Social Profile: 
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: Inside Pandora’s Pie Pizza, 130 N Williamson Ave, Elon, NC 27244
Phone: (336) 270-3800
Website: http://www.smittysicecream.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Smitty’s Homemade Ice Cream | Ice Cream Shop in Alamance County
Over 100 of them! Check out our various Flavors below & come visit us to find our occasional surprises at 3 Alamance County, NC Locations of Elon , Graham & …
Smitty’s Homemade Ice Cream (@SmittysHomemadeIceCream)
Smitty’s Homemade Icecream is now hiring at all our 3 locations!! Graham, Burlington and Elon Must be 17 years and older. Must be able to work weekdays and …
Smitty’s Homemade Ice Cream (@smittyshomemadeicecream)
Smitty Homemade Ice cream is hiring at all our 3 locations! Graham, Burlington and Elon Must be 17 years and older. Flexible hours Good pay with tip Must work …
Reviews
Jordan Kirkpatrick
This Elon location is also a part of the Pandora’s Pies next door. It has a nice section inside. It’s good ice cream. I went for the Cookie monster ice cream as it is a limited time flavor. Meaning it’s only available randomly. It is delicious. It’s blue & contains Oreos and soft crushed cookie pieces. I placed it inside a waffle cone which they make themselves. I wish I had gotten a large instead of the small and the small was 2.5 scoops which was a pretty good size. I will be back when the Cookie Monster ice cream returns, hopefully soon with a large scoop! ✨
… moreTony Gashi
Ice cream was ok. Not a lot of choices, but for a quick fix it is a great place to
… moreMiranda Eisen
We haven’t had Smittys in years and decided to give them a try again today. The prices were shocking $8 for a milkshake that was maybe 16oz and $7 for 2 small scoops of ice cream in a cup. The milkshake tasted like just milk it had 0 flavor and was very watery and the ice cream was just so bland. Hate to say that we were very unimpressed and the quality didn’t line up with the price or service.
… moreLuke S
We were excited to try a new place on 7/1124 and they advertised homemade ice cream. Ice cream was decent. The young lady who served us could not of been less interested in working or helping if she tried. She seemed like she definitely didn’t want to be there.
Employees need to remember the business they represent was started by someone with a dream!
… moreEmployees need to remember the business they represent was started by someone with a dream!
Megan Brouillard
Came just for ice cream. Found it odd to walk in and see a bar right in front of me and smell pizza while I’m eating ice cream. Wish they had more sorbet options (only had 1), kids enjoyed theirs too. Nice area outside to eat as well (still smell pizza though).
… moreKen Davis
Ice cream is always good however there was no vanilla which I found odd!! Also found out from a former colleague that when the new owner took over recently thst he he cancelled all gift cards that people already had making them null and void, they vowed to never go back, this is just wrong and certainly changes my opinion of the new owner
… moreSheneil Baez
It was a beautiful young lady behind the counter today that had ok customer service. We walked in as she was sitting behind the counter, some other employees made eye contact but didn’t welcome us verbally to the establishment. Upon ordering, I noticed the young lady was adjusting her shorts, touching her legs and then handling utensils and touching the waffle cone to see if it was ready. That was a huge turnoff. I’d love to coach businesses in the area on customer service and things they could improve to boost sales. The ice cream was good, but it didn’t have what we came for which is showing on their menu. They were out of many items or no longer sold them…. Would I recommend, maybe. If you’re in the area and there’s NO place else to get ice cream and sit outside to eat it and enjoy the elements.
… moreBrad H
A local creamery, the ice cream quality is great. This location sits inside a pizza place and off to the side. The ice cream and waffle bowls are excellent!
… moreBrian Ewbank
Awesome local ice cream in a pizza joint. Where can you go wrong? Always a great summer treat when campus is calmer. Recently found out that my son loves their ice cream. Definitely looking to get back soon.
… moreJulia Tatum
I had heard that Smitty’s was a great place to get ice cream so we drove from Railiegh after a meeting just to have ice cream. We looked on Google and it said they closed at 11:00pm and we got there around 9:55. There were people in the parlor and lots of workers. The young girl behind the register was pretty rude and short. The mop bucket was up next to the ice cream and filthy. We went to sit down and another lady came to us and said we closed at 10:00pm. I explained we had come from Raleigh to get ice cream and online and on the door it said 11:00pm. She stated that was when school was in sessions. She also told us there was plenty of seats outside. These two ladies seemed very aggravated we were there and the young girl said she had to count the register again and seemed very ticked off. I am very disappointed. You need to change your hours online and the door during summer hours and of you haven’t locked the door you are still open and need to smile and be courteous. Some attitudes need to be adjusted.
… more