incredibly disappointed… Y’all need to do better.
… moreJared Fisher
I rarely write reviews but my experience was so terrible i felt like I need to warn people about ever thinking of eating here. Came here ordered a small chicken bacon RANCH pizza. As you can see in the pictures there was no ranch. Ordered the cinnamon sticks and these lazy employees forgot to put cinnamon on em! I mean it’s in the damn name. Biggest waste of my money this year. Not to mention the two “employees” working treat this as their daycare as there were 4 kids screaming in the shop, when I walked in there was 1 in the kitchen without gloves doing something with pizza dough. God forbid they served that dough…. They probably did. DO NOT EAT HERE
… moreJulie C. McArthur
I went to this place for the first time because I was looking for a new place to try Pizza at and I saw it had good reviews. I don’t know if this was just an off night, but we went in and it was completely silent. There was only one person working covered in flower and sauce, and not wear. Any gloves are washing their hands in between any transitions. I was very hesitant to even eat the food, but I did put it in the oven when I got home and it was OK but I would not go back here again.
… moreAnnestasia Alderson
Not sure how this is a deluxe pizza and why it cost $39 for the small with none of the toppings that it’s advertised to come with. It had black olives and banana peppers… that’s it for toppings.
… moreJadeAdore Davis
Had the lunch special and some delicious chocolate chip cookies !!! Good music was playing and my appetite was fulfilled!!! I had a bad experience at the downtown location and this visit definitely improved my view of the business … this time felt like family .
… moreNick Klemetson
Ordered online to go. Arrived 15 minutes later and gave my name. Went and sat down. 10 minutes later he asked my name again and said he didn’t have my order. I showed it on my phone and he said okay. Five minutes later he came back and checked my phone AGAIN. 10 minutes later a different employee asked what my order was. Ten more minutes go by and they say they’re upgrading me to a large. Sure, why not? I don’t want to eat that much though. It’s 11:50pm and I just want to go home. They checked my phone again. Not sure why this time. I’ve seen two Doordash drivers come in and walk right out with a pizza.
I don’t know at what point my food started getting cooked but I sat in the restaurant for 45 minutes total. I heard “It’s coming out now, sir!” about 4 times. It’s 12:00am now, officially Sunday. I need to be at work in 7-ish hours. I just hope the pizza is edible. Not even good, just edible. I’m peeking over the counter and see three pizzas on the oven. I hope one is mine.
12:05am. Pizza acquired!! Smells good. Driving home now.
12:15am. They forgot to cut it! This pizza is actually really good though. Lots of toppings, crispy on top and good flavor all around.
I’d hate to see the place when it’s busy. Lots of people were coming and going. Music was blaring loudly. People kept coming in and out but they weren’t customers. I was entertained by a 10 year old kid folding pizza boxes. He folded 33 as I sat there.
… moreAubriAutumn
I’ve had the opportunity to meet an outstanding individual here; Mr. Terrell, not only did he help me with my order but he suggested the wings, and Hands Down!! theses are some of the best wings in the Coastal Empire. In addition, the chocolate chip cookies will take you back to child hood. Please give this guy a raise; he really cares about his customers, and the quality of the great food he prepares; the results are heart felt, delicious pizza, with cool fresh dessert. Don’t take my word for it, JUST STOP BY!! STONERS PIZZA !!
… moreNikki Forgey
The portion sizes are a scam. We ordered two LARGE pizzas and they look like smalls. They’re 9-10inches. Over $50 plus tip. We won’t be ordering from here in the future. Lesson learned. Waste of money.
… moreTabetha Nichols
I try to be as fair as possible when leaving a review. I looked at all aspects of service. I had my order delivered. I ordered the “It’s A Partay”, which comes with 2 extra large 2 topping pizzas, 12 cookies, garlic knots, and a 2 liter. They did not have any cookies available, so they substituted cinnamon rolls. The knots and cinnamon rolls were uncooked, and the cinnamon roll didn’t have any icing, which clearly stated they came with cream cheese icing on top and on the side. I called the location in midtown, 1100 Eisenhower Dr., to inform them of my finding and was told by the Manager, Tisha in a nasty rude way that she could refund me a dollar and I would have to come pick the dollar up because my order was delivered. The way this so-called manager talks to customers; she shouldn’t be employed. Why would I come get a dollar refund after I gave a tip that was 10 times the amount of the dollar. The pizza was nasty. My family didn’t even eat the pizza. The pictures are from the next day. I have contacted the corporate office.
… moreJ Bubbles
I ordered a small Buffalo chicken pizza and 5 Buffalo wings with ranch for delivery. It go here on time, delivery guy wasn’t friendly but wasn’t unfriendly either. The pizza was $13 for 10″…..really overpriced for what it is. Especially when you can see that 1/3 of the pizza is crust. Regardless, it was delicious. The wings were pretty good too, although one of them was burnt on the outside and slightly under cooked on the inside. The sauce does not stick to the wings so there wasn’t really any buffalo flavor, but the flavoring from smoking them made them better. The wings were $6 for 5. They’re pretty fat wings, so they’re worth the price. The ranch sauce was quite bland. To me, it tasted like lots of butter and mayo and barely any ranch. It was also warm, so that might be why the taste was off. I’d order from here again, but due to the price of the pizza, it won’t be often. I give it 4 starts because the food really was delicious.
… more