Social Profile: 
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No delivery
… View more
Hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday (Labor Day) | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–7 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–7 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–7 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–7 PM |
| Saturday | Closed |
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Simply Mae’s Cafe
Situated together at 601 Broad St in the heart of Downtown Story City, Iowa. Just 4 miles off of I-35 at Exit 124 & 1 mile from HWY 69 when turning at …
Cafe Online Ordering – Simply Mae’s Cafe
Simply Mae’s Cafe, 601 Broad Street, Story City, Iowa 515-357-9664 Restaurant in Story City, Comfort Food, locally owned, restaurants near me, …
Simply Mae’s Cafe menu in Story City, Iowa, USA – Sirved
(515) 357-9664 · www.simplymaes.com · 601 Broad St, Story City, IA 50248, USA.
Reviews
Mary J Williams
What a blessing to have found this lovely hometown treasure! Billie Jo has amazing homemade baked goods and menu items to satisfy any food palate. I loved the atmosphere — made me wish I could own a restaurant like this in Minnesota because it was so inviting, relaxing, and welcoming. My friend and I had the chicken salad sandwich with pasta and chips, coffee, and an oatmeal cookie sandwiched between this delectable vanilla cream frosting. Yum, yum, yum. The cookie we ate much later and couldn’t even eat the whole darn thing because it was so filling. But darn, it was so good! I might have to plan another trip to Des Moines so I can stop by Simply Mae’s again and try another one of her simply delicious homemade foods.
… moreDamian Butler-Buccilli
Fantastic, fresh food. Amazing service in a very relaxed and comfortable atmosphere. Good prices. Highly recommend.
… moreSenaca F.
Now this is a surprise. A extremely nice and beautiful mom and pop spot. Very friendly and simply a nice touching place. I love it…
… moreJeremy Polomny
I had the ham and cheesy potato hotdish. I went in for lunch on a cold rainy day. It was the brightest thing I found that day. Delicious food. Welcoming staff. Need to check out if you find yourself in Story City, IA.
… moreT. Cook
This is a beautifully decorated place with staff as nice and sweet as can be. They have many incredible items for the home or cabin for sale. The food is nothing less than excellent, and the prices are very fair. While we were there many customers arrived, some ate in and some carried out . We were just passing through but plan on stopping on our way back. I recommend the open face roast beef with luscious gravy and mashed potatoes accompanied by a side of piping hot corn. Top it off with their wonderful apple pie. 5 out of 5 stars.
… moreLaura Carlson
Fresh and made on site. Faces welcome. Iowa at its best!
… moreKaty Gruber
1st time visit & if we lived closer we would probably become regulars. Greeted with friendly smiles, a small easy lunch menu, fresh iced tea & baked goodies. The club sandwich came with chips & pasta salad. It was all very tasty, large portion & affordable. Thanks ladies!
… moreMardell Christian
I ordered a DELICIOUS Hot Beef Sundae to go! I hope they will carry it all the time, not just during the State Fair time. I also saw some cute tops that I’m going to go back and check out.
… moreMelissa Kepley
Love the food, Love the desserts, Love the owners and staff…I absolutely love I can call an order in and pick up with no wait!! super fast and kind service!
… moreBarb Green
The food is really really delicious! I had chicken salad on a croissant, pasta salad and chips. It was wonderful and I am a picky person!!
… more