Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Stoltzfus BBQ & Fresh Poultry | Reserve Your Poultry For The Holidays
Since 1978, Stoltzfus BBQ & Fresh Poultry has been dedicated to bringing the highest quality poultry products to our customers at Booths Corner. We carry a …
Stoltzfus BBQ at Columbus farmers market review – Facebook
The Amish make this bbq and this is one of the best BBQ places in NJ. I go there atleast once a month. Portions and food are great. There …
Stoltzfus BBQ | Cozy Local Spot for Hearty Barbecue in Columbus, NJ
Walking into Stoltzfus BBQ feels like stepping into a welcoming corner of Columbus where tradition and comfort mingle effortlessly. Nestled inside the Amish …
Reviews
W N
Inside of the Amish & Columbus Farmer’s Market. A savory tender brisket with side of sweet corn On the salty side but sweet BBQ sauce balances it out.
… moreJoe Caraballo
Nestled inside the Amish building of the Columbus Flea Market, the ever present 10 minute line is testament to the quality and quantity of food you’ll get. We ordered the chicken and ribs platter for $12 and shared. The mashed potatoes were smooth as silk, the Mac and cheese better than anything I can make at home, and the ribs in a word, sublime. Served cafeteria style the staff is warm and friendly. You can also order take out to go, the couple next to us was ordering enough to feed a regiment. It’s in the sticks but totally worth the trip for the food alone.
… moreBecky Clark
Affordable, tasty place to grab a quick bite to eat. We got the brisket sandwich with soup. It came with potato chips as well. The slice of brisket was delicious, although too large to be eaten as a sandwich. It melted in your mouth, but had a lot of excess fat. Service was fast and pleasant. There was a lot of tables open for seating. For the price, I would definitely return.
… moreShadaun Littlepage
Everything was delicious! There was so much to select from. I chose to get a BBQ wing platter with 2 sides which were Mac and cheese and roasted potatoes. The mac and cheese was just ok but I didn’t expect it to be so much, it wasn’t as cheesy it just takes like noodles with creamy cheese sauce and very wet in texture, but it was edible but I probably wouldn’t get it again. The roasted potatoes were very good, exactly how it sounds. I also picked, a kielbasa, which was very good. A smoked turkey leg, delicious and juicy. A side of green beans, just tasted steamed or boiled a bit with maybe butter in it but it was just ok in my opinion, I liked the texture not the flavor as it wasn’t much to it, just basic green beans. I also, picked a side order of wings, which I received the bbq and the plain smoked wings and my family and I enjoyed them, they were cooked just right and very juicy and the BBQ wings had a good smoky BBQ taste. That I would try again. But yhe lady who served me was very nice, friendly and professional, she was very helpful and patient as I really was amazed with such a huge selection. Everything was hot and fresh and they also gave me a large quantity. It was enough for I bought but lasted for 2 nights dinner. I also, got their fresh homemade Lemonade in a half gallon, that was delicious as well! I will definitely be back again! ❤️
… moreRiah L
Everything was super good and fresh. The mashed potatoes were outstanding. There’s always a long line but it moves pretty quickly. Highly recommend.
… moreJim H
We visited this ice cream shop recently, and while my wife was placing our order, I noticed several serious sanitation concerns:
The server used napkins that had been left on the counter for previous customers to handle the ice cream cone.
The ice cream scooper was being stored in an all-purpose sink instead of in a clean, designated container, which can easily contaminate the utensil.
When switching between flavors, the scooper was rinsed with water by hand, and the employee’s wet hand dripped directly over the ice cream while serving.
These practices raise major food safety concerns. I strongly urge management to take sanitation and handling practices more seriously to protect customers’ health. Regardless of tradition or background, proper food safety standards must be followed to prevent someone from getting sick.
… moreThe server used napkins that had been left on the counter for previous customers to handle the ice cream cone.
The ice cream scooper was being stored in an all-purpose sink instead of in a clean, designated container, which can easily contaminate the utensil.
When switching between flavors, the scooper was rinsed with water by hand, and the employee’s wet hand dripped directly over the ice cream while serving.
These practices raise major food safety concerns. I strongly urge management to take sanitation and handling practices more seriously to protect customers’ health. Regardless of tradition or background, proper food safety standards must be followed to prevent someone from getting sick.
Stephanie
Great food!! The rotisserie chicken was fresh and moist…the wings were so good!! My kids loved it!! Mac & cheese is also good, mashed potatoes were surprisingly the best restaurant mashed potatoes I’ve ever had!! Oh and don’t forget to pick up their half gallon of lemonade!!! Its the best!!
The service was phenomenal that’s honestly what made our trip the men and women are so hard-working and so polite!
… moreThe service was phenomenal that’s honestly what made our trip the men and women are so hard-working and so polite!
Charles
Clean location. Not as friendly as we hoped, considering this was time buying from Stoltzfus. We’ve purchased and eaten from others in the Amish Section and had better experiences. Since we were there for food, I must say the food was good to very good. Their mac&cheese was good but not as flavorful as I prefer for my palette. When speaking with a family member afterward, the family member said the same thing even before we mentioned anything about their mac & cheese. And their pricing is fair. I would go to this location again.
… moreKeira Brown
Just stopped here with my boyfriend. Prices were very reasonable for the quality of food. I got the BBQ chicken leg+thigh combo with Mac and cheese and roasted potatoes. I do recommend asking for some BBQ sauce on the side for the chicken. The Mac and Cheese was fire, just needed a little salt for my taste. THE ROASTED POTATOES THOUGH…OMG. I don’t know what the hell they did to those potatoes, but they were amazing. They were just plain little potatoes but had so much flavor. The ribs were fall off the bone and so tasty. I will 100% be coming back and trying their other offerings. YUM. (Best part is you know it’s real food. You can taste that homegrown difference.)
… moreConnie Cheung
Food court style, their meal platter came with 1 meat and 2 sides. We were there on Saturday at 12 noon, it already has a long line of customers. We bought rib platter and leg platter (because 1/2 chicken platter was sold out at that point). Both platters were delicious, both meat were juicy and tender. We had Mac & cheese, corns, potatoes and mash potatoes. All 4 sides were taste very good. Their price no one can beat it, before tax, rib platter was $8.75, leg platter was $5.5. Highly recommend.
… more