Tyler
We stumbled in here after driving from out of town to find that the Knuckleheads Kafe was closed. Our spirits low and our stomachs growling we ordered our taco salads and double pepperoni with extra cheese. Much to your delight the pizza was brought out to us. While the taco salad may not look fancy it is downright tasty, the kids thoroughly enjoyed them. The pizza? Oh yes, now that was the high point of the night. I have over my years ordered many pizzas from new places, and have a standard rule that all next places must be able to make a good double-pepperoni extra cheese. My friends, let me tell you, that was some damn good pizza. Easily top 5 lifetime. The pepperoni has flavor, and the cheese is thick like good mozzarella should be. We will absolutely be back and will be willing to drive 30 minutes for more of that tasty food.
… moreAether “Winnie!” M.
I’ve personally never been inside of Snyder’s until today and I can confidently say I will be returning for more. My friends and I all got the all you can eat buffet and all only paid $10-$11. All the food was hot and it was even better fresh. The man working the counter was very patient as we figured things out and kind through the entire transaction, amazing customer service. With the buffet we were even lucky enough to request certain pizzas and they were all out in incredibly good time compared to most pizza shops. The atmosphere is very welcoming and cozy, reminiscent of diner culture that I personally miss seeing. 10/10 for everyone thats interested in coming.
… moreMadison Pisarski
I love the pizza, it is amazing. So good that I drive 30 minutes to get it. Great price and quality food. Now onto the problem. Every time I come in, the buffet is empty. Usually I’m kindly told that they can make any pizza and it will take some time. I’m always happy to wait since it’s delicious when it’s hot and fresh. Today, 10/19, I came in to do the lunch deal and was told that they have nothing for the buffet, I asked if they can make a pepperoni and I’m willing to wait. The middle aged man at the counter acted visibly annoyed and asked if my girlfriend was going to do it as well. I wasn’t ordering for her, I was ordering for myself. Terrible customer service. I will not be coming back. ↔️
… moreJosh Schmidlin
Was camping at Mary Jane Thurston State Park so I figured I’d walk over and try a pizza. Pretty good pizza. When I come back to Mary Jane. I’ll make sure to come back
… moreSadie Seibert
We ordered pizza, breadsticks and a sub, the pizza & sub was okay, but the breadsticks weren’t even cooked all the way. We will not be coming back. Highly recommend going somewhere else, where they actually cook the food.
… moreGarrett Meade (G)
Pizza buffet. All day.
Proof of God’s love
Best days for buffet are Thursday – Sunday.
If no one is there they let you request a pizza with whatever you want on it then put it on the buffet. $9 buffet doesn’t include soda.
Pic is ranch/garlic sauce w/pepperoni and jalapenos
… moreLinda H
Theire food is good and they always have gluten free crust available. I love that they don’t upcharge that. The staff have always been nice.
… moreMolly Mackner
This was our first time visiting Snyder’s Pizza. I am incredibly impressed with this place! We ordered pizza the other day to take out on the boat with us. The service was exceptional, and the employees were phenomenal! When I picked up our order, the weight of the box & aroma wafting out hinted at a delicious dinner. With just one bite I was in love. It was one of the BEST pizzas I have ever eaten.
… moreCortnie
Perfect, inexpensive small town feel pizza buffet! $20: 2 for the buffet, 2 pops, and a water. He even asked if we had a request and made us a white cheese chicken and bacon, delicious!! That white sauce is so good. The breadsticks are good as we’re the other pizza slices they had up there. A must stop while in Grand Rapids
… moreA C
We ordered 2 hot buttered beef to go. They were very busy and understaffed. We were told hopefully about 30 minutes. The kid behind the counter said he would call when our subs went in the oven. 45 minutes later, still no call so we walked back to check. We were told they were out of beef, so we ordered a club instead with extra bacon to replace the beef. What we received was 1 piece of beef and 1 piece of ham with some cheese and lettuce. No turkey and no bacon. The sub was basically just bread. I understand that they were busy but we waited an hour for a garbage sandwich. We will never go back.
… more