Cozy, understated restaurant serving Italian classics & draft beer amid photos & artwork.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1211 Cape Coral Pkwy E, Cape Coral, FL 33904
Phone: (239) 945-7285
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Sicily Trattoria | Cape Coral FL – Facebook
We are still open Monday-Friday 12-9 Saturday 4-9 Closed Sunday … Dee Vicola is at Sicily Trattoria. Oct 17, 2025 . SATURDAY …
Sicily Trattoria: Authentic Italian Dining in Cape Coral
Visit us today or call (239) 945-7285 for reservations! Address: 1211 Cape Coral Pkwy E Cape Coral, FL 33904; Hotline: (239) 945-7285 …
Sicily Trattoria – Chamber of Commerce of Cape Coral
Sicily Trattoria. Member Since 2024. 1211 Cape Coral Pkwy E, Cape Coral, FL, 33904 … In 1986 he moved the family to Cape Coral, taking a job baking for Publix.
Reviews
Craig
I don’t see any responses from customer feedback on any reviews. Thank you for being open on Christmas Eve. The flavor of the entrees were good. The presentation, service, and one recipe are subpar. The eggplant with meat sauce had very little egg plant, mom was very dissapointed. She said there was only a few pieces of eggplant. Eggplant is cheap. Don’t be cheap. All the presentations lack color. See pics. Unispiring and not what I expected for 20+$. Add some color or garnish. HORRIBLE presentation. Service: good but New York style. Stop auctioning off drinks and food. Number your seats so they know where to go. When the server who took the order doesnt know what drink goes where, it’s Poor service. When the food runner doesnt know what dish goes to which person, it’s a system failure. The salad for the entree was iceberg and small, but ok for the entree price. I asked to not have olives and tomatoes, please add extra carrots instead. Salad came with olives and tomatoes and no extra carrots. You can see the size of the calamari. I liked the size and flavor. Again, presentation is junk. Put a lemon edge on at least.
… moreMandy Yeuglowitz
I had a great experience. They were 1 hour until closing and served us unhurried. The atmosphere was still relaxed and the Scicilians and New Yorkers at the bar, who were not overserved, were sharing their exciting stories to one another, at a tone that was not overloud. It was great atmosphere and I really wanted just great pizza. I’ve been to many other pizza places in the Cape and this one has knocked them out of the park for years. Yes, the price point was a little high but if you want great it’s not going to be cheap. They have been in business for many many years and the quality of food has been consistent through the years. I recall them having been off Pine Island Road back in the day and even then they were outstanding. Kudos for standing the test of time. Definitely will be returning.
… moreDan Horowitz
Excellent Italian in Cape Coral. Don’t miss out on the arancini appetizer. Excellent wine list too. Main dishes come with pasta, there is an option to upgrade to fresh pasta.
… moreMatt King
This is the best Italian restaurant in town. I’ve been going for years now and I take everyone there so they can experience it. Never a bad word to be said. The food is amazing. The Sicilian pizza is my favorite. The gnocchi is not far behind. The service is the best. I’d highly recommend trying out Sicily Trattoria.
… moreAnn Law
The food was amazing. The sever was horrible, we werent done spending our money there. The sever came up and asked if everything was okay. Due to his tip that he received. I called to speak to the manager and no one has got back to me. I thought it was every disrespectful to make a comment about a tip asking if he did okay because he wanted more for a tip. When we weren’t done spending money. He showed us the tip as well. I would like for a manger to get back to me.
… moreLevy Montes de Oca
This definitely has to be my favorite Italian place. Their exquisite meals are juicy and delicious, bursting with authentic flavors. Excellent service and a cozy atmosphere to complete the experience. You also have to do yourself a favor and try their pizza.
P.S. The only place I’ve ever had better pizza was in Italy.
… moreP.S. The only place I’ve ever had better pizza was in Italy.
Rhonda Hamrick
I ordered a deluxe pizza and a spaghetti and meatballs to go. Manny took my order and it was done in no time. The food was so good that I wish they were in Ohio! And that is saying something because Ohio has great pizza so much so that I am a pizza snob, lol. Highly recommend!!!!
… moreMike Rosario
We had an amazing dinner experience at Sicily Trattoria! I came here with my wife, our teenage daughter, and our 7-year-old, and everyone left happy and full. The food was outstanding, fresh, flavorful, and perfectly prepared. The service was just as impressive. The staff was attentive and made us feel right at home.
It’s not always easy to find a place that pleases the whole family, but Sicily Trattoria delivered on every level. From start to finish, it was a great experience. Highly recommend this spot if you’re looking for authentic Italian food and excellent service!
… moreIt’s not always easy to find a place that pleases the whole family, but Sicily Trattoria delivered on every level. From start to finish, it was a great experience. Highly recommend this spot if you’re looking for authentic Italian food and excellent service!
Theresa C
We had a lovely dinner. The staff was friendly and we ordered Chicken Marcella and Chicken Parmesan and that one needed more sauce. They have a couple bakery items like cookies and cheesecake and make other items during the week. The soup was pea soup for this day. Atmosphere was bright and very clean. I liked how we could watch mom and son cooking, that was wonderful to see. Go enjoy a nice dinner with this wonderful family. We enjoyed it.
… moreRobert R
First time there. Food was great. Manny was great. A tad loud for my preference but not so loud that I won’t go back. This will be our Cape Italian restaurant.
… more