Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 217 E Michigan Ave, Paw Paw, MI 49079
Phone: (269) 415-0881
Website: https://slysseafoodco.com/
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Sly’s Seafood & Co.
Sly’s Seafood & Co. 217 E Michigan Ave Paw Paw, MI 49079. (269) 415-0881. Copyright © 2026 Sly’s Seafood & Co. – All Rights Reserved. Powered by. This website …
Sly’s Seafood & Co. | Paw Paw MI – Facebook
Make your reservations on our website for Valentine’s Day!!! https://slysseafoodco.com or call during hours (269) 415-0881 ❣️✨.
Sly’s Seafood & Co. (@slysseafoodco) – Instagram
Fine dining focused on fresh seafood with seasonal locally grown produce. Now serving Paw Paw Brewing Co. Premium Handcrafted Spirits!
Reviews
flyfishguy
Little pricy for a dinner date with a couple drinks .
We got the build your own seafood boil and we were not disappointed. Good amount of crab legs and shrimp , the andouille sausage they use was delicious. The girls working the dining area were very nice and personable. Specialty drinks were nicely done and delicious.
We were in town for a concert, the place is very small and reservations are probably a must here .
Like I said it was a bit expensive but we definitely dint feel like we got ripped off , it was high quality and delicious. We will probably make this a regular dinner when we come back for more concerts.
… moreWe got the build your own seafood boil and we were not disappointed. Good amount of crab legs and shrimp , the andouille sausage they use was delicious. The girls working the dining area were very nice and personable. Specialty drinks were nicely done and delicious.
We were in town for a concert, the place is very small and reservations are probably a must here .
Like I said it was a bit expensive but we definitely dint feel like we got ripped off , it was high quality and delicious. We will probably make this a regular dinner when we come back for more concerts.
Kim Sleezer
We have been to Sly’s multiple times. Each time has been better than the previous time. The food is delish. Anne Marie and Kristen are excellent servers. Chef Tyler keeps creating masterpiece dishes. Great specials and cocktails. Their quality food is reasonably priced. We highly recommend.
… moreCreative Catering Services
Outstanding! Everything I have tried has been delicious! But the mushroom toast is everything! Tonightbintried it with the crab cakes and Brussel sprouts! Amazing! My husband can never resist the lobster carbenara. Delicious and classy!
… moreL Wilk
Our second time there and loved it just as much as the first time. Started with shrimp cocktail, raw oysters a nd a new dish of chorizo oysters with a tangy/spicy sauce. For entrees we had lobster carbonara, Cajun pasta, and maple pecan chicken. All were delicious with generous portions. We had to take leftovers home with us. Looking forward to those as well. Anne was our waitress and was friendly, attentive and Awesome!
… moreRobert Crago
We loved the food and the service was good. They don’t server beer.
… moreJeremy
The walleye dinner was to die for. It was so tasty and cooked very well. From the sauce to the rice and the crayfish and crab salad. Absolutely beautiful placement of the food. Dessert was also very amazing and delicious. Service was on point. Great place for seafood/fish.
… moreJeff Long
This was our second time dining at Sly’s, and once again, it did not disappoint. We came to celebrate my mom’s 78th birthday and made a reservation for six. From the moment we walked in, we were warmly greeted and promptly seated at our table.
We started with four appetizers, enjoyed drinks, entrees, and finished off with dessert—and everything was absolutely perfect. Each dish was delicious, and everyone at the table kept commenting on how amazing the food was.
The service was just as impressive. Not once did we have to ask for a drink refill or flag anyone down—the staff was attentive without being intrusive. A special touch that meant a lot: the chef even came out personally to wish my mom a happy birthday!
If you’re looking for a great dining experience where the staff truly seems to enjoy what they do, Sly’s is the place to go. It really is a hidden gem. I promise—you won’t be disappointed.
… moreWe started with four appetizers, enjoyed drinks, entrees, and finished off with dessert—and everything was absolutely perfect. Each dish was delicious, and everyone at the table kept commenting on how amazing the food was.
The service was just as impressive. Not once did we have to ask for a drink refill or flag anyone down—the staff was attentive without being intrusive. A special touch that meant a lot: the chef even came out personally to wish my mom a happy birthday!
If you’re looking for a great dining experience where the staff truly seems to enjoy what they do, Sly’s is the place to go. It really is a hidden gem. I promise—you won’t be disappointed.
Rich Uphues
Sly seafood is excellent. We’ve been here many times and are always impressed. Tonight I had them make me a Manhattan and they brought me a white version which I’ve never had. It was made with white whiskey from Paw Paw Brewery and a few other ingredients I don’t know but it should be on the drink menu for people that don’t like sweet drinks. It was delicious and unique. The new calamari was lightly breaded and tender wit 2 side sauces of cocktail sauce and a remoulade sauce. The whitefish with capers, lemon and butter with broccolini and jasmine rice was delicious and perfectly prepared! The swordfish with Parmesan risotto and broccolini was perfectly prepared, smoky and delicious. The lemon cake was moist and excellent! Well done kitchen and chef. Our waitress and hostess were both very pleasant and accommodating. Our waitress went above and beyond with service. Thank you everyone for making our evening exceptional!
… moreCindy Pyle
We went for lunch on my Birthday. The lobster rolls perfect clam chowder awesome. Jayden our server could not of done a better job.
… moreMatt Kahle
Very thoughtful and delicious menu. We really appreciated all of the attention to detail in the presentation and flavors. We will definitely come back to experience the entire menu!
… more