R B
Stopped in on a cold day to grab lunch. We sat by the warm fire and were greeted promptly. Great job from Brandon on getting our drinks and orders. He provided good feedback with a few questions we had about the menu. I had the Cuban sandwich with a cup of the onion soup. Both were great and the sandwich was very big!
… moreDani D.
It’s pretty with a nice view. Indoor and outdoor seating. The food was okay, the salad was great, the sandwiches were sandwiches lol, my sangria was amazing. Make sure to look at your receipt before paying because we had a whole extra meal added to ours that was more expensive than both the meals we ordered. The waiter was nice about it though apologized and fixed it promptly. Said it happens sometimes because of their computer system someone may add something to the wrong table. The dessert was amazing though I highly recommend the chocolate chip cookie dough cake! I wish I could have a whole cake lol I got it to go and didn’t get any plastic silverware and ended of just eating it with my hands because it looked so good and it didn’t disappoint!
… moreNina TS
We went here for a couples dinner date. Overall, it was a good experience but lacked an exciting factor. The pretzel appetizer was very oily but delicious. Our 4 meals were alright but nothing fancy. The bread was crispy on the sandwiches, and my burger was an average burger. The desserts were good, but again, they just fell short. More ice cream to balance the sweetness would have made one of them amazing. The service was wonderful – our drinks were filled up whenever they got low. The room is beautiful but it needs a good dusting. The price seemed high for what we got. It’s a good small, local place to eat if you want to try it out.
… moreJason Hoch
First and foremost, I have to applaud the service provided by our server Brandon! He was absolutely phenomenal and probably the best server I’ve had anywhere. His pacing was perfect between drinks, orders, and our food coming out. His efforts to find drinks to is to be applauded. He corrected a very minor issue with an app and that was the worst we came across.
The atmosphere was great and mirrored that of a cigar bar with comfortable leather seats, a great view of Lake Seneca, and a fire place.
Would absolutely return!
… moreBrianna MacMahon
Absolutely delicious food with generous portions. The dessert tray is fantastic, and the ambience is unbeatable. Very lovely and attentive staff. Highly recommend for anyone looking for great sandwiches and burgers!
… moreTodd Becker
We had calamari, Seafood chowder and crab cake sandwich.
… moreRichard Chu
Food was mediocre. We did go near the end of the night, but the food did not taste good and almost seemed rushed to put together, ironically it took a while to get our food. A few of the options on the menu were not available. The servers were nice but didn’t seem to attentive considering there wasnt many people eating at the time. O will definitely have to try this place again earlier in the day to give it a second chance.
… moretj laflamme
Great atmosphere, friendly staff, and really solid food. Stonecutters Tavern has that perfect balance of relaxed and welcoming while still feeling like a place you want to come back to. Definitely a spot worth stopping at if you’re in the area.
… morePeter Lupkowski
Colby worked hard to serve all of his tables and we were impressed with the food and atmosphere. The turkey, burger, and onion soup were wonderful and the themed drinks for St Patrick’s Weekend were fun. Walk in only stop a little early.
… moreNeil Clarke
Great views of the lake and the food was really good. Seafood chowder very good and creamy and the Cuban had a little extra kick from the stone ground mustard and the spicy Capicola.
… more